The Doomed Cruise - Game [OVER AND OUT ]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
- Status
kraby and balloon are both people I haven's seen talk as much as I thought would have. Especially since kraby has done nothing but vote and roleplay. No analysis whatsoever.
storm I can kinda-sorta see why he's been quieter, given how two games in a row he's been voted off and been innocent at the same time. Don't take that as an excuse, though.
Kraby is the most suspicious to me right now.
storm I can kinda-sorta see why he's been quieter, given how two games in a row he's been voted off and been innocent at the same time. Don't take that as an excuse, though.
Kraby is the most suspicious to me right now.
Just had a thought: The inactive people can say they were away, or that they weren't keeping up.
Kraby has definitely put work into his posts given the roleplaying. Why all the work into roleplaying instead of contributing reasons FOR his votes?
Kraby has definitely put work into his posts given the roleplaying. Why all the work into roleplaying instead of contributing reasons FOR his votes?
Shinyshark
Professional innuendo creator/finder.
Like I said before I don't know how to see if someone is suspicious, I'm trying to figure it out but I don't see why I'd have to post "I don't know shit about this boat and the people on it" to not look suspicious. Being a tard in this game makes you suspicious, that's something I figured out thus far.
But fine, I'll post more. It won't be useful, most likely, but you want it.
But fine, I'll post more. It won't be useful, most likely, but you want it.
>>>>This day has been showing a lack of evidence to directly point at a single person as the "mafia" and i can not really trust Prizyms since he went from a random chance of being killed in the night to a full on target. This risk is extremely dangerous for the fact that Endersteve5 also had the ability as Mafia for a "two-shot kill" which could mean that the person he chose would be hit twice breaking through any protection the "Doctor" may have provided to you. Now Endersteve5 is gone from this game, but couldn't there be the possibility that there is another mafia member out there with a "two-shot kill" ability? We can instantly assume any protection for either HypeBurst and Prizyms may be rendered useless if this hypothesis is true. If there is a protective role i would rather they protect Hype over Prizyms since Hype has proven his "town-ness" and Prizyms has more than likely pre-exposed himself to a large slam by a tank shell coming up in this night and has not got much information to prove he can be trusted anyways.
>>>>I am very suspicious of Defiant for the facts that he has gone silent right now and his roleplay character, but he seems to have used less roleplay now then before because of the opposition he received when using it before. Defiant did bring up logical points when i re-read his posts, but the character he roleplays as is very aggressive and is a dangerous character to try to be in a game where you can be lynched for being too aggressive or too passive. His character choice makes him a prime person to be extremely suspicious of especially when he has yet to appear (maybe due to school?). But, i have no evidence to really go out and vote for him and still trust him to a certain extent, but only take that as you will. Only evidence i can point which is as loose as water is Endersteve5, who we know is mafia, "protecting" (protecting?) Defiant on page 13.
Linky Linky (google docs[view mode only])
>>>>Now with barely evidence to back-up my vote I shall act like the illogical logical robot I am and vote for Storm886, who came out and stated he was mafia.
vote storm886
>>>>I am very suspicious of Defiant for the facts that he has gone silent right now and his roleplay character, but he seems to have used less roleplay now then before because of the opposition he received when using it before. Defiant did bring up logical points when i re-read his posts, but the character he roleplays as is very aggressive and is a dangerous character to try to be in a game where you can be lynched for being too aggressive or too passive. His character choice makes him a prime person to be extremely suspicious of especially when he has yet to appear (maybe due to school?). But, i have no evidence to really go out and vote for him and still trust him to a certain extent, but only take that as you will. Only evidence i can point which is as loose as water is Endersteve5, who we know is mafia, "protecting" (protecting?) Defiant on page 13.
>>>>Lastly, I have painstakingly read through the entire thread(again...) and wrote down every single person's vote choices and who didn't vote during the day to maybe draw some lines between peoples voting decisions. I have striked through all of the names of people who are dead through the entire thread, with colors that signify town(green), mafia(red), and unknown(orange). I have also placed the page where the action was taken in brackets "[ ]" so you can go look at the reasoning for the voting actions. I will update this constantly, though may run into trouble since google docs doesn't have a good ctrl-find-replace function (grumble grumble).
Linky Linky (google docs[view mode only])
>>>>Now with barely evidence to back-up my vote I shall act like the illogical logical robot I am and vote for Storm886, who came out and stated he was mafia.
Code:
string storm886 = "I am mafia";
if (storm886 == "I am mafia")
[INDENT=1]vote(storm886); [/INDENT]Reading back, wasn't Endersteve5 the 'Two-Shot Janitor'? I'm assuming that means he was a Janitor (Basically, a Mafia-sided role that can hide the role of a player from everyone but himself upon night kill) but the two-shot may have described his ability. From this we can deduce that Endersteve5 must have 'janitored' MarsKid N1 which resulted in his role not being shown.
1. grimmjowforever - ew who is this person
2. Alpha102 - Not much posts but probably a townie.
3. shinyshark - Rather doubtful of him. Could be anti-town. Claims doesn't know what to do. Not sure if can be trusted.
4. ansoro2112 - Too little posts ansy :u Post more.
7. Jivvi - Not as talkative as last season. However was mafia last season. I'll go with the hunch that he is on a different side and a townie.
8. Vatumok - Obviously innocent.
9. Prizyms - Not sure if could be trusted. I'm not too sure about his roleclaim, but his justification for his posts seem genuine.
11. Dessern5 - Not much contributive posts.
13.Sploorky - Not sure, seems townie. Need more clues.
15.digitalmez - Not sure..
16. 77_is_the_best - Not sure, but a little suspicious.
17. HypeBurst - Still can't get over last season :c I need to revisit the previous pages.
18. balloon98 - Idk.
19. storm886 - Idk.
20. kraby1 - Need to go through previous pages, no time.
23. One One Two - Not too sire about that "lynching post" on the first few pages.
24. Defiant_Blob - I feel like he is townie. His roleplaying makes sense to me, at least.
25. Old_Man_Oak_63 - Posted much more in the previous season. Not much in this season. I'm sorry oak, unlike last season I'm going to say you are a little suspicious to me./I]
27. K1ngHoward - Sometimes I'm too lazy to read through your posts :x will properly read through after exams
28. hihihilolHI - Honestly, post more.
29. Omar_Sales - Haven't made much of an impression.
30. cooliorules - Feels like townie
I'm sorry for the lazy post. Not fun typing on a phone.
2. Alpha102 - Not much posts but probably a townie.
3. shinyshark - Rather doubtful of him. Could be anti-town. Claims doesn't know what to do. Not sure if can be trusted.
4. ansoro2112 - Too little posts ansy :u Post more.
7. Jivvi - Not as talkative as last season. However was mafia last season. I'll go with the hunch that he is on a different side and a townie.
8. Vatumok - Obviously innocent.
9. Prizyms - Not sure if could be trusted. I'm not too sure about his roleclaim, but his justification for his posts seem genuine.
11. Dessern5 - Not much contributive posts.
13.Sploorky - Not sure, seems townie. Need more clues.
15.digitalmez - Not sure..
16. 77_is_the_best - Not sure, but a little suspicious.
17. HypeBurst - Still can't get over last season :c I need to revisit the previous pages.
18. balloon98 - Idk.
19. storm886 - Idk.
20. kraby1 - Need to go through previous pages, no time.
23. One One Two - Not too sire about that "lynching post" on the first few pages.
24. Defiant_Blob - I feel like he is townie. His roleplaying makes sense to me, at least.
25. Old_Man_Oak_63 - Posted much more in the previous season. Not much in this season. I'm sorry oak, unlike last season I'm going to say you are a little suspicious to me./I]
27. K1ngHoward - Sometimes I'm too lazy to read through your posts :x will properly read through after exams
28. hihihilolHI - Honestly, post more.
29. Omar_Sales - Haven't made much of an impression.
30. cooliorules - Feels like townie
I'm sorry for the lazy post. Not fun typing on a phone.
One one two
Per aspera ad astra
For Grimm, regarding the "lynching post" I made in the early stages of the game: I still maintain that I was right about what I said in it. Half the players haven't been posting (I'm semi-guilty of this, too), hence half the players look exactly the same. How do we differentiate Mafioso from Townies when this is the case? Well, it's not easy, as you can probably tell from this past page. This is exactly what I predicted would happen in the post you're referencing, and the town is suffering as a result.
The thing is, there are lots of players who can be proclaimed as Mafioso simply because they're not posting much.
Anywho, we're at a standstill, so I'm going to go ahead and:
-Suggest we let Hype and Prizyms do their thing. I'm skeptical and don't like the idea, but see no reason why we can't test the waters with it for a round or two considering they've both posted their supposed roles in the thread already.
-Start another lynch vote to get this round going.
I don't like the idea of voting off one of Storm, Kraby, Anso, Balloon, hihi, etc. (the players who have remained quiet for the entirety of the game) right now as there has to be town-sided roles in there. Power roles can use their abilities to pick out players from that bunch.
With that said, I'm going to bring back my earlier vote for someone I have been very suspicious of for the whole the game. Sporadic posting patterns, voting patterns, and that whole roleplaying thing that I don't exactly care for all play into this vote.
vote Defiant_Blob
The thing is, there are lots of players who can be proclaimed as Mafioso simply because they're not posting much.
Anywho, we're at a standstill, so I'm going to go ahead and:
-Suggest we let Hype and Prizyms do their thing. I'm skeptical and don't like the idea, but see no reason why we can't test the waters with it for a round or two considering they've both posted their supposed roles in the thread already.
-Start another lynch vote to get this round going.
I don't like the idea of voting off one of Storm, Kraby, Anso, Balloon, hihi, etc. (the players who have remained quiet for the entirety of the game) right now as there has to be town-sided roles in there. Power roles can use their abilities to pick out players from that bunch.
With that said, I'm going to bring back my earlier vote for someone I have been very suspicious of for the whole the game. Sporadic posting patterns, voting patterns, and that whole roleplaying thing that I don't exactly care for all play into this vote.
vote Defiant_Blob
Here's my list, I was gonna do one before, and started, but it got washed into the ether.
1. grimmjowforever - I reckon you're like me, no interesting role, but trying to gather as much little pieces of evidence as possible into a nice big pile
2. Alpha102 -
3. shinyshark - Generally rambles on, doesn't seems to know a whole lot about anything; but you never know (this guy had a storyteller role for Solitude, this could be an act :O )
4. ansoro2112 - Hello? Do you exist?
7. Jivvi - Hi
8. Vatumok -Blue from the neck up, blue from the neck down.
9. Prizyms - Still a little shifty about this guy. He's 'proven' that Vatu is innocent, but he still isn't as certain as Hype's role, which has been proven.
11. Dessern5 - Was mafia with him last time. He's playing the same way... Just sayin'
13. Sploorky - Not quite as in there and helpful last season
15. digitalmez - Same boat as grimm, imo
16. 77_is_the_best - You know, I'm really not sure
17. HypeBurst - Pretty sure you were proven innokent
18. balloon98 - Jumps around making links where he can, as per usual
19. storm886 - Suicidal due to being run over by a bandwagon every time he tries to help
20. kraby1 - I don't think he's contributed too much as a whole to the more focused conversation.
23. One One Two - Not too sire about that "lynching post" on the first few pages.
24. Defiant_Blob - Def generally seems to have the towns interest at heart, he's just trying out a different playstyle; one that fits his character. My gut ignores this guy.
25. Old_Man_Oak_63 - Posted much more in the previous season, like grimm said. This could mean a few things, though.
27. K1ngHoward - Seems to be very townie, he questions the questionable and tries his hardest to make sure we're on the right track
28. hihihilolHI - Hi, do you exist?
29. Omar_Sales - Haven't made much of an impression, like grimmy said.
30. cooliorules - Has tried to contribute here and there, seems blue
Oops, just read OneOne's bandwagon push.
24. Defiant_Blob - Def generally seems to have the towns interest at heart, he's just trying out a different playstyle; one that fits his character.
Here's my standing again
1. grimmjowforever - I reckon you're like me, no interesting role, but trying to gather as much little pieces of evidence as possible into a nice big pile
2. Alpha102 -
3. shinyshark - Generally rambles on, doesn't seems to know a whole lot about anything; but you never know (this guy had a storyteller role for Solitude, this could be an act :O )
4. ansoro2112 - Hello? Do you exist?
7. Jivvi - Hi
8. Vatumok -Blue from the neck up, blue from the neck down.
9. Prizyms - Still a little shifty about this guy. He's 'proven' that Vatu is innocent, but he still isn't as certain as Hype's role, which has been proven.
11. Dessern5 - Was mafia with him last time. He's playing the same way... Just sayin'
13. Sploorky - Not quite as in there and helpful last season
15. digitalmez - Same boat as grimm, imo
16. 77_is_the_best - You know, I'm really not sure
17. HypeBurst - Pretty sure you were proven innokent
18. balloon98 - Jumps around making links where he can, as per usual
19. storm886 - Suicidal due to being run over by a bandwagon every time he tries to help
20. kraby1 - I don't think he's contributed too much as a whole to the more focused conversation.
23. One One Two - Not too sire about that "lynching post" on the first few pages.
24. Defiant_Blob - Def generally seems to have the towns interest at heart, he's just trying out a different playstyle; one that fits his character. My gut ignores this guy.
25. Old_Man_Oak_63 - Posted much more in the previous season, like grimm said. This could mean a few things, though.
27. K1ngHoward - Seems to be very townie, he questions the questionable and tries his hardest to make sure we're on the right track
28. hihihilolHI - Hi, do you exist?
29. Omar_Sales - Haven't made much of an impression, like grimmy said.
30. cooliorules - Has tried to contribute here and there, seems blue
Oops, just read OneOne's bandwagon push.
24. Defiant_Blob - Def generally seems to have the towns interest at heart, he's just trying out a different playstyle; one that fits his character.
Here's my standing again
Just watch everyone and see what you can do! Try out what some other people are doing to gather intelligence, then try a few things of your own! You never know, you might come up with something really useful!
Sploorky
Member
Just as a note-I'm here, and I'm trying to be as useful as possible. From previous forum mafia games, when I went off on tirades to try to find the mafia, I would get lynched in disbelief. Forums are a great deal different than the irc mafia I am experienced at, which is why I'm being more careful here.
I'd like for two things.
1. For defiant to respond to 112's post, so we can hear both sides.
2. For us to not forget the people who barely speak, and only do so just to role play. You can go any way with the "People not speaking are mafia, people not speaking are town" things, but in the end, a quiet mafia member does work a fair bit. Which is why I'm generally most suspicious of the people who don't post a lot, ie ansoro, storm, kraby, and a few others.
I'd like for two things.
1. For defiant to respond to 112's post, so we can hear both sides.
2. For us to not forget the people who barely speak, and only do so just to role play. You can go any way with the "People not speaking are mafia, people not speaking are town" things, but in the end, a quiet mafia member does work a fair bit. Which is why I'm generally most suspicious of the people who don't post a lot, ie ansoro, storm, kraby, and a few others.
Ansoro2112
Hottie
I'm in the same boat as Shiny. Kind of new here. So you can say I'm getting used it. Sorry if I haven't talked much.
But oh well. I read several pages back. I noticed how Cooliorules always was in Endersteve's side. She was either trying to defend him or just trying to take away all the attention from him and blame someone else.
Endersteve even tried to protect her as well. He said in page 6 (right off the bat. When the game just started) "I don't think Coolio is Mafia".
Then when Vatumok told everyone that Endersteve was indeed Mafia Cooliorules became silent. She became from being active to a quiet player. She didn't even voted for Endersteve. It was not after Endersteve got lynched that she came back to the game and started talking once again. Without saying a word about Ender's death.
Its just something I found suspicious. Pls don't hate me. I'm still a noob.
But oh well. I read several pages back. I noticed how Cooliorules always was in Endersteve's side. She was either trying to defend him or just trying to take away all the attention from him and blame someone else.
Endersteve even tried to protect her as well. He said in page 6 (right off the bat. When the game just started) "I don't think Coolio is Mafia".
Then when Vatumok told everyone that Endersteve was indeed Mafia Cooliorules became silent. She became from being active to a quiet player. She didn't even voted for Endersteve. It was not after Endersteve got lynched that she came back to the game and started talking once again. Without saying a word about Ender's death.
Its just something I found suspicious. Pls don't hate me. I'm still a noob.
Hi I exist :) (At least, I think I do...
). I've been reading the arguments so far, but the person who strikes me as the most suspicious is coolirules, because of the way he/she refers to "the mafia", keeps on the sides, follows the bandwagon, and makes very short posts that don't really contribute.
). I've been reading the arguments so far, but the person who strikes me as the most suspicious is coolirules, because of the way he/she refers to "the mafia", keeps on the sides, follows the bandwagon, and makes very short posts that don't really contribute.
Sploorky
Member
Actually a really good find, ansoro/hihihi. It certainly raises some red flags, but I'd like to hear coolio's response/see what other people think.
Also, to note--Both tracker and watcher CAN be mafia roles. Having the role and your evidence does not mean you are always town sided.
Also, to note--Both tracker and watcher CAN be mafia roles. Having the role and your evidence does not mean you are always town sided.
Hi I exist :) (At least, I think I do...
>>>>These are good points and "may" prove Defiant's innocence if there is more to Cooliorules being mafia. Cooliorules voted against Defiant three separate times on Day 0 alone and also voted for Nottykitten(town) on Day 2 while staying silent on Day 1 during Endersteve5's(mafia) trial.
Nah I've just been very busy and I kind of skim through the posts. The number of people in this game makes it is hard to keep track of when you're busy. In addition, I am a normal old passenger as usual...
Alright, so K1ngHoward voted for me because I said I was mafia. Maybe he is mafia and in that case he wants a town member to be lynched of course. He knew I was quiet so he thought that I wouldn't retaliate against him and he thought he could get an easy bandwagon against me. In the back of his mind he was thinking that I could be a very powerful town role too.
Nah..... my gut doesn't think he is mafia. Carry on.
- Status