SCP - Secure, Contain, Mafia [GAME OVER]
- Thread starter Fiestaguy
- Start date
- Status
Call it self doubt for me. As you all may or may not know I subbed in at the end of the last mafia game, fell for a claim and totally f*cked the town. I'd definitely still say Iggy is my main FoS but I also had to go to school and didn't want any votes going on while that involved me in case I missed something.
So, what? You think that iggy seems suspicious and that he is probably mafia, but since he's a townie, he's harmless and a No Lynch would be the best option?
Hear, hear.
Seems to me like you just took whatever Tim said and claimed that in order to make yourself look more innocent or more believable. Also, just hours before this post you said you don't think you have any particular powers or abilities:
Now, what I don't understand is what people (Notty, Tim and Road) regard as believeable in his claim. First off, as I just showed you, it's contradictional and secondly, vanilla townie, which is what he claimed at first, is the easiest role to fake if you're a scum and new to the game, and because of that it's usually the first choice for new scum to fakeclaim. When people started thinking that due to "O5 Overseer" name he might be a PR, he of course said that yes, he is indeed a PR and then adopted the first PR description that was mentioned. I don't know, the only thing that could in some way prove his innocence is, in fact, the fact that he mentioned "O5 Overseer" as his role name and that he later said he didn't even know what that meant, so if he didn't know what it meant, he probably couldn't have come up with that name himself. Only, he probably would have seen it if he did some basic research about SCP and then he could've just said he doesn't know anything about it, so that defense isn't all that certain either.
All in all, the defense iggy has put up is incredibly flimsy in my opinion. I have nothing against you personally, iggy, nor do I have some evil agenda in this game which makes me vote you, but I'm reading some especially strong scumtells off of you, whereas I haven't seen a single towntell yet, so the only logical choice for me is to assume that you're scum and therefore, the only reasonable choice for me would be to lynch you.
If iggy is really telling the truth, I would like at least one of the other two he says he's associated with to come out and claim that association. That would really be the only way to keep me from voting him at the moment.
Right now I want to change the perspective.
I see iggies claim as legit, whyz?
Because users have given hints they are the other two level fives. Neither wants to back him because we don't know if there is a protection role.
Given we now know the town has a threeway night decision to kill, tjis might be tje only pr ”weight” other then an investigation role.
Not knowing if they have protection or if they will ever even learn each other-insert image from venture brothers, contents when the council meet and everyone is only siluettes on tv screens-
Should there be a protection role then having two level fives in the open certainly kills one and locks the protection role up, decisively leading to a town loss because much like my last game the role blocker was forced to block the doctor, leaving the investigator to learn info and the mason to convert.
Now we can do conjecture and all everyone who they think another level five is, but that helps nothing to get progress.
I see iggies claim as legit, whyz?
Because users have given hints they are the other two level fives. Neither wants to back him because we don't know if there is a protection role.
Given we now know the town has a threeway night decision to kill, tjis might be tje only pr ”weight” other then an investigation role.
Not knowing if they have protection or if they will ever even learn each other-insert image from venture brothers, contents when the council meet and everyone is only siluettes on tv screens-
Should there be a protection role then having two level fives in the open certainly kills one and locks the protection role up, decisively leading to a town loss because much like my last game the role blocker was forced to block the doctor, leaving the investigator to learn info and the mason to convert.
Now we can do conjecture and all everyone who they think another level five is, but that helps nothing to get progress.
20 pages for day 0 gosh.
Iggy situation (get it like icky?): I'm in a split of opinions. On one hand I feel like iggy is trying to hide behind fake-town claims and trying to throw his FoS around everytime throws the spotlight on him. I've done the same thing in the Bloody Masquerade if anyone remembers the whole Watcher/Tracker incident so I've seen this type of ploy before. On the other hand though I feel like this also could just be him being a newbie and not liking to be pulled into the spotlight because he wants to survive longer but I wonder why a townie would be so defensive if he has nothing to hide.
I'm wondering why you would want to no-lynch today when there's a chance we could lynch a third-party vig/third-party vig like council. I'd feel like that'd be about as important as lynching mafia considering in Bloody Masquerade, the Voltari killed off the Mafia then proceeded to kill everyone and win the game. If anything I feel we should take this chance and throttle it until we feel we've gotten all the info we can.
I'm mainly just curious as to why you'd want to leave a possibly non-town aligned vig/vig council member alive another day when there's a chance he could kill us during the night. It seems to me a too risky of a plan while we have every opportunity now to get at least some more info about them and possibly lynch off one of the potential vig council members or the vig.
Iggy situation (get it like icky?): I'm in a split of opinions. On one hand I feel like iggy is trying to hide behind fake-town claims and trying to throw his FoS around everytime throws the spotlight on him. I've done the same thing in the Bloody Masquerade if anyone remembers the whole Watcher/Tracker incident so I've seen this type of ploy before. On the other hand though I feel like this also could just be him being a newbie and not liking to be pulled into the spotlight because he wants to survive longer but I wonder why a townie would be so defensive if he has nothing to hide.
I too along with I think quite a few people would like to know the answer to this question though to me it seems like you're just jumping on every chance there is to try and hide from the spotlight. I'm honestly at this moment unless you've got a really good answer to this willing to lynch you.
I'm wondering why you would want to no-lynch today when there's a chance we could lynch a third-party vig/third-party vig like council. I'd feel like that'd be about as important as lynching mafia considering in Bloody Masquerade, the Voltari killed off the Mafia then proceeded to kill everyone and win the game. If anything I feel we should take this chance and throttle it until we feel we've gotten all the info we can.
I'm mainly just curious as to why you'd want to leave a possibly non-town aligned vig/vig council member alive another day when there's a chance he could kill us during the night. It seems to me a too risky of a plan while we have every opportunity now to get at least some more info about them and possibly lynch off one of the potential vig council members or the vig.
Std, Lord Voltari was town sided.
The Council was town sided.
Town won the masquerade. (Yay me)
There is a possibility that the O5s are not town sided.
Though even if Iggy is town, we have something to gain from lynching him: the alignment of the other two O5s.
Even with one O5 out, the other two will still be able to kill. This is great if Iggy flips town, not so great if he turns out to be mafia or 3rd party.
Vote Iggy234
Not necessarily because I'm sure he's mafia, but because even if he's not we gain something.
The Council was town sided.
Town won the masquerade. (Yay me)
There is a possibility that the O5s are not town sided.
Though even if Iggy is town, we have something to gain from lynching him: the alignment of the other two O5s.
Even with one O5 out, the other two will still be able to kill. This is great if Iggy flips town, not so great if he turns out to be mafia or 3rd party.
Vote Iggy234
Not necessarily because I'm sure he's mafia, but because even if he's not we gain something.
I'm trying to piece stuff together as best as I can and sometimes I just end up assuming some of the pieces of this puzzle in order to make it all fit and sometimes they don't. I'm not going to make a vote based off of assumptions which is why as I said beforehand I'm not voting him until I feel like there's enough pieces of the puzzle put together to make a real judgement call.
I know it was a joke <3 and I'm willing to take the risk of assuming since I'm not doing him any damage by trying to figure out how this is all put together.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Meanwhile I was just about to respond x)I didn't remember that
sorry notty. tim explained to me how the voltari works and ninja'ed you being able to explain yourself.
But still why do you think that they are 3rd party? [Actually thats not even possible, since a group of people that can kill during the night is just a Mafia group or second Mafia group].
And I doubt that he would just outright state how many Mafia members are in his group and that hes one of them. So I am way more inclined to believe the group is town-sided.
Mooglie
The Local Cow
Well.
Assassins would have won Masquerade
if Digi wasn't a maniac.
IT WAS ALL PERFECT
WE HAD THE 'INNOCENT' LIE DETECTOR ON OUR SIDE
I WAS BEING INVESTIGATED AND WOULD SHOW UP INNOCENT
NOTTY WAS GETTING INTO THE VOLTARI
WE WOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO MAKE 2 KILLS A NIGHT
THEN DIGI IS JUST LIKE
'HEY LET'S KILL HIM EVEN THO HE'S BEING INVESTIGATED LOL!1!11!1'
i swear i still say assassins won that game nasnuanhui
Assassins would have won Masquerade
if Digi wasn't a maniac.
IT WAS ALL PERFECT
WE HAD THE 'INNOCENT' LIE DETECTOR ON OUR SIDE
I WAS BEING INVESTIGATED AND WOULD SHOW UP INNOCENT
NOTTY WAS GETTING INTO THE VOLTARI
WE WOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO MAKE 2 KILLS A NIGHT
THEN DIGI IS JUST LIKE
'HEY LET'S KILL HIM EVEN THO HE'S BEING INVESTIGATED LOL!1!11!1'
i swear i still say assassins won that game nasnuanhui
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
(This is why I shouldn't read spy novels)
Perhaps he's only PRETENDING to be clueless, in order to fool us into believing that it's really a town-sided group. I'm not inclined to believe this, really, but with all the scummy things he's said, I just can't let him slide.
Perhaps he's only PRETENDING to be clueless, in order to fool us into believing that it's really a town-sided group. I'm not inclined to believe this, really, but with all the scummy things he's said, I just can't let him slide.
I gave what I believe to be sound reasoning.This is just fucked up. People want me lynched because they think I'm mafia. Even if they think I'm town they want to lynch me (timdood).
OH HEEEELLL No!
Even if you are town, we have something to gain from lynching you.
- Status