SCP - Secure, Contain, Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Hunter]

has anyone confirmed the legitimacy of the claims made by the "overseers" yet?
they could simply be mafia members posing as townsided prs.
any there is no known way to prove their legitimacy 100%
but lynching one could reveal things

 

[Nottykitten]

Well, Iggy/Oak can explain what the overseers do at night. They had one night now, so they should know who the third member is and what they are supposted to do.

 

[Hunter]

and why was endersteve typing in a way implying his higher status/superiority?

anyone else notice that, or at least something standing out about the way his posts were presented

 

[Hunter]

wasn't there some talk regarding CaffeinatedKitty
was that resolved?

 

[Nottykitten]

I didn't notice that, he seems to be playing as usual.

 

[Hunter]

AHEM! Ender is one of my fos because of a gut feeling that is growing larger every minute.
Chicken;ditto
Caff: too quick to jump to conclusions.

Plus who can trust a person with purple eyes,homicidal poultry or a half human-cat mutant? >.>

My current theory is that Iggy is third-party if no more 'Councilmen' show up.
If he was innocent, atleast one would step up (methinks)
If he was mafia, a fellow member would step up (methinks)

Eh, still suspicious of him. I swear, if there's a Fool role in a closed set up I am going to rage.

To be perfectly frank my eyes are being drawn to Ender, who's relentlessly attacking Iggy and not really accepting any defence, shrugging it off as too flimsy. I'm slightly worried about the tunnel vision I believe I'm seeing.

three quotes from older posts relevant to my previous statements

 

[Timdood3]

has anyone confirmed the legitimacy of the claims made by the "overseers" yet?
they could simply be mafia members posing as townsided prs.
any there is no known way to prove their legitimacy 100%
but lynching one could reveal things

I said this yesterday and everyone was like "amg no they good"

 

[Notme]

lol it was long night

Also no one died, thats nice :)

 

[Hunter]

I said this yesterday and everyone was like "amg no they good"

yeah, maybe if one died we would have actual info
watch the next two or so day/night cycle be nolynching and nokilling
and then, surprise!
third party cultists end up winning
and-
wait.
oh god cultists

 

[Hunter]

But there's the point; we still don't know if they're town-sided or evil third party or what. They could be a mafia with a day chat, for all we know.
...now that I think about it, that seems quite likely to me. I don't trust iggy at all, and if you think about it, he blundered through his roleclaim, which he only used to save his own skin. And if you look at it, it's working. I'm not unvoting, and if it ends up a nolynch and he dies overnight and turns out to be town, so be it.

another relevant quote by the glorious caff of the kitties

 

[Hunter]

in this case , one of the overseers could be an agent of the mafia
"infiltrated the council" and whatnot
and the role goal is to disrupt council proceedings?

(this is a possibility, is it not?)
(this is a game of mafia)
(this is not sparta)

 

[Nottykitten]

Just a random thought while reading and thinking the last few pages over; am I the only person whom is bothered by this? Even chicken's vote gave an explanation (somewhat) but this is literally just saying "I'm going to bandwagon and lynch this person without even bothering to give an opinion with my vote." Maybe it's just me, but I'm keeping a note of this for now.

I forgot to answer this yesterday. But yes, appearently you are the only one.

 

[Ltin]

wasn't there some talk regarding CaffeinatedKitty
was that resolved?

It wasnt resolved, just a very weak argument that fell to the wayside.

 

[Dess]

Strange for there to be no deaths. Could it have been possible for all actions to be blocked just once?

 

[The Road to Ruin]

I'm guessing the mafia rolled the dice with either Oak or Iggy and lost out, good for us!

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

Ok. Honestly, I find it hard to believe that the mafia would pass up this chance. Either they're playing games with our heads, or these "overseers" are lying about their roles. This is only more evidence that they are the mafia, at least to me. How can you all be disregarding such blatant clues?

 

[Ltin]

Ok. Honestly, I find it hard to believe that the mafia would pass up this chance. Either they're playing games with our heads, or these "overseers" are lying about their roles. This is only more evidence that they are the mafia, at least to me. How can you all be disregarding such blatant clues?

How can you assume so much and still regard it as evidence?
There are plenty of other possibilities.

 

[Nottykitten]

Ok. Honestly, I find it hard to believe that the mafia would pass up this chance. Either they're playing games with our heads, or these "overseers" are lying about their roles. This is only more evidence that they are the mafia, at least to me. How can you all be disregarding such blatant clues?

I really don't see what you're trying to say. "Either the mafia is playing with out heads or the overseers are lying about their roles"

I don't see the connection between those two. So what if the overseers are lying? That doesn't explain at all why there is no kill tonight. We aren't disregarding clues because there are no clues to disregard.

 

[Faliara]

No one died? Woah. Didn't quite expect that. I'm glad.

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

For one. If the "overseers" really aren't the mafia, then why didn't the mafia kill them? What mafia member wouldn't want to take out a major pr the first night? The first logical conclusion is that they are in fact the mafia, so neither died, and the second that the mafia is trying to convince us that the first is true.
And for two, Iggy, one of these so-called overseers, gave such obvious clues that he was part of the mafia, and used the claim to save his skin. And even then he fumbled it. Role PMs are meant to be clear, if I'm not mistaken. How can you possibly misread one? He claimed vanilla town and then latched onto a suggestion of what his action could be.
If this really does turn out to be a ploy by the mafia, I'm going to be either laugh or cry because you all fell for such an obvious trick.

 

[Timdood3]

For one. If the "overseers" really aren't the mafia, then why didn't the mafia kill them? What mafia member wouldn't want to take out a major pr the first night? The first logical conclusion is that they are in fact the mafia, so neither died, and the second that the mafia is trying to convince us that the first is true.
And for two, Iggy, one of these so-called overseers, gave such obvious clues that he was part of the mafia, and used the claim to save his skin. And even then he fumbled it. Role PMs are meant to be clear, if I'm not mistaken. How can you possibly misread one? He claimed vanilla town and then latched onto a suggestion of what his action could be.
If this really does turn out to be a ploy by the mafia, I'm going to be either laugh or cry because you all fell for such an obvious trick.

What you say makes sense as a possibility. It's the way you say it that makes me skeptical.

 

[Timdood3]

Will elaborate later tonight. Marching band and stuff.

 

[Ltin]

For one. If the "overseers" really aren't the mafia, then why didn't the mafia kill them? What mafia member wouldn't want to take out a major pr the first night? The first logical conclusion is that they are in fact the mafia, so neither died, and the second that the mafia is trying to convince us that the first is true.
And for two, Iggy, one of these so-called overseers, gave such obvious clues that he was part of the mafia, and used the claim to save his skin. And even then he fumbled it. Role PMs are meant to be clear, if I'm not mistaken. How can you possibly misread one? He claimed vanilla town and then latched onto a suggestion of what his action could be.
If this really does turn out to be a ploy by the mafia, I'm going to be either laugh or cry because you all fell for such an obvious trick.

Ever heard of a doctor?

 

[Ltin]

Or perhaps the mafia hit a bleeder of some sort?

 

[Mooglie]

Ever heard of a doctor?

(or roleblocker)