Retaking Rochester (Concluded)
- Thread starter Jivvi
- Start date
- Status
@Sephhh though the cop and contact have extremely similar abilities it's important to remember they are very different roles. the general idea behind the cop is that it needs to share it's investigations with the town so they can lynch the towns enemies, while the contact is mafia sided the contacts investigations are already considered into the mafias night kills and used in that way. It could even be a hinderance if you knew my investigations as it gives the doctor ideas on who they should protect and generally gives the town ideas on better ways they can make strategies against the mafia.
the reason I was "wrong" was because I lied. I didn't really want to share my investigations so i just picked you and said you were a traitor. I'm pretty sure now you aren't a traitor. In the beginning I was scum telling pretty hard. (I often play aggressively for my side and it can really show)I was reverse scum hunting (town hunting) on day 1 pretty obviously, and I even claimed i was hunting for townies sometime during this game. to compensate for this I tried to look like i was playing both sides simultaneously by throwing around some obvious things that sounded like town Ideas but really weren't meant to be that helpful. You stated observations of me compensating in that way, maybe it was legitimate at the beginning but I think you picked up on my scum tells and started using that series of comments to accuse me of being the Illusionist since you then knew we weren't on the same side. I find the Illusionist theory to be completely rediculous because the Illusionist is a solo player, they only win if they make it to the end themselves whereas players with teams can afford to be more competitive and put themselves in the spotlight to try find information to help their team. the Illusionist has nothing to gain by going into the public spotlight and the information isn't nearly worth the reward for them. between the no-lynch, your actions in game, and your theory that I'm the illusionist that I don't think you really believed, I believe you to be town-sided trying to push me as the illusionist because we're on opposing sides and after your reaction to my cop claim, even if i was wrong on it I think more than ever that you are town aligned.
the reason I was "wrong" was because I lied. I didn't really want to share my investigations so i just picked you and said you were a traitor. I'm pretty sure now you aren't a traitor. In the beginning I was scum telling pretty hard. (I often play aggressively for my side and it can really show)I was reverse scum hunting (town hunting) on day 1 pretty obviously, and I even claimed i was hunting for townies sometime during this game. to compensate for this I tried to look like i was playing both sides simultaneously by throwing around some obvious things that sounded like town Ideas but really weren't meant to be that helpful. You stated observations of me compensating in that way, maybe it was legitimate at the beginning but I think you picked up on my scum tells and started using that series of comments to accuse me of being the Illusionist since you then knew we weren't on the same side. I find the Illusionist theory to be completely rediculous because the Illusionist is a solo player, they only win if they make it to the end themselves whereas players with teams can afford to be more competitive and put themselves in the spotlight to try find information to help their team. the Illusionist has nothing to gain by going into the public spotlight and the information isn't nearly worth the reward for them. between the no-lynch, your actions in game, and your theory that I'm the illusionist that I don't think you really believed, I believe you to be town-sided trying to push me as the illusionist because we're on opposing sides and after your reaction to my cop claim, even if i was wrong on it I think more than ever that you are town aligned.
I really don't see a reason to share my investigations with you especially after the explanation of my first paragraph, and I'm really not sure why I'd share the investigations to someone I believe to be my enemy upon their request.
Well said. I wanted Caff to answer that question though, not you.
I want you to share the investigations because since you've 'revealed' your role, then I guess you could share it to the benefit of the majority. If you're playing that "I'm dying" game right now, and if you are right, then you might actually help your faction by revealing your investigations. If you can investigate then I guess you might have investigated a town role right now. I still can't tell if you're lying or not at this point. The possibilities of this game are crazy.
In another note, I like it how the tension increased so great this day x).
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
I was going to say pretty much the same thing anyway, just a lot simpler XD
The Contact and the Cop are essentially the same role, except the Contact is Mafia-sided and the Cop is Town-sided. It wouldn't have changed what his investigation was.
The Contact and the Cop are essentially the same role, except the Contact is Mafia-sided and the Cop is Town-sided. It wouldn't have changed what his investigation was.
Yeah, myusername22 you may as well reveal your second investigation.
Who did theWeakGuy replace then?
If I would have to use deductive reasoning with myuser as the contact doing a power play with a false cop claim
he wouldn't reveal who his second investigation is because he had found the cop, which he couldn't say he found simply because he was cop claiming himself. Using the idea that he was town side and couldn't reveal a fellow town side to the advantage of a cop claim. though none of that matters now since we have both sides claimed.
he wouldn't reveal who his second investigation is because he had found the cop, which he couldn't say he found simply because he was cop claiming himself. Using the idea that he was town side and couldn't reveal a fellow town side to the advantage of a cop claim. though none of that matters now since we have both sides claimed.
Population - 14
To Lynch - 8
To No-Lynch - 7
Votes-5
(5) - myusername22 (raxo2222, Sephhh, chicken23456789, CaffeinatedKitty)
Apologies if this is slightly incorrect, tapatalk makes it difficult to sift through x)
To Lynch - 8
To No-Lynch - 7
Votes-5
(5) - myusername22 (raxo2222, Sephhh, chicken23456789, CaffeinatedKitty)
Apologies if this is slightly incorrect, tapatalk makes it difficult to sift through x)
This is the exact list of people I suspected of being town-sided
Huge coincidence. Thanks. I will recheck later though as I did think there was one other person voting me
Caff unvoted, albeit not bold.
Could you quote that post? I've been unable to find it. Though in honesty this might be a good chance to look for the illusionist.
Unvoting me might not be a bad idea. If we don't find the illusionist in time neither of us will win. I'm on tapatalk and my house is having power issues with this thunderstorm so I'll look into my suspicion and make a post about it later. Right now I think I know who the illusionist is
- Status