The Doomed Cruise - Game [OVER AND OUT ]

[cooliorules]

I'm wi ENDER, I'm so freaking confused x3
I'll do more of my role play tomorrow c;
Also, I probably will be posting less, but I'll still be in the game and posting c:

TO THE GAME RELATED STUFF:
As I said in my last vote, defiant is the person I'm most suspicious of, but also those who aren't talking (storm886 and hihihilolHI)
Going to hold off on my vote until at least tomorrow (most probably night).

 

[cooliorules]

Excuse ender's name in caps. I have autocorrect, iPad.

 

[nitasu987]

Ah'm pretty darn sure tha' we neeta mahke a deshishun shoon o' we ahl gonna git it!

Translation: I'm pretty darn sure that we need to make a decision soon or we're all gonna get it!

 

[Omar_Sales]

If you want to officially abstain, you must do it in bold on the last line.

I'm at a loss, currently so Im going to eat some licorice and think.

I said Im abstaining for now, means I'm gonna wait and see how the day goes on before actually casting my vote.

 

[Enderfive]

If you want to officially abstain, you must do it in bold on the last line.

I'm at a loss, currently so Im going to eat some licorice and think.

I said Im abstaining for now, means I'm gonna wait and see how the day goes on before actually casting my vote.

You don't have any suspicions at all right now?

 

[Omar_Sales]

You don't have any suspicions at all right now?

Read my first post; I do.

 

[Enderfive]

You don't have any suspicions at all right now?

Read my first post; I do.

Ah, I see now. Must've missed it the first time.

 

[storm886]

Oh sorry, I have been very busy lately and you guys post sooooo much T.T. So I read some and skimmed over a good bit for now at least. I have noticed that there seems to be some suspicion on endersteve. I feel like he is just excited for his first game of mafia and that's it.
Who would be your shot-in-the-dark right now? Mariosatr. He is very quiet in both mafia and survivor. He is kind of a mystery to all of us which isn't a good thing. Ironically I have been quiet lately hahaha but I will see if I can fix that.

How suspicious do you think you yourself seem? I feel like people will see me very suspicious in the coming days when I start to go after people. I will probably be lynched around day 1 or 2 by some type of pyramid. If you were in the past two seasons, you will know what I am talking about.

 

[Nottykitten]

Oh sorry, I have been very busy lately and you guys post sooooo much T.T. So I read some and skimmed over a good bit for now at least. I have noticed that there seems to be some suspicion on endersteve. I feel like he is just excited for his first game of mafia and that's it.
Who would be your shot-in-the-dark right now? Mariosatr. He is very quiet in both mafia and survivor. He is kind of a mystery to all of us which isn't a good thing. Ironically I have been quiet lately hahaha but I will see if I can fix that.

How suspicious do you think you yourself seem? I feel like people will see me very suspicious in the coming days when I start to go after people. I will probably be lynched around day 1 or 2 by some type of pyramid. If you were in the past two seasons, you will know what I am talking about.

Sorry about that =c

 

[cooliorules]

If you want to officially abstain, you must do it in bold on the last line.

I'm at a loss, currently so Im going to eat some licorice and think.

I said Im abstaining for now, means I'm gonna wait and see how the day goes on before actually casting my vote.

Read that completely wrong, sorry xD

 

[Enderfive]

Actually it's my second season playing Mafia, I also played in Season 5. But yeah, of course I'm excited, I'm always excited and if you count in the fact that I haven't really done anything with you guys the last two months because my computer broke down, then yeah, I'm excited.

I have three suspicions right now: digitalmez, mario and ansoro. Correct me if I'm wrong, but they have all been very quiet and they all joined the no-lynch bandwagon. From what I've heard and experienced, the mafia will try to lay low and unseen so everyone will simply forget about them, they're eager to join bandwagons and a no lynch favours the mafia. So for these reasons these three seem suspicious to me.

Then there is of course Jivvi, who burped up some questions without answering to them, which, as OOT suggested, could've been a way for the mafia to seem pro-town and neutral at the same time. Also, if you ask me, I think Jivvi overreacted to the suspicion on him just a tiny bit. But I do think that Jivvi was merely trying to get the discussion rolling.
And then there is Ooglie, who is acting rather peculiar, but I think it's because he's a result of a horrible experiment which resulted in him turning into a mancow.

So for me, the first three people I named in this post are also the most suspicious.

 

[Jeercrul]

Crap, I'm such a noob in life. Before I signed up for this, I originally thought my end-of-years examinations are 5 weeks away. Turns out I messed up the dates and they are 2 and a half weeks away and I have not started on ANY revision at all. For the following 4 weeks (exams are two weeks) I will be on semi-hiatus and gradually to full hiatus. My first language papers start on 2nd Oct and before that week and between the two weeks I will most likely be posting little, but I will be checking to see the thread's progress. I'll be pming Gmk of course.

As for Alpha102, your post about me not providing any proper justification before voting no-lynch, I believe you missed the previous pages (you already stated it but just telling you this). I believe my reason is clearly explained in short and sweet sentences. I will not be changing my vote, regardless of whether lynching has a better outcome than no-lynch, unless someone can really convince me to do so. If anyone still thinks that my reason is still not justified enough, feel free to tag me as I won't be checking out the thread as much.

 

[Alisha]

SORRY, I really dropped the ball on that post. :S

 

[GmK]

///VOTECOUNT///

Players needed to lynch: 16
Players needed to no-lynch: 15

No Lynch - 11 - digitalmez, shinyshark, grimmjowforever, K1ngHoward, infernofox, mariosatr, ansoro, kraby1, Prizyms, balloon98, HypeBurst, (NL-4)
endersteve5 - 1 - Vatumok (L-15)
K1ngHoward - 1 - MarsKid (L-15)
Omar_Sales - 1 - Defiant_Blob (L-15)


Players not voting: Alpha102, myusername22, nottykitten, Sploorky, Dessern5, endersteve5, Ooglie, storm, 77_is_the_best, hihihilolHI, Jivvi, Old_Man_Oak_63, Omar_Sales, One One Two, cooliorules, nitasu987

 

[digi]

I have three suspicions right now: digitalmez, mario and ansoro. Correct me if I'm wrong, but they have all been very quiet and they all joined the no-lynch bandwagon. From what I've heard and experienced, the mafia will try to lay low and unseen so everyone will simply forget about them, they're eager to join bandwagons and a no lynch favours the mafia. So for these reasons these three seem suspicious to me.

At first I was against the idea of not lynching. I wanted to vote for someone who I felt was guilty. My problem is if I make a hunch vote I usually point fingers at veteran players, such as Defiant Blob and NottyKitten. Due to my experience, they've always expressed outright deceit and deviousness. Which, in my opinion, makes them culpable targets. I don't want to take that route. So I'm going to play it easy. I hopped right on that no-lynch bandwagon because I believe in the "there are no leads" argument.

Here's something-
What makes you think that lynching someone on the first night is the right way to go?
We all know the risk of lynching the wrong person. Which gives Mafia a leg up and leaves us passengers one person down. Yet there's that other side of the spectrum where we could get lucky. COULD. I understand how alluring that risk is. At the end of the day I'd rather we lose (for example) 2 passengers instead of 3. Make of that what you will.

Also, what are the roles? (GmK) I just want to know how many there are in the Mafia crew and if there are any 3rd party roles.

 

[Enderfive]

I have three suspicions right now: digitalmez, mario and ansoro. Correct me if I'm wrong, but they have all been very quiet and they all joined the no-lynch bandwagon. From what I've heard and experienced, the mafia will try to lay low and unseen so everyone will simply forget about them, they're eager to join bandwagons and a no lynch favours the mafia. So for these reasons these three seem suspicious to me.

At first I was against the idea of not lynching. I wanted to vote for someone who I felt was guilty. My problem is if I make a hunch vote I usually point fingers at veteran players, such as Defiant Blob and NottyKitten. Due to my experience, they've always expressed outright deceit and deviousness. Which, in my opinion, makes them culpable targets. I don't want to take that route. So I'm going to play it easy. I hopped right on that no-lynch bandwagon because I believe in the "there are no leads" argument.

Here's something-
What makes you think that lynching someone on the first night is the right way to go?
We all know the risk of lynching the wrong person. Which gives Mafia a leg up and leaves us passengers one person down. Yet there's that other side of the spectrum where we could get lucky. COULD. I understand how alluring that risk is. At the end of the day I'd rather we lose (for example) 2 passengers instead of 3. Make of that what you will.

Also, what are the roles? (GmK) I just want to know how many there are in the Mafia crew and if there are any 3rd party roles.

It's a closed setup game, so we don't know any of the roles.

As for the fact I support the lynch, I've explained my reasoning already several times. Even statistically we'll have a better chance taking the Mafia down even if we don't lynch right. Or at least that's what I've read elsewhere.

 

[Enderfive]

But thank you for that post nonetheless, you explained your reasoning behind the vote and now I don't consider you as suspicous as ansoro or mario, although you're definetly not cleared in my eyes.

 

[digi]

It's a closed setup game, so we don't know any of the roles.

I feel blinded by this.

Let me answer these:-
Who would be your shot-in-the-dark right now?
I'm always suspicious of NottyKitten and Defiant Blob. To me, they're reprehensible players. Yet for entertainment value and the fact that they can post posts every day and stir up some kind of discussion; I genuinely like having them around.

If I'm going to take a stab in the dark, I'm going to go with--
Actually no. I'm paranoid about this question because I feel that this in some way could help Mafia frame me. I don't want that. So I'll keep it to myself.
I think you're all god damn shifty!

Spoiler

How suspicious do you think you yourself seem?
Due to my quiet disposition its made one person suspicious of me. Other than that I don't think I'm an incredulous player. Not yet anyway, I hope :\

Why is GmK so sexy?

I need proof before I can make such a critical judgement.

 

[Jeercrul]

It's a closed setup game, so we don't know any of the roles.

As for the fact I support the lynch, I've explained my reasoning already several times. Even statistically we'll have a better chance taking the Mafia down even if we don't lynch right. Or at least that's what I've read elsewhere.

Explain how statistically we have a better chance of taking Mafia down when townies are the majority.

 

[Enderfive]

It's a closed setup game, so we don't know any of the roles.

As for the fact I support the lynch, I've explained my reasoning already several times. Even statistically we'll have a better chance taking the Mafia down even if we don't lynch right. Or at least that's what I've read elsewhere.

Explain how statistically we have a better chance of taking Mafia down when townies are the majority.

I don't exactly remember how it went, but I think it was based on the fact that if we mislynch, the townies don't have such a big majority anymore and thus, our chances of randomly hitting scum would increase. And yes, it isn't the best scenario, but I'm just trying to convince you guys with whatever I have to make you reconsider that no-lynch vote, because I really do think lynching is a better option.

 

[digi]

How suspicious do you think you yourself seem?
Due to my quiet disposition its made one person suspicious of me. Other than that I don't think I'm an incredulous player. Not yet anyway, I hope :\

No, not incredulous -- it's 3 in the morning. For some reason I thought that word meant untrustworthy. It doesn't. What I meant to say is that I don't think at this point in the game people really find me and me alone a shady character. I think generally everyone's suspicious of everyone right now.

On a side note--
This rpg seems interesting. I'm seriously channeling Tallulah Bankhead right now.

 

[MarsKid]

My, all this bloody arguin' is gettin' us nowhere! We c'n talk 'n talk all we like, but aye see nothin' comin' out of it!

OOC:

Gonna bring back my earlier point, but with more to it: the only reason we're not voting yet is because we're trying to figure out who is suspicious. We're voting for people and pointing figures just to see if we can draw somebody out. After the Mafia and Killer (I'm guessing there is one) make their hits and we move into Day 1, when people are out voting to kill, then we can see patterns emerge.

But right now, we've had 10 pages of trying to look for a person to throw overboard.

Now I know I'm guilty of this strategy since I called K1ng out. Which is funny, considering he only made an appearance when I questioned him.

So either we just end this day with a no-lynch and move into the next day, or we settle on some of the more shady characters.

 

[myusername22]

originally i voted no lynch. then i unvoted only because i felt it was silly to rush into a no lynch without letting everyone at least post once/see everyones opinions. however that being said I only unvoted because i didn't want day 0 to end so quickly i still am not in favor of lynching anyone tonight.

since we've gotten much further in and there's still not much evidence(though i feel i did successfully get a better feel for the game and certain people ) the argument is growing stale and i think it is time to go forward into night 0

vote no lynch

 

[Nottykitten]

I hold my ground when I said I'd vote for the next person that votes a No Lynch.
At first I started doubting if I'd go through with this. But not anymore.

I said in my first post I wasn't going to say wo my shot in the dark was incase I might make the mafia mad. But if people do that we don't have much discussion now do we =S. At that moment I didn't even really have a shot in the dark. But while reading throught the No Lynches people were voting, I just radnomly had the thought at one of them: "This person is mafia". And from thay moment I kept that in mind. I didn't say it however. Funnily enough, that person was Myuser. And now he voted No Lynch [again..] I feel a bit safer with voting him.

I might not have any proof other than a hunch. But this is the best I can go off.

Vote myusername22

 

[K1ngHoward]

>>>>We should move into the next day with a "no lynch" for it is a better day with more information even if the information is vague. Right now we have many unanswered questions about the roles that are playing at the moment:
-How many Mafia?
-How many power roles?
-Are there any power roles?
-How many deaths per night?
-Will the mafia be meeting together before they kill?
>>>>These are important questions that can help refine our own judgments of who may be the mafia. We are just pointing towards an open plain expecting someone to appear that won't and though people keep saying we have a "chance" to hit a mafia member; you forget that we have the same "chance" to hit a power role. This will cause tremendous hurt to our group since we will lose the people who can help find information about our mysterious criminal organization. There is even higher "chance" of hitting a townie which won't hurt us immensely, but it will be detrimental over time when mafia majority slowly starts growing.
>>>>I can't deny that this 10 pages of conversation has been useful, but we are still trying to pin down an unseen enemy that won't appear just because we point fingers at everyone. Tomorrow we can sharpen our views, pull out discrepancies, and narrow down our list of suspects. Right now every single person is on the "mafia list" and anyone could be chopped off because someone decides they have "evidence" (note suspicion does not equal evidence. Suspicion can lead to evidence, but it is not evidence itself.) that this player is the mafia. I am still staying with my vote.
MarsKid
I made an appearance before you called me out and stated my views before that. Though i have the time to post every hour (except at nights), I like to wait for many people to post after me and gather my thoughts before i just launch in a random direction. I love to digest information :)