Republic - Completed

Faliara

Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2012
Messages
2,588
Reaction score
3,080
I don't really know what to think about Oog. On one hand, I'm really tempted to consider him suspicious- mainly because he's saying that Notty should be kept alive, so I figure that it might just be bias on my part. But also...

He keeps saying 'but of course I could be wrong about my suspicions, all my suspicions this game have been wrong so far', on top of his defense of certain people. Under the assumption that Ooglie is mafia, it's like he thinks that Notty will die and be revealed as scum but feels an obligation to at least try to save her, so he wants to dismiss any connection he might have with Notty in case that happens so he doesn't get lynched too.

The thing is, that could just be plain unconfidence on his part. He might just be feeling that he's utterly useless. God knows how many times I posted 'I could be wrong' or 'I'm the useless one here, so I could just be spouting nonsense' in the past, and I almost used that in the first paragraph of this post before I realized how utterly hypocritical that is of me. With that said, in spite of my complete distrust of Notty extending to Oog for defending her, I can easily see myself in his place as a town member who doesn't know any better.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
I don't really know what to think about Oog. On one hand, I'm really tempted to consider him suspicious- mainly because he's saying that Notty should be kept alive, so I figure that it might just be bias on my part. But also...

He keeps saying 'but of course I could be wrong about my suspicions, all my suspicions this game have been wrong so far', on top of his defense of certain people. Under the assumption that Ooglie is mafia, it's like he thinks that Notty will die and be revealed as scum but feels an obligation to at least try to save her, so he wants to dismiss any connection he might have with Notty in case that happens so he doesn't get lynched too.

The thing is, that could just be plain unconfidence on his part. He might just be feeling that he's utterly useless. God knows how many times I posted 'I could be wrong' or 'I'm the useless one here, so I could just be spouting nonsense' in the past, and I almost used that in the first paragraph of this post before I realized how utterly hypocritical that is of me. With that said, in spite of my complete distrust of Notty extending to Oog for defending her, I can easily see myself in his place as a town member who doesn't know any better.
Oog is also uncc Watcher right now, though I guess it's possible he's the Mafia rolecop and visited Ltin last night and took his role
 

TheWeakGuy48_

Geezuslike
Donor
Mafia Host
Joined
Dec 31, 2012
Messages
218
Reaction score
785
I find it REALLY FUNNY how the people who I REALLY suspect claimed Citizen (Danni+Foggy+Rune+Sploorky(don't remember if foggy claimed it or not but he's still suspicious)). It becomes even more funny when I am actually a Citizen (again). Anyway I'm just gonna say that since this thread is filled with mafia that don't want an autocrazy, and we actually go democracy, then it is out of the question to lynch Notty. We will elect Danni with 3 proven townies and during the night you must subpoena Rune and Danni must be one of the representatives.

Elect: Faliara, Enderfive, Aqua and Danni12212
 

LISTINGS09

Ain't afraid of no ghost
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
366
Reaction score
606
I find it REALLY FUNNY how the people who I REALLY suspect claimed Citizen (Danni+Foggy+Rune+Sploorky(don't remember if foggy claimed it or not but he's still suspicious)). It becomes even more funny when I am actually a Citizen (again). Anyway I'm just gonna say that since this thread is filled with mafia that don't want an autocrazy, and we actually go democracy, then it is out of the question to lynch Notty. We will elect Danni with 3 proven townies and during the night you must subpoena Rune and Danni must be one of the representatives.
We have to go demo to have a chance of success and sub anyone suspicious otherwise it's just finger pointing and 'claims' in which most people (looking at you inf) in mafia are going citizen. We've needed demo from the start but the council flaked and it cost us dearly.
 

LISTINGS09

Ain't afraid of no ghost
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
366
Reaction score
606
I don't really know what to think about Oog. On one hand, I'm really tempted to consider him suspicious- mainly because he's saying that Notty should be kept alive, so I figure that it might just be bias on my part. But also...
Read back over Oogs stuff and look at how they interact with Notty/Inf specifically. They are Mafia.

We should be able identify all but one of the Mafia after this night, if there's enough of us left.
 

Aqua

Does anybody remember laughter?
Mafia Host
Joined
Mar 29, 2015
Messages
640
Reaction score
2,808
Mfw if we mislynch we lose and people are now just casually throwing suspicious people into the lynch when there is a confirmed antitown.

Like you do realise if we fuck up the lynch and/or the dictator nightkill and notty kills ender as she promises we will actually lose the game right?

Anybody who is trying to casually lynch whoever they "deem" suspicious and silently remove me from the council either has their head up their arse or is definitely scum.

Actually look at the situation we're in people and make up your minds. Remember tavern arcana where notty survived for 3 days longer than she should have because sheep people believed her lies?

This was not a calculated play, if it wasn't for wim's redardicity (yeah Velzerat ya big dumb dumb) notty would have been inches away from being lynched. She lucked out on that front and as a final last attemtp to sink her claws in she started this dumb charade and kept repeating herself over and over until you guys started to cave and believe her.

I mean TheWeakGuy48_ what has notty said to convince you? All she's done is just repeat herself in a joking friendly way whilst giving subtle threats like some sort of comic book villian and you've straight up given in?

I don't get it.
 

TheWeakGuy48_

Geezuslike
Donor
Mafia Host
Joined
Dec 31, 2012
Messages
218
Reaction score
785
I mean TheWeakGuy48_ what has notty said to convince you? All she's done is just repeat herself in a joking friendly way whilst giving subtle threats like some sort of comic book villian and you've straight up given in?
BECAUSE NOTTY IS LITERALLY THE BIGGEST THREAT TO THE MAFIA, JESUS AQUA
 

TheWeakGuy48_

Geezuslike
Donor
Mafia Host
Joined
Dec 31, 2012
Messages
218
Reaction score
785
There is zero reason why it would be 2. You don't need to make assumptions like this since the game is mechanically consistent.
I asked for clarification because Notty posted this

Name me 1 difference between a council of 4 and one of 3. Either way you can only put in 1 suspicious person since 2 can force autocracy
 
Top