The Chronicles of Mafia - GAME OVER - MASONS WIN

erik5456

Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2013
Messages
34
Reaction score
185
Are we really suspicious of Claire right now? She's literally been open with us and i myself can confirm on having gotten the other message regarding her not having shot anyone. Let alone that, but the rest of her story checks out based on what Rune and Dess said. If anything, Rune or TheWeakGuy should be in the spotlight right now.

Rune you spelled out mafia with your posts and are pushing for Claire being suspicious on the basis that she has a gun and the fence will punish you for revealing the task. Ok just to keep it clear with everyone This person sending random messages to others is a 3P. They know nothing and they're trying to fuck with us. As for the gun, I think it's clear Claire lost that by the message that others and I got. Unless the fence has gotten some modifications (which may be possible but it doesn't seem likely), just say fuck them and dont play along with their shit. Also ya what Sploorky said cuz he ninja'd me makes you suspicious man.

TheWeakGuy, something seems suspicious. This fence boi is definetily something along the lines of a filthy RPer and because they RP, they are most definetily thorough. Almost seems like you want to hide your task more than anything else. That being said, this is all just a supposition.

Since we might actually get somewhere, rune is suspicious, and pressure is never terrible, I'll vote rune as soon as more people speak on the matter
 
G

Guest35486

Guest
I’m willing to leave Arelic’s first post be for now, but before that I have one last question;

Arelic, why didn’t you use the gun?
1) rune mentioned 3p in his next post so i thought he's 3p
2) theweakguy's next post had "scum" in it but he did say he thinks the messages are from a player so idk if he would have told the truth
3) dess just straight up stopped posting like i tried to get him to post by tagging him but he just didn't
i was waiting for dess to post because i wasn't sure about weak based on the reason stated above and i rather shoot a mafia than 3p (which i thought rune was) but day ended while i was away anyway
 

Faliara

Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2012
Messages
2,588
Reaction score
3,080
i was waiting for dess to post because i wasn't sure about weak based on the reason stated above and i rather shoot a mafia than 3p (which i thought rune was) but day ended while i was away anyway
ah, okay. sorry; i missed that bit.
I'm not saying we should not kill him, I'm saying we should wait because everyone hasn't been able to speak yet
that’s fair.
 

HKCaper

Almighty Goat
Joined
Oct 21, 2014
Messages
110
Reaction score
1,197
I have read all this and I gotta say it is a mess. Anyway, I must admit that the way the letters in Rune's post spell out mafia makes him kinda suspicious. Also, the way rune reacts just feels a bit off (although i am not sure why), sploork made a good point imo
I feel like there's a gap of logic here: you're acting as if there is a repercussion to failing the task, which during day 0 was understandable, but in your post you only indirectly mention the word mafia. Wouldn't you be worried that spelling it out wouldn't count as mentioning it? Also, why are you mentioning these roles anyways if your task was to claim a role that wasn't your own?

And why are you testing if you got different tasks? This all happened during day 0. There was no indication that anybody got any tasks. How did you know arelic's task included mentioning her alignment?

Maybe I'm reading this wrong but things don't add up. I'm gonna stick a vote on runeman
then again rune is receiving votes at an alarming rate and i kinda agree with erik. I feel arelic is being honest about her messages, and afaik nothing has happend as some sort of repercussions. I agree that Rune is being kinda susp rn, but i think we shouldnt really pay to much attention to these messages, as erik said.

as far as im concerned rune is susp enough to be a prime lynch target for today, but id rather wait for more people to speak before we lynch rune.
 

erik5456

Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2013
Messages
34
Reaction score
185
Well except we actually have a reason for Rune's lynch
I mean we also had a reason for Unu lynch just this one feels more solid and game based instead of behavior. And TWGs right, we should still discss Unu lynch IF we decide not to lynch Rune. We don't want a divided town right now. I will say though Later Gator was the most suspicious out of all of them IMO and his silence today hasn't really helped.
 

Faliara

Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2012
Messages
2,588
Reaction score
3,080
I think 2 jailer claims was a fair reason in the addition to how unu was acting. Something I think everyone has kind of ignored today
... That’s true- we did, in fact, forget about that. It was the very reason some people chose to go along with the vote.

I still consider Rune suspicious, but we should start talking about what’s going on with Sploorky’s role claim being similar to Unu’s, as well. We shouldn’t let the day end so quickly with little discussion passing by.
 

Sploorky

Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2011
Messages
1,890
Reaction score
3,656
Also there has been awfully little discussion about Unu's lynch.
which surprises me a lot, actually. I was expecting someone to call me out for starting the unu lynch.

I didn't bring it up because I felt that if I started the subject, it would make me look really guilty. I also didn't want to take away from the fence conversation. From personal experience, trying to talk about two entirely separate things during a game of mafia causes each topic to not get the attention it's needed.

I think it's something to talk about once the runeman situation is sorted out, either by lynching or by fence giving someone a gun(if it comes to that, please nobody shoot rune at 4 votes).
 

Sploorky

Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2011
Messages
1,890
Reaction score
3,656
I think 2 jailer claims was a fair reason in the addition to how unu was acting. Something I think everyone has kind of ignored today
Lets not mince words here. I didn't claim jailer, I claimed a role that has similar abilities to jailer.

I can claim if need be, but I don't want to unless people genuinely think I'm guilty for initiating the unu lynch. I think there was a lot of evidence against unu and even though I was wrong, a lot of his actions were way too suspicious
 
Top