The Doomed Cruise - Game [OVER AND OUT ]

Status
Not open for further replies.

cooliorules

That Awkward Noodle
Donor
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
1,512
Reaction score
2,478
Also now that I've read all the posts, while I was out at the dentist I was actually thinking exactly what grimm said in the second paragraph.
He used those that are dead, and said that they are their sepcific roles, to make us think "Oh, hey! He must be right!"
I'm going to unvote for now, will consider it a bit more as to who I will vote.

unvote
 

One one two

Per aspera ad astra
Donor
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
194
Reaction score
324
While I think grimm brings up some good points, it's nothing that can be considered as absolute as an investigation would be. Furthermore, if her role is worth protecting, I see no reason why she would hint to having an important one and then refuse to reveal it. Seems like a bluff to me.

I'm going to wait for Balloon's response before voting, though-- it does seem convenient to have investigated only dead players up to this point.

unvote
 

HypeBurst

Just Fabulous
Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
450
Reaction score
1,165
We definitely need Balloon's take on this. What Grimm said about balloon conveniently investigating all dead people is very sound in my opinion. But I just don't understand why if Balloon is a actually a mafia, why he would just kill himself because at the death of Grimm, Balloon would easily be the next target.

The only idea I have came up with is, the mafia have an investigative role of their own and have realised that Grimm is a strong town-sided power role, and they are sacrificing one of the grunts to get rid of Grimm. And the reason why it took so long for Balloon to post that was because they were deciding who would be sacrificed within the mafia.

But with that idea, comes the question, "why not just kill Grimm at night?", well there's so many power roles out there. Whether you choose to believe me that the passenger tracker is a town sided role or not is beside the point, there are Priz, Vat and I who have came out with these town sided roles and, from what I know, we should be gotten rid of too, so why not use this lynch opportunity to remove Grimm and they will be free to kill one of Priz Vat or Hype off?

But this could all be Grimm just playing with my head again so I'm not changing my vote and I'm waiting for Balloon to respond.
 

Alisha

Member
Mafia Host
Mafia Mod
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
805
Reaction score
2,829
This all happened while I was asleep? Okay, I need time to wake up and then I'll post my thoughts. Just one thing before I forget:

K1ng, you said there are three investigative roles? If balloon is a regular cop, and Vatumok had an inspect, who is the third?
 

Alisha

Member
Mafia Host
Mafia Mod
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
805
Reaction score
2,829
Okay, after rereading the posts after I woke up fully I noticed k1ng did say four. My mistake, I consider watcher/tracker different from typical investigation roles.

I'm not sure what to think. We trusted Vatumok when he claimed Jack of All Trades, yet balloon is different. Grimm raises a point in that his previous investigations were of dead people, yet of course she would undermine balloon because of being 'outed'.

I want everyone to remember: There could be a contact-styled role in this game.(Mafia sided investigative role)

unvote
 

Vatumok

Former CA
Joined
Aug 13, 2011
Messages
715
Reaction score
1,573
Grimm's story seems more credible than balloon's. I feel like there are a lot of holes in his story. For example his inspections, all dead people and people that were not really suspicious. I'd first like to see a few more posts of Grimm and balloon before making a final choice.
For now:
unvote
 

GmK

International Man Of Cake
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
2,987
Reaction score
5,686
///VOOOOOOOOTECOUNT///

Players needed to lynch: 11
Players needed to no-lynch: 10


Kraby1 - 1 - Dessern5, (L-10)
Cooliorules - 3 - ansoro2112, hihihiLolHI, Omar_Sales (L-8)
Sploorky - 2 - Old_Man_Oak_63, storm886 (L-9)
grimmjowforever - 3 - balloon98, HypeBurst, 77_is_the_best (L-8)
balloon98 - 1 - grimmjowforever (L-10)

Abstaining - 1 - Shinyshark
NoLynch - 1 - K1ngHoward (NL-8)

Players not voting: kraby1, Jivvi, Defiant_Blob, digitalmez, One One Two, cooliorules, Prizyms, Alpha102, Vatumok, Sploorky
 

Sploorky

Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2011
Messages
1,890
Reaction score
3,656
It's simple
Grimmjow is mafia, we can trust balloon.
If grimmjow is innocent we lynch balloon so of it'd be pretty dumb to just accuse him.

Before I make my vote though what exactly does it mean if someone is 'guilty'
(Sorry I'm a noob :D)
guilty=antitown. Be it mafia or third party.

And I'm on the same boat with omar, really. I'll wait for balloon's response before voting, but I just don't see why balloon would fake claim.
 

balloon98

The balloon that never pops
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
825
Reaction score
559
Ok so my role is called passenger police officer. Yes I do myself find it in a bad situation to have 2 of my investigations dead but that is why I didn't come out with it earlier. Also because of being extremely inactive which I apologize for. I understand the 4 investigating roles is peculiar so I will probably check out the others tonight but no I wouldn't fake proclaims since choosing you wouldn't make any sense to target compared to others. I felt this is what would happen since 2 of my investigations died but at this point I don't know what else I can do to make you guys trust me I mean this is my role and what I found that's all I got.

Now I know he is guilty but my role doesn't specifically name his role. I honestly came out with my role so I could actually have a reason to check this rather than watch for the sidelines gathering info and since some mafia are down it seemed like not a bad time to expose grimmjow
 

Omar_Sales

Squid
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
256
Reaction score
837
Well as stated before, it's probably the only leads we have.
The options are:
•Balloon is honest and grim is guilty, therefore 1 less threat to us
•Grim is innocent, we lynch balloon and he is an antitown
•Grim is innocent, balloon gets lynched and turns out to be townie aswell, but someone who gets innocent people lynched is better off dead.

In any case I think there's nothing but benefiting from grim's lynch. (If you are innocent grim your dead won't be in vain bby).

Disclaimer: Bold text might not come out right, trying to bold from a phone :S

unvote
vote grimmjowforever
 

GmK

International Man Of Cake
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
2,987
Reaction score
5,686
///VOOOOOTECOUNNNNNT///

Players needed to lynch: 11
Players needed to no-lynch: 10


Cooliorules - 2 - ansoro2112, hihihiLolHI, (L-9)
Sploorky - 2 - Old_Man_Oak_63, storm886 (L-9)
grimmjowforever - 6 - balloon98, HypeBurst, 77_is_the_best, Jivvi, Dessern5, Omar_Sales (L-5)
balloon98 - 1 - grimmjowforever (L-10)

Abstaining - 1 - Shinyshark
NoLynch - 1 - K1ngHoward (NL-9)

Players not voting: kraby1, Defiant_Blob, digitalmez, One One Two, cooliorules, Prizyms, Alpha102, Vatumok, Sploorky
 

Jeercrul

Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2012
Messages
343
Reaction score
502
I finally have the time to post now, thus I will address your concerns in this post.

The reason why I earlier refused to reveal my role because I saw no use in doing so, without people jumping at me and holding suspicions against me. It would also put me in a slight disadvantage if I were to survive the lynching, that's why I only planned to do so in worst-case scenario, that is, if people still refused to believe me.

I am the 5-Shot Cult Psychiatrist. I am given 5 chances to choose a random player, without knowing their roles, to try to convert them into passive townies. If I hit a cult member (other than the cult leader), they will lose a member on their side and the player would be converted. So far I have only targeted OMO on the second night. Results were negative. However I myself am not too sure about the existence of a cult in this game, being told an ambiguous reply about the existence of a cult in the game.

My purpose here is not to convince you to immediately believe me and unvote. My purpose here is to inform you of my role, and hopefully, turn the flipped tables around. It is up to you to choose to trust me. I am also here to tell you to go through the past pages and judge for yourself on whether I am innocent or not, of course, with careful consideration and rational thinking. Of course, I hope to survive as it would be more advantageous though at the mercy of being recruited into a cult at night whose status is indefinite. Again, as stated, you are free to investigate me if I were to survive this day.

There is not much I can do at this point. I have already presented my arguments against balloon, and right now I am simply making a clarification; you are to judge for yourself. All I wanted to say has been said. I wish myself best of luck.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top