Plane Troubles [Concluded]

[CaffeinatedKitty]

But if I can't find anything wrong or suspicious about what everyone has said, who would be suspicious to me? The people whose comments I haven't analysed; i.e. the people who haven't posted much of merit.

...
if you haven't found anything wrong or suspicious then they're doing it right.
See above comment.

 

[midnightgirl24]

Okay, since I'm in no condition to really write something coherent, I'm going to head to bed. When I get into my computer class tomorrow morning, I will read over the things I missed and will make a longer post with my vote. I will be able to do this because I am ahead in the class.

 

[Swate]

...
if you haven't found anything wrong or suspicious then they're doing it right.
See above comment.

But to to quote Sherlock Holmes, "Once you have eliminated all impossibilities, whatever remains, however improbable, is the truth."

I mean, other than me just not reading through things with enough viscosity (or whatever the word is), what other explanation is there for who is Mafia?

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

But to to quote Sherlock Holmes, "Once you have eliminated all impossibilities, whatever remains, however improbable, is the truth."

I mean, other than me just not reading through things with enough viscosity (or whatever the word is), what other explanation is there for who is Mafia?

Technically, just because you don't see them saying anything suspicious, it doesn't mean they're innocent. It could mean that they're really good at hiding.
But since it's really late and I need sleep, I'll be going offline for now o/

 

[Sephhh]

Technically, just because you don't see them saying anything suspicious, it doesn't mean they're innocent. It could mean that they're really good at hiding.
But since it's really late and I need sleep, I'll be going offline for now o/

I think you guys are on the same boat, but just misunderstanding each other.. xD

 

[Notme]

Hmm... Game stalled a little

 

[Mia]

Alright after reading through all this it seems we have not progressed at all, all we have merely done is talk a bit about this and a hit about that so forth. We need to work together to figure something out because right now we are getting no where. (Also thought I did this ages ago but it must not have posted correctly) I'd like to get some more talking done, Unvote raxo

 

[Notme]

Hmm... who is least active here? maybe they are mafia in hiding?

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

OH MY GOSH
How many times must I say it?? Just because a person is quiet doesn't mean they're hiding something!
Now, I have school, be back in about 8 hours

 

[Sephhh]

OH MY GOSH
How many times must I say it?? Just because a person is quiet doesn't mean they're hiding something!
Now, I have school, be back in about 8 hours

Technically, just because you don't see them saying anything suspicious, it doesn't mean they're innocent. It could mean that they're really good at hiding.

Not saying anything = not innocent

That's what I got from your post. Just probably a mistype though (correct me if I'm wrong). Anyway you must know that if you were Mafia one option to stay out of lynch-zone is to become somehow quiet because less talk = less chances of slipping. Sure, there's work, sleep, school and timezones, of course it's out of our control, but it's still a fact that it's lesser posts - lesser slips.

In this case were dealing with, we're considering all options right now (and we always should). I'l literally tired and I've exhausted what I can say about suspicions and it looks like that most of what's being done right now is stalling and stuff (pardon me I must really be tired right now x)). Someone just please help us get the pace going.

 

[Mia]

Emily got back from her little adventure after having a long think, we have still gotten nowhere and the killers are still lurking. Emily was exhausted and fell asleep quickly hoping she would rest unnoticed.

Going to sleep will check I morning. c:

 

[midnightgirl24]

(Hooray for a legit computer for once! \o/)

From what I have read, there seems to only be two suspicious people (one being Raxo) in my opinion. This leads me to a conflicted vote. Unfortunately the problem we're having is we're not getting anywhere due to lack of evidence for a lynch. Because of it being very early in the game, there won't be a lot for any of us to go on here.

Hmm... Game stalled a little

This is only because of our lack of evidence. (Or someone planned for this to happen to give the Mafia more time.)

Alright after reading through all this it seems we have not progressed at all, all we have merely done is talk a bit about this and a hit about that so forth. We need to work together to figure something out because right now we are getting no where. (Also thought I did this ages ago but it must not have posted correctly) I'd like to get some more talking done,

Unfortunately, talking is still really not getting us nowhere. We're worried because we may end up lynching an innocent passenger or worse, a PR, or we get lucky and lynch a member of the Mafia.

With a lack of evidence, we just kind of have to take the risk, and hope we make the right choice when it comes down to it all. I'm still undecided on my vote because of the conflict I'm having between which of the two stands out as more suspicious.

 

[Notme]

(Hooray for a legit computer for once! \o/)

From what I have read, there seems to only be two suspicious people (one being Raxo) in my opinion. This leads me to a conflicted vote. Unfortunately the problem we're having is we're not getting anywhere due to lack of evidence for a lynch. Because of it being very early in the game, there won't be a lot for any of us to go on here.


This is only because of our lack of evidence. (Or someone planned for this to happen to give the Mafia more time.)



Unfortunately, talking is still really not getting us nowhere. We're worried because we may end up lynching an innocent passenger or worse, a PR, or we get lucky and lynch a member of the Mafia.

With a lack of evidence, we just kind of have to take the risk, and hope we make the right choice when it comes down to it all. I'm still undecided on my vote because of the conflict I'm having between which of the two stands out as more suspicious.

So what is your second suspicion? Maybe you are right with this one, so we can hopefully lynch mafia

 

[midnightgirl24]

So what is your second suspicion? Maybe you are right with this one, so we can hopefully lynch mafia

I'm not ready to say the person until I'm completely sure I have been reading over their posts right now.

 

[Notme]

I'm not ready to say the person until I'm completely sure I have been reading over their posts right now.

Okay

 

[Samlen]

Back and finished rereading everything again. If you read that, I pointed out that raxo did almost nothing in his defense, yet many people unvoted. I see where people are coming from for unvoting, making a mistake in this would be disastrous and the evidence still isn't as strong as I'd like, which is partially why I haven't voted to lynch him. This little tidbit of fact is why I'll still be suspicious of raxo, even if it won't push me over to vote for him yet. I still can't find any stronger than leads other raxo, but I'll certainly be searching and the more talking we do, the more likely we can find a decent lead.

Before I'm gone for another 7-8 hours, I'm going to point out that here in my post from earlier I point out two large points, one being that raxo still hasn't done much of anything to defend himself and is still our biggest lead with the the other point being that if we do want to find another lead, we need to talk. Not talking is, in some ways, almost as suspicious as raxo here and, in other ways, it is more so since we learn nothing of said person, as others have already pointed out.

 

[Swate]

I'm planning to go through literally all the posts word for word tomorrow (it's midnight atm here, about to go to sleep.) I can't remember who it was, but I once read about this philosopher who simply stated that all seemingly unaswerable questions and problems are due to us being confused by words (i.e. a word is used which has two meanings, you think it means the wrong one, that sort of thing.)

 

[Swate]

Before I'm gone for another 7-8 hours, I'm going to point out that here in my post from earlier I point out two large points, one being that raxo still hasn't done much of anything to defend himself and is still our biggest lead with the the other point being that if we do want to find another lead, we need to talk. Not talking is, in some ways, almost as suspicious as raxo here and, in other ways, it is more so since we learn nothing of said person, as others have already pointed out.

This is why my vote continues to be on him. Until someone else flops and says something something suspicious, my money stays on Raxo. I'm not giving myself any alternative, or we're going to sit here stalematily for a whole week.

 

[midnightgirl24]

This is why my vote continues to be on him. Until someone else flops and says something something suspicious, my money stays on Raxo. I'm not giving myself any alternative, or we're going to sit here stalematily for a whole week.

The only reason I haven't mentioned the other person is because I want to be absolutely sure before I do. I don't want to wrongly accuse them.

 

[Sephhh]

(Hooray for a legit computer for once! \o/)

From what I have read, there seems to only be two suspicious people (one being Raxo) in my opinion. This leads me to a conflicted vote. Unfortunately the problem we're having is we're not getting anywhere due to lack of evidence for a lynch. Because of it being very early in the game, there won't be a lot for any of us to go on here.


This is only because of our lack of evidence. (Or someone planned for this to happen to give the Mafia more time.)



Unfortunately, talking is still really not getting us nowhere. We're worried because we may end up lynching an innocent passenger or worse, a PR, or we get lucky and lynch a member of the Mafia.

With a lack of evidence, we just kind of have to take the risk, and hope we make the right choice when it comes down to it all. I'm still undecided on my vote because of the conflict I'm having between which of the two stands out as more suspicious.

I'm glad you finally made that long post you have long been telling us you're gonna do . For your worries, I have a good idea who the doctor and the cop is already, so I think I can eliminate that I guess, but for the passenger, well I only have 1 person for sure who is one. I hope you get what you want to get soon though!

 

[midnightgirl24]

I will make a coherent response when I'm back on my computer and not on my phone! \o/

 

[Pikmon2]

Is there a way we can like pull straws or something, that seems to be the only way at the moment, haha.

After reading some more, I'm being a bit more swayed towards Raxo again, but not 100% sure yet.

 

[midnightgirl24]

Is there a way we can like pull straws or something, that seems to be the only way at the moment, haha.

After reading some more, I'm being a bit more swayed towards Raxo again, but not 100% sure yet.

Well really there's nobody else completely suspicious to pull straws with.

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

Technically, just because you don't see them saying anything suspicious, it doesn't mean they're innocent. It could mean that they're really good at hiding.

Not saying anything = not innocent

That's what I got from your post. Just probably a mistype though (correct me if I'm wrong). Anyway you must know that if you were Mafia one option to stay out of lynch-zone is to become somehow quiet because less talk = less chances of slipping. Sure, there's work, sleep, school and timezones, of course it's out of our control, but it's still a fact that it's lesser posts - lesser slips.

In this case were dealing with, we're considering all options right now (and we always should). I'l literally tired and I've exhausted what I can say about suspicions and it looks like that most of what's being done right now is stalling and stuff (pardon me I must really be tired right now x)). Someone just please help us get the pace going.

tbh I'm not even sure what I'm saying any more
I was talking about two different groups- the first quote for quiet people and the second for more talkative. People seem to be accusing them at different times... And not to mention I made the first post(for quiet) when I'd just woken up and now that I look at it I wish I'd thought it over -.-' it's horribly cranky and just... Ugh.

 

[Mia]

This is why my vote continues to be on him. Until someone else flops and says something something suspicious, my money stays on Raxo. I'm not giving myself any alternative, or we're going to sit here stalematily for a whole week.

I agree, we cannot sit here for a week with no progress. Maybe if we start making accusations on other people something might spill? I don't know but we aren't getting anywhere with this.