The Doomed Cruise - Game [OVER AND OUT ]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
- Status
GmK
International Man Of Cake
(Sorry, no flavor today because of the whole travelling thing)
After a night that seemed to go on for ages (*cough slow mafia cough*) day finally dawned.
Luckily, compared to the slaughter the night before, things aren't as terribad...well except for the following person:
Ooglie101, a Passenger, was killed.
End of Night 3, start of Day 3
MafiaPlayer
After a night that seemed to go on for ages (*cough slow mafia cough*) day finally dawned.
Luckily, compared to the slaughter the night before, things aren't as terribad...well except for the following person:
Ooglie101, a Passenger, was killed.
End of Night 3, start of Day 3
MafiaPlayer
May as well claim my role. I am the Passenger Watcher - very similar to HypeBurst's Tracker role but instead of seeing who a player targeted, I see who they were targeted by. I decided against outing reports earlier as I feared that the people visiting them were town-sided, or I didn't find anyone at all. Due to this, I think the Mafia may be working together to kill one person rather than each Mafia member having their own kill - we need to work out who is performing the night kill each night.
Nothing of value has really been gotten, sadly. If I can catch a lead today I'll visit but I can't guarantee anything =(
Nothing of value has really been gotten, sadly. If I can catch a lead today I'll visit but I can't guarantee anything =(
I think K1ngHoward said that he thinks all Mafia members had their own kill, but the evidence from tonight seems to point towards the contrary - that the mafia decide to kill one person.
>>>>This is very disturbing that means that if the total mafia can only kill 1 person, the night before we had 3 "town roles" that killed people. (One being Nottykitten) I don't see how those two other roles can go around and kill randomly and see that helping us. And yes i did think that mafia had one kill each, but last night and the first night prove otherwise, but we can't throw out the option that it is 1 kill a night since we still have 2 unaccounted for murders if the mafia can only kill once a night.
Sploorky
Member
Alright, so what we can gather--
There is no serial killer role, or if there is, he's not going on a rampage killing everyone. I'm going to assume the former, because if you had a role built around killing everyone, you'd probably use it every night.
Notty's lynch--Innocent, but 'deranged'. Considering notty admitted to killing that night, deranged must allow you to kill people, because lucky and passenger don't. Considering the fact that people voted for notty...we sadly can't get much off of that, considering notty was killed for a valid reason, being found to kill someone and assumed mafia.
I'm going to look into the votes for notty and see if we can get any people voting just for the sake of getting someone eliminated. In the meantime, I'll be waiting for any PR roles to possibly discuss what they did the last night, if there was anything important happening.
There is no serial killer role, or if there is, he's not going on a rampage killing everyone. I'm going to assume the former, because if you had a role built around killing everyone, you'd probably use it every night.
Notty's lynch--Innocent, but 'deranged'. Considering notty admitted to killing that night, deranged must allow you to kill people, because lucky and passenger don't. Considering the fact that people voted for notty...we sadly can't get much off of that, considering notty was killed for a valid reason, being found to kill someone and assumed mafia.
I'm going to look into the votes for notty and see if we can get any people voting just for the sake of getting someone eliminated. In the meantime, I'll be waiting for any PR roles to possibly discuss what they did the last night, if there was anything important happening.
Sploorky
Member
I doubt the mafia each has one kill a night. Lets assume there are....4 or 5 mafia to 30 members. If they never got lynched, that's 5-6 deaths a day, because why would the mafia not use all their kills in a night? It seems illogical.
But can it be a retaliation power? Since the night after we killed a mafia member 4 people died. Since one of those kills was Nottykitten's i am guessing we have 3 mafia members left by my logic. They then get a kill each for the death of their partner.
HypeBurst
Just Fabulous
I feel terrible that Vatumok used his last role on me considering I hit a no result last night. Im not sure If I want to say it though.
One explanation I can see from the lack of kills is that (in my last night probably) the mafia didn't want me catching out one person and they decided to play it safe til they know I'm out if the game.
One more thing, Prizyms Im kinda unsure why you role-claimed when you had no information to bring to the table. Both Vat and I had a potential mafia investigated. (loloopssorryguysfornotty) and thats why we claimed when we claimed. But now you have claimed a potentially lynch-threatening role for almost no reason. I would like to hear your side of this :)
One explanation I can see from the lack of kills is that (in my last night probably) the mafia didn't want me catching out one person and they decided to play it safe til they know I'm out if the game.
One more thing, Prizyms Im kinda unsure why you role-claimed when you had no information to bring to the table. Both Vat and I had a potential mafia investigated. (loloopssorryguysfornotty) and thats why we claimed when we claimed. But now you have claimed a potentially lynch-threatening role for almost no reason. I would like to hear your side of this :)
I simply haven't found anything of value. Defiant_Blob was visited by mariosatr night 1 (Jailkeeper, Defiant_Blob became immune to the effects of other night visits that night). The other nights I've visited people who didn't receive any visitors, simply because the mafia are a very unpredictable type. However, once the amount of Mafia gets smaller, my importance increases - assuming there is one Mafia member who consistently performs the night kill each night, if we can get them lynched the Mafia presumably will not be able to kill. And if I visit someone killed, I get the name of the visitor - if they're the only visitor, they are the killer. My claim wasn't for no reason - it's so that today we avoid killing another Town-sided role because they have a night kill ability, purely because of the night kill ability.
TL;DR
I'm the Watcher (I see who visits people at night), and from my information and also that of previous days it seems that the Mafia can perform one kill a night, and presumably that would mean one person performs the night kill every night. If we can get that Mafia member lynched, I assume that the Mafia would not be able to kill.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
(I don't know what TL;DR means, could you explain that)
And what I thought, is that the mafia, as a group, choose the one person they throw overboard, not that there's one person in the mafia who is able to kill.
TL;DR means 'too long didn't read', I made this not just for you but also to those who couldn't be bothered to read my 3 post spiel on the matter.
Some players, most notably K1ngHoward, think that there may be criteria that allows the Mafia to get more than one kill a night.
HypeBurst
Just Fabulous
I'm quite confused on how you role-claiming equals avoiding another town sided kill, other than you. If you were in the firing line and getting votes, then you claim your role but you were completely safe. It just makes me nervous.
If you get more important as the game goes on, why would you reveal yourself if you haven't "haven't found anything of value". I know that tonight I'm getting lynched unless some miracle happens but now that you have claimed too, you're also on the chopping block. But you wouldn't have to worry if you were, oh I don't know, a mafia posing as a town-sided role. All theoretical of course.
- Status