REVIVAL OF MAFIA: Dire Streets {(OVER: FENCE WIN + town)}

[Ltin]

So we have two scenarios here

1) Friendly is telling the truth. This would mean notty is lying.
2) Notty is telling the truth. If so i would bet that the FENCE is actually blackmailing Friendly to claim FENCE when he isn't, instead of the FENCE just outright claiming. That doesn't make any sense. In short, i don't believe Friendly.

 

[Dess]

Can the fence even contact multiple people in a day?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Friendy who else have you contacted? And why did you just claim?

Ooglie101 Notme did you get contacted by anyone when you were voting on geek?

 

[Ltin]

Marskid is the FENCE's win condition simply to be alive at the end?

 

[Friendy]

So we have two scenarios here

1) Friendly is telling the truth. This would mean notty is lying.
2) Notty is telling the truth. If so i would bet that the FENCE is actually blackmailing Friendly to claim FENCE when he isn't, instead of the FENCE just outright claiming. That doesn't make any sense. In short, i don't believe Friendly.

Look at the way Notty words her sentences, why would she say

They said they send a message to all town roles except me and that way the Town knows something I don't and because of that people are gonna assume I'm not with them.

If she didn't want the townies to admit they're a towny? It's quite clearly reverse psychology, saying it the way she has would mean, (which you've already done) that you'd admit to being a towny, giving the mafia an easy target for their lynch while also trying to get those who are suspicious of notty off of her back while she conducts this plan.

 

[Friendy]

Friendy who else have you contacted? And why did you just claim?

Ooglie101 Notme did you get contacted by anyone when you were voting on geek?

I've not contacted anyone, I've claimed because Notty is lying.

 

[Ltin]

Hey guys, just fyi




THE MAFIA KNOWS WHO ISNT MAFIA, AND ONLY ONE THE THIRD PARTIES COULD POTENTIALLY BE ON THEIR SIDE

 

[Ltin]

The part of Notty's story that doesn't make sense to me is this

To show I coöperate they want me to use certain keywords n my post.

Why? What purpose does that serve? That doesn't show cooperation. It sounds overkill. Almost made up...... (tsk tsk)

Still more skeptical of Friendly though.

 

[Friendy]

Hey guys, just fyi




THE MAFIA KNOWS WHO ISNT MAFIA, AND ONLY ONE THE THIRD PARTIES COULD POTENTIALLY BE ON THEIR SIDE

Then why would Notty lie about being forced to do something by the FENCE and then vote me when I'm FENCE and I didn't tell her to do anything? In fact it more backs up my claim that I actually claimed the role, I could've let her vote and that'd be that.

 

[Nottykitten]

Ltin the full extend of the Fencewin condition can be found at the signup thread. It tells who they can win with.

 

[Ltin]

Then why would Notty lie about being forced to do something by the FENCE and then vote me when I'm FENCE and I didn't tell her to do anything? In fact it more backs up my claim that I actually claimed the role, I could've let her vote and that'd be that.

That isnt even relevant. You told me (or whoever you were talking to, it was kinda ambiguous) i had admitted i was town like that was a bad thing. I was simply pointing out that the mafia already knows.

Ltin the full extend of the Fencewin condition can be found at the signup thread. It tells who they can win with.

Are you sure? I checked and didnt even see a win condition.

 

[Ltin]

Oh i see it. It wasn't with the role list so i was confused.

 

[Friendy]

That isnt even relevant. You told me (or whoever you were talking to, it was kinda ambiguous) i had admitted i was town like that was a bad thing. I was simply pointing out that the mafia already knows.


Are you sure? I checked and didnt even see a win condition.

I misread your post my bad

 

[Ltin]

Has anyone received a gun?
before you answer.
Friendly have you given anyone a gun today?

 

[Nottykitten]

The part of Notty's story that doesn't make sense to me is this

Why? What purpose does that serve? That doesn't show cooperation. It sounds overkill. Almost made up...... (tsk tsk)

Still more skeptical of Friendly though.

I am honestly not sure. Im supposted to use the words: "day 0" "day 1" "day 2" in my post to show I'm on the Fences side.


Also I just want to say its 2 am here and Im on a phone that constantly loses internet so my posts might not come as quick and long as usual. Or I migbt simply go to sleep and stop responding till I wake up.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Friendy

For Town: The Mafia must be eliminated, as well as all third party roles. The Fence will be the major winner if they survive long enough to get the joint-win, so if the town wants total victory, he/she must be cut out of the picture.

I still don't understand your claim there but SURE

 

[Nottykitten]

The thing that riddles me most is why me. Why would the fence(Friendy) pick me to threaten and turn people against me. Maybe Friendy wanted to control a more experienced player so that Friedy could order me to start a lynch on someone and people would be more likely to follow an experienced player. And when I decided not to be a puppet they got angry and tried to turn roles against me? Thats the only thing I can think of atm.

 

[Ltin]

IMO a win is a win. It would be different if town did not win if fence was alive at the end, but it doesn't say that. I feel like different levels of victory don't really matter/are irrelevant

 

[MarsKid]

Votecount:
Nottykitten = 1(Friendy)
Infected_alien8_ = 1(Vatumok)
Dessern5 = 1 (Infected_alien8_)
Friendy = 2(hipman500, Nottykitten)
Geekenstein = 2(Ltin, CaffeinatedKitty)

10 Players to get majority.
Deadline @ midnight Tuesday.

 

[Ltin]

The thing that riddles me most is why me. Why would the fence(Friendy) pick me to threaten and turn people against me. Maybe Friendy wanted to control a more experienced player so that Friedy could order me to start a lynch on someone and people would be more likely to follow an experienced player. And when I decided not to be a puppet they got angry and tried to turn roles against me? Thats the only thing I can think of atm.

Friendly was pushing for a lynch of people still voting geek right? You were one of those people yes?

 

[Ltin]

The way i see it, the fence is a liability, like survivor. Except unlike when i claimed survivor (SCP i think) The game isn't close to over, AND the fence can actually do things other than sitting back and letting the game happen. It would be logical for the fence to turn on the town if the mafia looks to be winning. The FENCE cannot be trusted, and even if friendly is lying, a town sided role would not be smart in claiming fence.

unvote

vote Friendly

 

[Ltin]

Don't think you're off the hook notty.
If he is the fence he is essentially implicating you as well.

 

[Ltin]

Or he is only lying about the not sending any messages yet.
Mars could the fence give anyone a gun on day 0?
Friendly have you given anyone guns (at all)?

 

[Friendy]

Or he is only lying about the not sending any messages yet.
Mars could the fence give anyone a gun on day 0?
Friendly have you given anyone guns (at all)?

Yes.

Infected_alien8_

Though wouldn't it be useful for the townies to keep me alive in order to kill the Mafia off quicker? The way I see it is if the townies want to lynch me off after the mafia have been crucified, then I've fulfilled my role and I claim a moral victory.

 

[Ltin]

Though wouldn't it be useful for the townies to keep me alive in order to kill the Mafia off quicker? The way I see it is if the townies want to lynch me off after the mafia have been crucified, then I've fulfilled my role and I claim a moral victory.

If we go with that plan and it gets to the point that we need to lynch you because you have betrayed us, it will already be too late.