midnightgirl24
You're gonna have a bad time.
This. This is why I haven't voted yet (or really said much for that matter)
Retaking Rochester (Concluded)
- Thread starter Jivvi
- Start date
- Status
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
Yes. Yes, I lied about investigating myuser. No, I didn't lie about being cop. I was covering for the person I did investigate, who happened to be another town role.(luck much?) Sooo imagine how surprised I was when he backed up my claim. I did investigate him last night to see if I really was right, but we all know how that turned out... I am not the Illusionist, and not very mysterious after this post, I should think.
Who seems the most dangerous to you role wise?
Probably the Illusionist.
Who seems the most dangerous to you in general?
Std, because he doesn't seem afraid to say what he thinks... And because of this he could hit upon something important.
Who seems most and least suspicious?
I don't have an FoS anymore... .-. He died, just a little bit. Erik seems the least suspicious, because of how he's acting right now.
How do you think myuser died?
I think myuser was hit by the vigilante this second time, maybe the mafia the first.
Who seems the most dangerous to you role wise?
Probably the Illusionist.
Who seems the most dangerous to you in general?
Std, because he doesn't seem afraid to say what he thinks... And because of this he could hit upon something important.
Who seems most and least suspicious?
I don't have an FoS anymore... .-. He died, just a little bit. Erik seems the least suspicious, because of how he's acting right now.
How do you think myuser died?
I think myuser was hit by the vigilante this second time, maybe the mafia the first.
But how am I supposed to believe you?
You lied about investigating myuser and I'm also confused about why you didn't vote myuser if you knew he was lying about your claim being real and his also.
suhduyfsfeI have pretty much no clue what that's supposed to mean...
Obviously I am paying attention to the votecounts from last night <.>
(I completely missed that, sorry. )
Really not good enough for me, there was no reason to investigate myuser after this claim.
investigating myuser was pointless because had his claim been legit like we all thought then he was definite the target of the vigilante, should he still have his life after the night that would mean the vigilante would know he is traitor.
Should he really be the contact and as he said the quack should not protect him, he would die indefinitely.
So why would you investigate a dying person?
vote caffeinatedkitty
investigating myuser was pointless because had his claim been legit like we all thought then he was definite the target of the vigilante, should he still have his life after the night that would mean the vigilante would know he is traitor.
Should he really be the contact and as he said the quack should not protect him, he would die indefinitely.
So why would you investigate a dying person?
vote caffeinatedkitty
I do have to agree, I am confused as to why you would investigate someone who had died. How would this help your allies if you really were a cop? Though you might rule out one role wouldn't it be more beneficial to investigate someone who seems suspicious, I can only suspect your using this as a last resort to try and keep your claim. just adding my bit to this sorry if it makes no sense just woke up 
Who seems the most dangerous to you role wise?
The Illusionist
Who seems the most dangerous to you in general?
Everyone really, I still don't know who to believe.
Who seems most and least suspicious?
The most suspicious definitely the lurkers and Caff seems to be hiding something. As for least suspicious no one, everyone is dangerous at this point.
How do you think myuser died?
No idea as I still don't know all the different roles and what they do
Who seems the most dangerous to you role wise?
The Illusionist
Who seems the most dangerous to you in general?
Everyone really, I still don't know who to believe.
Who seems most and least suspicious?
The most suspicious definitely the lurkers and Caff seems to be hiding something. As for least suspicious no one, everyone is dangerous at this point.
How do you think myuser died?
No idea as I still don't know all the different roles and what they do
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
Like I said, I wanted to make sure I was right. He was acting really oddly IMO. And how was I supposed to know he would die? He might've been protected, or the killing roles might've done something unpredictable. I'm a cop, not a mind-reader.
oops ok since I was away I just realised he wasn't lynched but killed overnight, sorry I just realised this so I can now see why you would investigate him. Ignore anything in my other posts that I said about this, sorry bout the mix-up x3 I would like to see others opinions before placing a vote.
I'm still questionable about your investigation. You could have just invented the investigation on Natsu since he's dead anyway, and that since you've already lied on your second investigation, I don't think that's good enough for me. You chose to lie about your investigation to "cover up" a town person and I know that it would be a bit better than saying that you investigated a town role, but either of the reasons would do the same thing. Also, yes he did tell the Quack not to die for him and he's going to die anyway since no one else can protect him, so that would be a bit suspicious why you would investigate a dying person.
How would he have been protected? Also I don't know how the killing roles would have done something unpredictable since basically the only people who can kill is the Vigilante which is a town role and the Duo (which doesn't even know who the Contact really is). On your side too I'd say that the doctor did protect you as you said (I think). Plus, probably the reason he backed your claim is to make others believe more that he "is" the Contact especially with all the doubts that is thrown at him -- and yes it did work apparently.
Doctor works the same way as in "traditional" mafia games- one player per night is chosen to be protected.
If a bulletproofed player is saved, the doctor save takes priority over the shielding.
(The vest stays intact.)
Vested players are alerted to being hit, but only if the vest were to break.
If a bulletproofed player is saved, the doctor save takes priority over the shielding.
(The vest stays intact.)
Vested players are alerted to being hit, but only if the vest were to break.
midnightgirl24
You're gonna have a bad time.
I want to let you guys know that I really won't be able to reply (decently most likely) because I'm currently without a computer and won't be hooking up my new one until Wednesday since that's when it arrives and I'm using my phone for the forums in the meantime
So based on this, and extrapolating that myusername would know that his vest is in tact or not, doing his contact claim knew he would survive.
Continuing on this I can only assume that the vigilante busted the vest and then caffeinated redirected the mafia hit towards myusername killing him. Unless the doctor power supersedes the kill.
So situation a: myuser vest is broken and was killed by vigilante
B: vest was in tact and vigilante busted vest, mafia kill was redirected from caff to myuser via illusionist power despite doctor protection.
c vigilante killed myuser and mafia targeted another person and busted vest of a traitor.
I personally write down things i think and then add what others say. Personally, with a side by side comparison it helps me understand a bit more. Plus this is reverse mafia, I'd be more surprised if everyone wasnt confused. Just try and find ur own way of understanding
I'm just waiting for more defence and posts before I decide on an action. To be heard I almost lynched myusername before but I decided to wait for a defence, and welp -- the game's intensity just rocketed.
It's quite suspicious that 2 of the people you investigated are dead so they can't confirm there role and you won't reveal the other one. To add to this you decided to investigate myusername22 when we all knew he was just about to die. So in my opinion you are either trying not to find anyone important, lying about being the cop and making all of this up or you have really bad luck.I'm not the Illusionist, why do you think so
- Status