What I actually think is that (if there are remaining mafia) they did not vote for 112. I assume the mafia would not all go for the same tactic and vote for 112, maybe it's someone that is trying to fly under the radar like hihihilol.
The Doomed Cruise - Game [OVER AND OUT ]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
- Status
I feel like I should take back my vote and vote for you now squid. People who start with O are obviously noobs. :b
Alpha, you mentioned how my vote is based on how I feel. You're right, there is no clear logic.
What I do know is, throughout the seasons I've played Mafia with Ansoro, his game style is usually passive. I find it out of character for Ansoro to make these accusations and risk his position in the game. I can't help but believe him. It seems like a whim and I'm basing my vote on a hunch.
Part 1
First of all let's start since vatu became an important influence in the game.
Here he weeded out endersteve and after he got lynched he earned people's trust, including mine. Let's recall what happened with prizyms and 112, same thing could've happened here.
Let's recall to what vatu said last round. Paying close attention to what he said he claimed myuser to be innocent and then he asked for the doctor to protect him. My theory is e wanted to hog the doctor so they didn't protect myuser and the mafia could kill him, showing that vatu was right, furthering his trust. (JOAT can be mafia aswell btw)
It's funny he had this idea, why does playing 'against' their own mafia sound familiar?
Now it just seems to me he's trying to call out as mafia whoever he can since he has the trust of the town.
Nice guess!
Vatu calling out on notty again to which prizyms supports with a bad argument that notty countered.
But in the end notty got lynched.
He kept on bluffing if he was a power role or not which is why I think the mafia got him. He also was 'suspicious' according to Vatu in the last night.
Here he weeded out endersteve and after he got lynched he earned people's trust, including mine. Let's recall what happened with prizyms and 112, same thing could've happened here.
nitasu987 - Passenger Bodyguard - was killed
mariosatr - Passenger Protective Detail (Jailkeeper*) - was killed
infernofox - Passenger - was killed
myusername22 - Passenger - was killed
Let's recall to what vatu said last round. Paying close attention to what he said he claimed myuser to be innocent and then he asked for the doctor to protect him. My theory is e wanted to hog the doctor so they didn't protect myuser and the mafia could kill him, showing that vatu was right, furthering his trust. (JOAT can be mafia aswell btw)
It's funny he had this idea, why does playing 'against' their own mafia sound familiar?
Now it just seems to me he's trying to call out as mafia whoever he can since he has the trust of the town.
Nice guess!
Vatu calling out on notty again to which prizyms supports with a bad argument that notty countered.
But in the end notty got lynched.
Ooglie101, a Passenger, was killed
He kept on bluffing if he was a power role or not which is why I think the mafia got him. He also was 'suspicious' according to Vatu in the last night.
Ansoro2112
Hottie
I think I didn't actually used PM mechanics actually. I revealed my role. Said what I can do in different words.
Now, if Jivvi was clever enough to think about looking back to his PM and making sure it was the same then not my fault I guess.
Now, if Jivvi was clever enough to think about looking back to his PM and making sure it was the same then not my fault I guess.
After re-reading that it sounds like it was close enough that Jivvi could identify with it. Unless the passenger roles all have different text, this is a serious game-balancing problem. It does say in the rules that it's okay to paraphrase, but that seems like it went ultra-specific within the paraphrase. I would like to hear from GmK as well.
I'm going to stop responding to arguments until this is worked out, as this gives knowledge that we shouldn't have.
I'm going to stop responding to arguments until this is worked out, as this gives knowledge that we shouldn't have.
Defiant_Blob
(￣^￣)ゞ
((Silently acknowledging that you have similar PMs would be okay.
However, you're actually using it as an argument.
You're telling other Passengers to look at their PM and compare it to yours, which is PM Mechanics.
The first paraphrase of the PM was okay, but then you extended what Jivvi said.
It was a mistake, yes, but it's provided info as Alpha stated we shouldn't have.))
Ansoro2112
Hottie
Ah! I get it now. To be honest I tried to be careful with that rule. Before I revealed my role I actually asked 2 questions just to make sure I was not going to break the rule. But it was Jivvi who did catch that at the end. I think the rule is a bit confusing in my opinion. Or at least for me sinc eits like my first time playing the game. So I'm sorry if I did crossed the line.
Guess we'll wait for Gmk.
Omar_Sales
Yeah, I didn't get it right every time, gosh, I have to be mafia. I do not really follow you Omar. After I have used my abilities I just have as much chance to find a mafia as a normal passenger.
Also, why would the mafia do the same trick twice? That sounds rather silly.
If you think I'm guilty because I said that possibly there are no mafia in the game: I felt like it had to be said that it's possible there is none anymore and that I would be able to say it without looking very suspicious.
I'm not sure why I'm still alive but it's 1. Doctor, 2. Maf scared of doctor protection, 3. More important roles have priority.
Yeah, I didn't get it right every time, gosh, I have to be mafia. I do not really follow you Omar. After I have used my abilities I just have as much chance to find a mafia as a normal passenger.
Also, why would the mafia do the same trick twice? That sounds rather silly.
If you think I'm guilty because I said that possibly there are no mafia in the game: I felt like it had to be said that it's possible there is none anymore and that I would be able to say it without looking very suspicious.
I'm not sure why I'm still alive but it's 1. Doctor, 2. Maf scared of doctor protection, 3. More important roles have priority.
GmK
International Man Of Cake
///VOOOOOTECOUNNNNNT///
Players needed to lynch: 8
Players needed to no-lynch: 7
Sploorky - 1 - storm886 (L-7)
ansoro2112 - 1 - Defiant_Blob (L-7)
Alpha102 - 2 - digitalmez, ansoro2112 (L-6)
Players not voting: Shinyshark, Jivvi, cooliorules, Old_Man_Oak_63, hihihiLolHI, Alpha102, Sploorky, Vatumok, 77_is_the_best, Omar_Sales
Concerning the PM mechanic: It is like Defiant_Blob states, unfortunately I did not catch it fast enough to edit, but please from now on refrain using PMs as basis for reasonings, etc. The rule is there for a reason.
Players needed to lynch: 8
Players needed to no-lynch: 7
Sploorky - 1 - storm886 (L-7)
ansoro2112 - 1 - Defiant_Blob (L-7)
Alpha102 - 2 - digitalmez, ansoro2112 (L-6)
Players not voting: Shinyshark, Jivvi, cooliorules, Old_Man_Oak_63, hihihiLolHI, Alpha102, Sploorky, Vatumok, 77_is_the_best, Omar_Sales
Concerning the PM mechanic: It is like Defiant_Blob states, unfortunately I did not catch it fast enough to edit, but please from now on refrain using PMs as basis for reasonings, etc. The rule is there for a reason.
As I said before I didn't post everything because it's too long and I can't get too arrange it properly on my phone. I'll do it later today, on my way to school right now
- Status