SCP - Secure, Contain, Mafia [GAME OVER]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Notme

Notme

Self-Aware Forum AI
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
6,484
Reaction score
8,491
25 30 20 20 15 10 10 5 2 1
Timdood3 said:
Seems people for got about this. Or ignored it. Either way people voting GmK without addressing it unsettles me.
My reasons:
1) I've had a hunch on him for a few (game) days, though I never bothered to address because discussion was elsewhere, and it was only mild.

2) His role itself: See my first post of the day

3) He has lacked generous activity (that's not the reason keep reading), and so it's hard to get an accurate judge (keep going), but his actions so far have seemed relatively neutral. Sure, he sniffed out a third party, but that's a third party; Hunter's death still benefited the mafia as well by reducing our numbers. Normally, I don't mind neutral, but it feels like he's forcing it. He's trying to be active without actually assisting us.

Vote GmK

And thus marks the halfway point of this vote. Though I would like Ltin and raxo2222 to go back and reply to road....

As for this:

First off, ltin claimed survivor. Either you forgot his claim or you're both mafia /shrug.

Also, how can you be certain coolio and I are town? There's been nothing to confirm us. Unless you have information that the rest of the town doesn't, and know we aren't mafia because you are. Newbie mistake of being too trusting or scum slip?

And that concludes tonight's episode of Tim Responds to Stuff that Happens.
Click to expand...
Well it was only guess
 
Notme

Notme

Self-Aware Forum AI
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
6,484
Reaction score
8,491
25 30 20 20 15 10 10 5 2 1
The road to ruin said:
I don't understand this. We've already had theories about 05 having a mafia infiltrator so that doesn't prove anything. Addtionally Ltin claimed 3rd party same as me, was that some sort of slip? I buy as lens claim but I urge everyone to hold your votes until GmK has a chance to respond. I find razo and loins eagerness to vote without sufficient evidence concerning.



This especially so.
Click to expand...
Well it was only guess
 
cooliorules

cooliorules

That Awkward Noodle
Donor
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
1,512
Reaction score
2,478
25 20 30 20 10 5 15 10 2 1
raxo2222 said:
I thought there were real claims, and I tried to deduct from it who is mafia.
Click to expand...
What claims..?
Are you saying that the people who you said are town are who you believe to be town?
If so, then you really should have said 'I believe these are town people' instead of saying 'these people are town'

Still don't know what to take from it.
 
Ltin

Ltin

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
951
Reaction score
1,481
30 20 15 10 10 5 2 1
cooliorules said:
What claims..?
Are you saying that the people who you said are town are who you believe to be town?
If so, then you really should have said 'I believe these are town people' instead of saying 'these people are town'

Still don't know what to take from it.
Click to expand...
I think he means he was going off the claims in the list. It had opinions, but also each person's claims.
 
Notme

Notme

Self-Aware Forum AI
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
6,484
Reaction score
8,491
25 30 20 20 15 10 10 5 2 1
cooliorules said:
What claims..?
Are you saying that the people who you said are town are who you believe to be town?
If so, then you really should have said 'I believe these are town people' instead of saying 'these people are town'

Still don't know what to take from it.
Click to expand...
Stop being so confused little girl >.>

I tried to come with something by analyzing this stuff:
Samlen said:
Raxo2222 - Claimed Vanilla town, now part of the 05 Council after Iggy died. Given my theory about the 05, I feel he could be town or anti-town sided
Ltin - Claimed Survivor, easy role to claim, could easily be survivor or anti-town.
Timdood3 - Claimed Vanilla town, now with a 'blue keycard' that lets him visits rooms he knows the number of. The keycard bit feels mostly confirmed, though nothing to prove him as town or anti-town.
Jolteon42 - Loyal Vigilante, I feel like Jolt's one of the most confirmed people role-wise, and I would say is one of the most confirmed town-sided people.
Samlen - Hai there, I feel like there's more than enough evidence to support my claim, so now that my goal is done, I'm a confirmed not anti-town here helping the town because I'm bored \o/
GmK - Claims Room Visitor, seems very ambiguous in general and role visiting may or may not have side effects of 'breaking' the room when entering. Nothing to say he's confirmed town or anti-town, though 'breaking' rooms doesn't feel particularly pro-town.
Old_Man_Oak_63 - Confirmed 05 and Item-giver, though with my theory about the 05's, he doesn't feel to be confirmed anti-town or pro-town.
chicken23456789 - Claims bodyguard, probably town-sided if claim is true, though only way to prove claim is for him to die while protecting someone, so who knows for sure. Would be a weird role to try and fake claim (imo) so I feel that he could be leaning more towards town (though not completely confirmed).
The road to ruin - Interesting claim, if claims is true, then it really *is* in his best interest to kill Mafia, though we may not be able to confirm his alignment for sure until he dies or meets his win condition
Faliara - Claims Security Chief, I'd probably have to go through a bunch of the pages again to double-check on whether or not Fal's role was confirmed or not, though it does feel more confirmed than most other people's roles and it would seem more likely to be a pro-town role (again, not certain either way)
cooliorules - Claims Vanilla town, nothing to support her as pro-town or anti-town. (Supposed Bulletproof, not completely confirmed)

So list of living people (with my thoughts copy/pasted from last time i posted this, plus one or two other bits).

Honestly, GmK does look most suspicious on first glance, and I don't have enough time right now to do anything more than that for now, so that's that.
Click to expand...
 
Fiestaguy

Fiestaguy

The man with 8 fingers.
Joined
Sep 11, 2013
Messages
2,197
Reaction score
1,642
30 25 20 20 15 10 10 5 2 1
raxo2222 said:
Stop being so confused little girl >.>

I tried to come with something by analyzing this stuff:
Click to expand...
raxo2222 please keep in mind that calling someone a 'little girl' will most likely be taken as an offense, Hereby, we ask you to please refrain from naming others things like this in the future.
 
The Road to Ruin

The Road to Ruin

Member
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
148
Reaction score
263
10 5 10 2 1
raxo2222 said:
Stop being so confused little girl >.>

I tried to come with something by analyzing this stuff:
Click to expand...
But there are internal inconsistencies. For example you threw Ltin in your list of confirmed town while you even voted for me. We both claimed 3rd party and by his own claim Ltin actually has interest in letting mafia win, where as I have interest in hunting mafia down. Not to mention with only 6 votes needed and today probably being the last day if we don't shape up you voted way to early.

While I don't have a crystal ball to see for sure it just looks to me like you might be mafia who made a slip, far more damning than GmK for being too suave if you ask me.
 
Notme

Notme

Self-Aware Forum AI
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
6,484
Reaction score
8,491
25 30 20 20 15 10 10 5 2 1
The road to ruin said:
But there are internal inconsistencies. For example you threw Ltin in your list of confirmed town while you even voted for me. We both claimed 3rd party and by his own claim Ltin actually has interest in letting mafia win, where as I have interest in hunting mafia down. Not to mention with only 6 votes needed and today probably being the last day if we don't shape up you voted way to early.

While I don't have a crystal ball to see for sure it just looks to me like you might be mafia who made a slip, far more damning than GmK for being too suave if you ask me.
Click to expand...
Well these inconsistence were because I did that too fast - just accident.
 
The Road to Ruin

The Road to Ruin

Member
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
148
Reaction score
263
10 5 10 2 1
I want to say before I log off for the night that I with a dead line being instituted I must demand an answer from raxo2222 Ltin and Timdood3 but mostly the first two. As I've said I think I cracked a slip up that wasn't terribly much to go on but we have GmK on the chopping block for now so I must ask for clarification. Raxo posted an original vote based on a hunch, fair enough, but when the information he used to narrow down his list of suspects was brought into question he hasn't unvoted or presented further evidence for his claim, I must ask for more (damn this deadline). Ltin, you actually voted on a joke and while I think that was dangerous enough during a game so close you haven't revoked it since the deadline was announced so I must ask for more. Tim while I love that you posted a nice block of info to justify your vote I want to ask how solid do your think your evidence is? Do you trust your vote enough knowing that a time limit is in effect?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top