The Doomed Cruise - Game [OVER AND OUT ]

[Sploorky]

Ansoro laid suspicion on you.

If he's guilty, you're likely innocent. If you're guilty, he's likely innocent.

VRISKA: What an injudicious assumption! This line of thinking will cause really cause us to lose!!!!!!!!
VRISKA: All you're doing is causing people to 8e afraid to lay suspicions on others 8ecause if they're wrong, then they can 8e attacked for 8eing wrong.
VRISKA: Just 8ecause you are innocent, doesn't mean who always choose the correct person to 8elieve is guilty!

What?

I'm speaking to discuss the fact that if one person is guilty, the other person is probably innocent. Why is everyone misconceiving this? I'm not saying "Lynch one, if he's innocent, lynch the other." I'm saying "If we lynch one, and they turn out to be guilty, the other person is either innocent or it's a not so common ploy by the mafia."

This is an if situation, not a when situation.

 

[Sploorky]

Screwed up the quoting there. Defiant_Blob you'll get the gist.

 

[cooliorules]

Nice quoting there c;
And I understand what you're saying, so if you lynch me you're gonna be disappointed guys.
Just saying

 

[Shinyshark]

vote Abstain

 

[cooliorules]

Little talk and a vote with absolutely no other speech, whether it's a "sorry I've been away" or anything.
That might strike as suspicious to some, I'd suggest justifying your answers

 

[cooliorules]

Your answers? xDD votes**

 

[GmK]

///VOOOOOOOOTECOUNT///

Players needed to lynch: 10
Players needed to no-lynch: 9


Defiant_Blob - 1 - One One Two (L-9)
Kraby1 - 6 - 77_is_the_best, Alpha102, Dessern5, Sploorky, Prizyms, cooliorule (L-4)
Cooliorules - 4 - ansoro2112, hihihiLolHI, Vatumok, Omar_Sales (L-6)
Sploorky - 2 - Old_Man_Oak_63, storm886 (L-8)

Abstaining - 2 - HypeBurst, Shinyshark
NoLynch - 1 - K1ngHoward (NL-8)

Players not voting: kraby1, balloon98, Jivvi, grimmjowforever, Defiant_Blob, digitalmez


PSA: Abstaining sucks, I could hit myself for even having it put in the rules to allow it..
PSA 2: I hope the count is correct, just returned and am still jetlagged

 

[hihihilolHI]

It is a little bit shifty to, as someone who hasn't posted much, to accuse coolio, who has been chipping in and trying to help where she can.

Huh? That makes no sense >_> I post less than coolio, so my accusing her makes me suspicious?

 

[Jivvi]

It is a little bit shifty to, as someone who hasn't posted much, to accuse coolio, who has been chipping in and trying to help where she can.

Huh? That makes no sense >_> I post less than coolio, so my accusing her makes me suspicious?

Kinda

 

[balloon98]

This might seem sudden and unlikely but I want this posted so we can get someone out of the way. Here we go again since I too am an investigating role which tells me not the actual role but only if someone is guilty or not.

To answer questions that will come 1st night investigated inferno since some people seemed suspicious about him and he wasn't guilty. Next night investigated myusername since people were suspicious of him then they both ended up dying. Finally last night I found out a guilty person which was grimjow. You can believe me or not but I am telling the truth. He is guilty so I feel this is better than a shot in the dark so vote grimmjowforever

 

[HypeBurst]

oooo omg we have a lead yay :D. If your telling the truth, we kill grimm who is mafia. If your lying we kill off a town but then we can lynch you off the next day and kill a different mafia. I see no downsides :).

unvote
vote grimmjowforever

 

[Sploorky]

Would be a completely dumb idea to lie to us this early in the game, sooo....Don't see why not. Your head if you're not telling the truth on this.

unvote
vote grimmjowforever

 

[Sploorky]

Actually, scratch that, shouldn't vote so fast.

grimmjowforever what do you have to say?

unvote

 

[cooliorules]

Not sure if this is a possibility, but he MAY be a mafia investigative role, although he seems to be right about inferno and user. I see no point in not beliving him. Unless something else comes up, my vote will go with grimm.

unvote
vote grimmjowforever

 

[77thShad]

I find this a much better lead than Kraby and if balloon is lying we can kill him tomorrow.

vote grimmjowforever

 

[cooliorules]

If it is true though, we will most likely loose him soon, probably tonight, from the mafia. So let's hope this is a definite lead!

 

[77thShad]

Balloon what's your role called exactly?

 

[Vatumok]

unvote
vote grimmjowforever

 

[K1ngHoward]

>>>>Very nice investigating Balloon, though we now run into the problem that one of our current "cops" (let us just call them that for now) may be a fake. I don't know about the amount of roles a usual forum mafia game gets for this size of a group, but three (four if you count Vatumok) seems like too many cop roles. Getting four cop roles in a single game of 30 people sounds like a lot, but what do i know since this is my first forum mafia game and this could be the norm it just seems very suspicious to have this many cops in one game in a single game.
>>>>Another point to bring up is why Balloon98 didn't tell us earlier, why tell us after a whole week of semi-productive work went in and just when we begin to falter he comes in to miraculously "find" a mafia member. Now, he does run into the same risks that Vatumok had when he came out with Endersteve5 as a mafia player. We believe him because there is great risk involved if Grimmjowforever is found not to be mafia and would cause his quick death the next day. What if grimmjowforever is actually an important role that the mafia has to get rid of and Balloon98, being the mafia, discovered the important role and would risk his own life to get him out of the way. A lot of this is just speculation, but a 4th "cop" coming out is just way too suspicious for me to pass by and vote against grimmjow. I will probably vote for him later on, but i will sit on the sidelines with Sploorky and wait for his response to the evidence presented against Baloon98's accusation.

Sploorky If Grimmjowforever is Mafia this will be a good opportunity to see if my theory of a "retaliation ability" the mafia acquires after the death of one of their comrades. We should see two (unless there is more mafia) deaths tomorrow if I am right and Grimmjowforever is mafia.

>>>>Staying with my vote, for now.

 

[Jeercrul]

I'm sorry for not posting, have been busy with exams and not checking the thread frequently. I'll apologise if this is unable to address your suspicions, had biology paper today and I'm mentally exhausted. Again, really sorry for that.

So, apparently it seems that balloon, you, have claimed to be cop and accused me of being guilty. May I ask where is the logic in that? Are you merely taking the chance to vote off the inactive players as an valid excuse simply because so many people have roleclaimed and they were all trusted? I will call myself innocent, but I will not reveal my role. Investigative roles, hype, prizyms, coolio, etc, feel free to investigate me tonight. As king had said I do not think it is very coincidental that four investigative roles have popped up while there were only one-two roles in the past. Furthermore, you had claimed to be cop but was mafia last season, and you are using this story again in this season. It is up to others to judge for themselves whether balloon is guilty or not but in my shoes you are guilty.

This might seem sudden and unlikely but I want this posted so we can get someone out of the way. Here we go again since I too am an investigating role which tells me not the actual role but only if someone is guilty or not.

To answer questions that will come 1st night investigated inferno since some people seemed suspicious about him and he wasn't guilty. Next night investigated myusername since people were suspicious of him then they both ended up dying. Finally last night I found out a guilty person which was grimjow. You can believe me or not but I am telling the truth. He is guilty so I feel this is better than a shot in the dark so vote grimmjowforever

And to answer this directly, you have in fact, used the names of the players that are considered dead already. Both infernofox and myusername have died on Night 2. I do not believe that you are a cop. You could have been using the names of the dead players to find yourself a valid excuse to convince others that you are an investigative role, when in fact, you are simply just manipulating others who have not yet noticed your trick yet. It was a bad move balloon, I am voting for you.
P.S. Please address me as a girl.

vote balloon98

 

[Jivvi]

Righto, looks like another fun jumble to screw our heads over trying to solve!


In my point of view, what we really have to decide is who to lynch first, as this could either be a poor attempt at a fake cop claim, countered by a skilled townie, or it could be a real, inexperienced cop claim beaten back by a mafia member who is strong in the words department.
Also, grimm, if your role is worth withholding at this stage, then surely it must be a prestigious role, no? f you have a minor role, or none at all, it may be best to claim now, to clear this up.

 

[Jeercrul]

I would prefer not to reveal my role.

 

[GmK]

///VOOOOOOOOTECOUNT///

Players needed to lynch: 11
Players needed to no-lynch: 10


Defiant_Blob - 1 - One One Two (L-10)
Kraby1 - 3 - Alpha102, Dessern5, Prizyms, (L-8)
Cooliorules - 3 - ansoro2112, hihihiLolHI, Omar_Sales (L-8)
Sploorky - 2 - Old_Man_Oak_63, storm886 (L-9)
grimmjowforever - 5 - balloon98, HypeBurst, Vatumok, cooliorules, 77_is_the_best (L-6)
balloon98 - 1 - grimmjowforever (L-10)

Abstaining - 1 - Shinyshark
NoLynch - 1 - K1ngHoward (NL-8)

Players not voting: kraby1, Jivvi, Defiant_Blob, digitalmez

 

[Jivvi]

Well, votes are spread across the board
We should try and tackle one issue at a time so that we actually get something done.

 

[cooliorules]

Grimm I'm not an investigative role?