Retaking Rochester (Concluded)

[Pikmon2]

Who is most suspicious now? Eh, I guess myusername22 at the moment, for the rash decision making. I understand wanting to move forward quickly, but still.
Who is least suspicious? brownlee because I feel bad for him (and also I see everyone about on the same level of suspiciousness so far.)

 

[erik5456]

Who is most suspicious now?

I have a strong suspicion I am the most suspicious because my vote on midnightgirl probably looks uncalled for.
Who is least suspicious?
tbh erik because he's given more read than anyone (this could also be a bad thing though) TRUST NO ONE

also the vote on midnight is because it feels like she's not even making an attempt at making progress if we all just say "nothing happened" it's going to keep running that way until something happens or we no-lynch. @midnightgirl24 I want to know why you aren't making an attempt at contributing but are instead just saying eh, nothing happened so we can do nothing.

I must agree with myusername in this case that if no clarification is given, then midnightgirl it will seem extremely suspicious.

 

[midnightgirl24]

Who is most suspicious now?

I have a strong suspicion I am the most suspicious because my vote on midnightgirl probably looks uncalled for.
Who is least suspicious?
tbh erik because he's given more read than anyone (this could also be a bad thing though) TRUST NO ONE

also the vote on midnight is because it feels like she's not even making an attempt at making progress if we all just say "nothing happened" it's going to keep running that way until something happens or we no-lynch. @midnightgirl24 I want to know why you aren't making an attempt at contributing but are instead just saying eh, nothing happened so we can do nothing.

Well one, I'm extremely tired (and irritated) and not completely sure on anything. I'm not going to jump to a conclusion without evidence. And this is my day off and I'm seriously busy so I can't spend all my time reading this right now.

 

[myusername22]

Well one, I'm extremely tired (and irritated) and not completely sure on anything. I'm not going to jump to a conclusion without evidence. And this is my day off and I'm seriously busy so I can't spend all my time reading this right now.

Thank you, I apologize for the accusations but i needed to call someone out on something to test reactions, To which i must say I really need to call an F.O.S. on erik now

@erik5456 while it is completely true midnight wasn't contributing a lot Nobody was. why would you be so quick to agree with me? to be honest what I did should have looked scummy

 

[midnightgirl24]

Thank you, I apologize for the accusations but i needed to call someone out on something to test reactions, To which i must say I really need to call an F.O.S. on erik now

@erik5456 while it is completely true midnight wasn't contributing a lot Nobody was. why would you be so quick to agree with me? to be honest what I did should have looked scummy

It's fine, but I'm just not going to say much today until I finish what I'm doing and I actually get to sleep tonight ;_;

 

[erik5456]

@myusername22 you did look scummy but i thought that midnight was also very suspicious after what you had pointed out. All the while, i am sorry if i made ur current burden worse in any way midnight and i hope ur day goes better.
Also, username why do you seem to want to put the blame onto someone so quickly? first you try put major suspicion onto midnight and then (right after you called me least suspicious) you try to pin suspicion onto me. Care to explain please?

 

[erik5456]

also for clarification whats an F.O.S.?

 

[Pikmon2]

Fire on sight, I think. I'm not too sure.

 

[myusername22]

also for clarification whats an F.O.S.?

it means finger of suspicion, It's a way of saying hey this is really suspicious you guys should take this into serious consideration without yet pushing a vote or a bandwagon on the person.


to be honest at this point with this game set-up I'm not really sure how much that helps me, this game is so confusing both sides could be considered "scum" I'm not going to state which side I'm trying to eliminate but hopefully this helps my teammates more than my enemies

 

[chicken23456789]

Who are the most suspicious: To me the people who aren't talking are the most suspicious. :)

 

[Mia]

Who are the most suspicious: To me the people who aren't talking are the most suspicious. :)

I don't think your allowed to reply to this thread as your not in the game, make sure to sign up next time if you want to participate :3

We don't have much to go off at the moment and I just woke up so Im just going to wait a bit and see what happens.

 

[Enderfive]

I don't think your allowed to reply to this thread as your not in the game, make sure to sign up next time if you want to participate :3

We don't have much to go off at the moment and I just woke up so Im just going to wait a bit and see what happens.

I am not in the game, but just gonna pop in and point this out to you:

Note:
chicken23456789 has taken roboboy77's place.

 

[Mia]

Oh ok sorry it was 6am didn't see that he had I just went off the living list x3

 

[erik5456]

Who are the most suspicious: To me the people who aren't talking are the most suspicious. :)

Remember for different timezones people who aren't currently talking could be asleep or doing other things like jivvi if I'm not wrong

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

Who is most suspicious now?
Myusername, because of his completely uncalled for vote on mid. She was correct in that nothing had happened to throw suspicion on anyone, and that's no reason for her to be voted for.
Who is least suspicious?
I'm probably a bit biased because I survived the last game with her, but midnightgirl. I just don't see any reason to suspect her.

Now that I've read through this completely, it might actually be a bit tougher than last game due to.. Well, just the nature of it. I'd like to kind of wait and see who does what before I form a more solid opinion than those at the top of my post.

 

[Sephhh]

I'm actually confused myself now since that myuser mentioned it too. Confusion -> Questions -> Answers. To help everyone understand the game more then it would be helpful to answer these. You may or may not post your answer. Remember that the Mafia is leading right now in terms of number.

If you were part of the Mafia, how would one be considered a scum?

same goes to the other side:

If you were part of the Town where you are not part of a majority, how would one be considered a scum?

 

[Lee_scar]

I'm really wanting to look at what people are saying and just watch for now, someone has to slip up sometime.

Though with all the allegations and suspicion going around midnight sure did immediately respond and fight instead of letting it roll off the shoulder, being a single vote and all.

 

[myusername22]

Shoot I forgot to do this earlier.


[Bold] unvote [\bold]

 

[myusername22]

Who is most suspicious now?
Myusername, because of his completely uncalled for vote on mid. She was correct in that nothing had happened to throw suspicion on anyone, and that's no reason for her to be voted for.
Who is least suspicious?
I'm probably a bit biased because I survived the last game with her, but midnightgirl. I just don't see any reason to suspect her.

Now that I've read through this completely, it might actually be a bit tougher than last game due to.. Well, just the nature of it. I'd like to kind of wait and see who does what before I form a more solid opinion than those at the top of my post.

I realize it doesn't help that I forgot to change my vote until right now. I'm sorry it was a legitimate mistake.

However, have you read any of the more recent posts? As a voting reason that would make me look pretty scummy like an uncalled for vote on midnight should. The reason behind the vote was to test the reactions of others which is why I dropped the accusations as soon as Erik agreed with me. As I've stated the reasons against mid I listed were absolutely uncalled for in terms of reasoning so it seems pretty odd Erik would just jump aboard and agree with me doesn't it? My reason to accuse midnight was a scum trap, but he had absolutely no reason to jump aboard and possibly encourage/start a bandwagon/random lynch. The idea that Erik wouldn't even come off slightly skeptical while agreeing with me tells me he probably isn't against lynching without reason and therefore is one of the scummiest players in the game. I don't know about you but to me that gives me a major fos on Erik.

 

[erik5456]

I realize it doesn't help that I forgot to change my vote until right now. I'm sorry it was a legitimate mistake.

However, have you read any of the more recent posts? As a voting reason that would make me look pretty scummy like an uncalled for vote on midnight should. The reason behind the vote was to test the reactions of others which is why I dropped the accusations as soon as Erik agreed with me. As I've stated the reasons against mid I listed were absolutely uncalled for in terms of reasoning so it seems pretty odd Erik would just jump aboard and agree with me doesn't it? My reason to accuse midnight was a scum trap, but he had absolutely no reason to jump aboard and possibly encourage/start a bandwagon/random lynch. The idea that Erik wouldn't even come off slightly skeptical while agreeing with me tells me he probably isn't against lynching without reason and therefore is one of the scummiest players in the game. I don't know about you but to me that gives me a major fos on Erik.

You know username the thing is I didn't just immediately bandwagon, I had simply agreed with you that it would seem suspicious it's not like I had just added a vote onto midnight immediately. Besides if u were doing a scum trap then why not leave it a bit more? It would have simply helped you to further know who was acting scummy or notice a slip up in anyone for that matter.

Hey Also, I understand calling out people and trying to find scummish people but at the same time going as far as being the first to vote it makes me feel as if ur either extremely confident or ur trying to pin it onto one person. First midnight and claiming it was a "scum test" is what I'd call it and then the second you seem to realize she isn't guilty whatsoever so you turn onto me after stating I had seemed less suspicious then all. Besides it hadn't been as if I had just straight said username ur suspicion is 110% great like I've stated I was simply agreeing with ur point made. It's like me saying I loved blueberry pie but that it was sour, you agreeing it was sour and me then claiming you hate blueberry pie, not much sense now is there?Like you I'm just trying to help my allies and keep as much info as possible away from my enemy's but wether I've done so or not is still far from answered. Sorry if I've confused anyone either I must admit my mind is in jumble ATM cuz. 2 projects due tommorow that need most of my attention ;-;

 

[midnightgirl24]

I'm really wanting to look at what people are saying and just watch for now, someone has to slip up sometime.

Though with all the allegations and suspicion going around midnight sure did immediately respond and fight instead of letting it roll off the shoulder, being a single vote and all.

Well I was really irritated and exhausted (still am) at the time and I wasn't going to let me be randomly voted for when I did nothing. Now I'm going to go to sleep soon and try to post something tomorrow.

 

[erik5456]

Well I was really irritated and exhausted (still am) at the time and I wasn't going to let me be randomly voted for when I did nothing. Now I'm going to go to sleep soon and try to post something tomorrow.

^ this anyone would react by trying to defend themselves at a random day 1 lynch except if people knew it was a super friendly joking lynch. If anything she reacted just fine .

 

[midnightgirl24]

^ this anyone would react by trying to defend themselves at a random day 1 lynch except if people knew it was a super friendly joking lynch. If anything she reacted just fine .

I'll be honest, it was a bit cranky. XD I am tired and I'm really cranky when I'm woken up early after a night of little sleep

 

[myusername22]

I know people might be upset like "omg myuser why didn't you claim you were going to run a scum test" but I'd like to point out I couldn't very well run it in advance as for Erik you're still my primary f.o.s. its true you didn't actually input a vote and start a bandwagon in that way but scum tend to try avoiding ending up on the official vote counts this early anyway. That way if things go wrong they don't look like the initiators.

You're defense is that you weren't starting a bandwagon but comments like that can be there to help convince others someone is guilty and to make others feel it might be okay to bandwagon on them.

-continuing in a second post

 

[myusername22]

Also to consider, scum can be very quick to agree with others, that's why you look so suspicious to me at the moment, the post you gave originally didn't felt too much like you were agreeing with me and I can see where the blueberry pie thing comes in now. If there had been a little bit more skepticism in your post then maybe, as far as your comment i should have left the trap open longer, maybe but I'm not very good with these traps and didn't want to let things go too far or people would find me suspicious for randomly attacking midnightgirl,

on a final note: you've had plenty of chances to find me suspicious before I thought you were suspicious. It's generally considered bad gameplay to suspect someone only because they suspected you. I know it's easy to do but we need to try to stray away from that if possible because that's how you get people on the same team going at each others throats while the scum just sit back and watch xD