The Red Scare [Game Over]

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
I feel like this game has gotten a bit quiet, possibly because it seems nobody is by a computer and can't be asked to type on phone, or just nothing happened. I do strongly believe that Inf is Maf, and if that is the case then I am also suspicious of Notty due to Interations between them. Aqua and Samlen have been quieter than I expected, can I hear anything from you about suspicons (also I don't know if Unu is TWG's sibling and has been posting some things on his behalf but would still like to hear from TheWeakGuy48_ )
Why do you 'strongly' believe I'm mafia just because of the joke though? Like, even aqua has admitted that this reason is trashy now, why can't you do the same ;-;

Sorry but I'm very much aware that I have the most votes and I'm trying to 1) understand why and 2) get them off me
 

Enderfive

sarcasm incarnate
Mafia Host
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4,802
You also asked for cult leaders to say who they were, with Infected (I think would be a bad thing if we lost our cult leaders and if mafias knew who they were, they could easily be targeted at nights).
please explain to me why i, town or otherwise, should care about the cult leaders surviving or not even slightly

i did have a purpose when i asked the cult leaders to out themself, namely to see if there'd be more than two claims, in which case it would've been much easier to decide on a lynch; notty can back that up as i hinted at this when i first asked the cult leaders to out and i'm pretty sure she of all people would've gotten the hint

These are three moves that would be benefitual for the mafias.
explain how, otherwise you might as well be saying that the sky is red and human beings have seven legs and you'd have about as much credibility as you do now


meanwhile inf discovers aqua is a moron who values my opinion because i'm his friend and he thinks for some reason that i'm not as big a moron as he is, what a surprise

honestly this game is getting more ridiculous by the minute (yes thank you i realise i'm to blame as well)
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
i did have a purpose when i asked the cult leaders to out themself, namely to see if there'd be more than two claims, in which case it would've been much easier to decide on a lynch; notty can back that up as i hinted at this when i first asked the cult leaders to out and i'm pretty sure she of all people would've gotten the hint
Actually I didn't, I was too focussed on Infected as it seemed obvious to me he wanted the other cult leader to out so that he could win the game day 0.
 

Fog

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 24, 2012
Messages
62
Reaction score
991
Why do you 'strongly' believe I'm mafia just because of the joke though? Like, even aqua has admitted that this reason is trashy now, why can't you do the same ;-;

Sorry but I'm very much aware that I have the most votes and I'm trying to 1) understand why and 2) get them off me
It's a mix of the joke, and the way you're acting you seem TOO cheesy... I can't say 100% cause im not cop ;) but I have them VIBES
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Actually I didn't, I was too focussed on Infected as it seemed obvious to me he wanted the other cult leader to out so that he could win the game day 0.
I wanted them to out because it would mean one less mislynch we'd have to go through as town, and to be honest it kinda striked me as odd that you always seemed to take on the cult leader's mindset on everything - like, you were always thinking with the 'Cult Leader hat' and it made me question whether you were one yourself, but then I scratched that idea after you sabotaged my plans to get the other cult leader to out since I figured, if you were cult leader yourself, you'd pretend to agree and try to get them to out just in case it wasn't me, but thinking about it, if you were so convinced it was me, then maybe you wouldn't, in which case maybe you're cult leader after all...dundundun...I mean if you are I don't care because they don't effect me but yeah

It's a mix of the joke, and the way you're acting you seem TOO cheesy... I can't say 100% cause im not cop ;) but I have them VIBES
Where have I been 'cheesy'?

meanwhile inf discovers aqua is a moron who values my opinion because i'm his friend and he thinks for some reason that i'm not as big a moron as he is, what a surprise

honestly this game is getting more ridiculous by the minute (yes thank you i realise i'm to blame as well)
I mean I always knew he was a moron but if he's town then he can't be sure that you're not mafia, so the fact he's being so buddy-buddy with you is weird to me.
 

Enderfive

sarcasm incarnate
Mafia Host
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4,802
....if I read that right. how would lynching a cult leader be a mislynch? we wouldn't be getting mafia but they're still not town
considering how they probably count against the mafia, i'd say they count as a mislynch too

just not one that's as detrimental to town as an actual townie mislynch
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Actually Ender why are you still voting me when there are people you think are Mafia who also voted jivvi, when you said you'd want to look in people who voted jivvi for maf? Just because my name popped out more or something? How is that any more valid than lunching based on play styles? Like, what?

I can't shake the feeling off that all game you've tried to get me lynched just because it's me and it's probably easier than getting a lot of others lynched (especially since right now I have the most votes).

Now, if this theory is right, Ender voted me after I became suspicious of HK and Samlen day 0. But he's put Samlen in suspicion, and when I still had suspicion on HK today along with others, oh look, he's still voting me. He's also said that voting on play styles isn't valid (well, not explicitly said it but implied it), which would discard my vote for HK, and then proceeded to vote me for a reason even more ridiculous. I'm sorry Ender but you're becoming more and more suspicious to me the more I think about you. If Ender and HK are Mafia together it would make sense that Ender would try to protect him, especially since HK is new and so would probably need some help. This would also explain HK's vibes this game. Just a theory.
 

Aqua

Does anybody remember laughter?
Mafia Host
Joined
Mar 29, 2015
Messages
640
Reaction score
2,808
Foggy2406 been really busy recently, which is why I haven't been posting, plus cba to read thru all the shit, tho it seems ntohing important has really come up yet so it doesn't rly matter...

also on the subject of the cult leaders, are both leaders town, or could one leader be mafia?
 

Enderfive

sarcasm incarnate
Mafia Host
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4,802
fact is you're omgusing me right now, and i'm not saying that your reasoning doesn't make sense from your point of view, but i don't think you'd be seeing it as clearly as you think you do if i had voted anyone else besides you in the same manner

i, once again, posit the question: who do you think i should vote, if not you? it's not like i think any of the players alive actually deserve the vote, as things are right now
 

Oak Milk

Kill Hungry Thirsty Dead
Mafia Host
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
1,267
Reaction score
1,922
Alright well to start off with I'm going to say this first and I have to repeat myself again from now on you will be getting a vote from me.

Voting someone based on how they have played in previous games is meta and you should not, nor should you ever count it as serious evidence. People using it as the basis of their vote need to understand that people can change the way they play. If you really understand a person that well, then it shouldn't be difficult for you to actually find something they have done wrong and vote for them based on that.

Right, rant over.

At this point a lot of stuff has and hasn't happened, personally I feel like most of it is irrelevant, yes there have been a lot of people spouting who they think is suspicious who is connected to who etc. etc. but the issue is that ultimately, we've had all this talk and yet we haven't gotten anything out of it. Just a whole bunch of circlejerking. So let's fix that by starting at the worst offender.

vote Infected_Alien
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Foggy2406 been really busy recently, which is why I haven't been posting, plus cba to read thru all the shit, tho it seems ntohing important has really come up yet so it doesn't rly matter...

also on the subject of the cult leaders, are both leaders town, or could one leader be mafia?
I mean if you're too busy to play maybe ask for a replacement instead of just refusing to read through because you "cba"

And the cult leaders are neither town or Mafia, they're third party

fact is you're omgusing me right now, and i'm not saying that your reasoning doesn't make sense from your point of view, but i don't think you'd be seeing it as clearly as you think you do if i had voted anyone else besides you in the same manner

i, once again, posit the question: who do you think i should vote, if not you? it's not like i think any of the players alive actually deserve the vote, as things are right now
I really don't understand your first paragraph so could you reword that please

To answer your question, how about any of the other people that you have said you think are Mafia, people who aren't actively scumhunting and helping like I am, or even people who I've literally just made several points against. There are plenty of people in this game who have fair points made against them, and I am not one of them, yet you choose to vote for me because people like oak are likely to sheep you and you get an easy lynch?

Speaking of which:

Alright well to start off with I'm going to say this first and I have to repeat myself again from now on you will be getting a vote from me.

Voting someone based on how they have played in previous games is meta and you should not, nor should you ever count it as serious evidence. People using it as the basis of their vote need to understand that people can change the way they play. If you really understand a person that well, then it shouldn't be difficult for you to actually find something they have done wrong and vote for them based on that.

Right, rant over.

At this point a lot of stuff has and hasn't happened, personally I feel like most of it is irrelevant, yes there have been a lot of people spouting who they think is suspicious who is connected to who etc. etc. but the issue is that ultimately, we've had all this talk and yet we haven't gotten anything out of it. Just a whole bunch of circlejerking. So let's fix that by starting at the worst offender.

vote Infected_Alien[/QUOTE

Okay first of all, you can deny the validity of playstyle arguments. Yes, some people change the way they play so yes it's not 100% evidence to use against someone, but it's an observation that could mean something else, and you can't just pretend that's not a fact. And no, just because you notice someone's playstyle change that does not mean you're going to have an easy time finding something more concrete. Like, this point just doesn't make any sense to me.

Next, what? Why are you voting me? For being the biggest "offender"? Offender of what exactly? Of talking a lot? Of having the most votes? I'm sorry but this is so ridiculous. Like what? Ender votes me because I pop into his head, despite the fact that he and others have pointed out several other people who have actual points made against them, foggy votes me because somehow me making a bad joke is uncharacteristic of me as a townie (do you even know me hello?), iggy still hasn't explained why he's suspicious of me and then just to top it all off, you swing in and vote me for basically no reason whatsoever. Like what is even happening right now? Is there anyone in this game who isn't trying to kill me for stupid reasons and ignoring the fact that I've been actively scumhunting unlike many others, or ignoring the other suspects in the game who actually have decent points made against them by myself or unusual or igg?

Sorry if this post comes off as a bit aggressive but I'm just so bewildered by what is happening and can't believe how yet again I am going to be lynched early on for trying to help town. Loads of people jumped on the jivvi bandwagon, even when I contradicted their views on lynching, but no, let's vote for the only person who tried to stop town from killing the cop Kappa. Lots of people have been lurking or had points made against them but no let's get inf because he sure talks a lot and helps a lot and so he must be Mafia Kappa. Oh he made a joke, must be Mafia Kappa. Oh he wondered why hip of all people was killed, must be justifying his kill in the thread or if we don't like that idea lets come up with a super convulted theory as to how it possibly *could* be inf and roll with that. Then let's make empty points against him which are recycled from others and make no sense and kill him off. Like seriously is no one seeing what is happening? I'm losing hope
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
In response to oak (it's in my oak quote above because mobile sucks but reposting so everyone sees. Also the broken images are where I say k.appa)

Okay first of all, you can deny the validity of playstyle arguments. Yes, some people change the way they play so yes it's not 100% evidence to use against someone, but it's an observation that could mean something else, and you can't just pretend that's not a fact. And no, just because you notice someone's playstyle change that does not mean you're going to have an easy time finding something more concrete. Like, this point just doesn't make any sense to me.

Next, what? Why are you voting me? For being the biggest "offender"? Offender of what exactly? Of talking a lot? Of having the most votes? I'm sorry but this is so ridiculous. Like what? Ender votes me because I pop into his head, despite the fact that he and others have pointed out several other people who have actual points made against them, foggy votes me because somehow me making a bad joke is uncharacteristic of me as a townie (do you even know me hello?), iggy still hasn't explained why he's suspicious of me and then just to top it all off, you swing in and vote me for basically no reason whatsoever. Like what is even happening right now? Is there anyone in this game who isn't trying to kill me for stupid reasons and ignoring the fact that I've been actively scumhunting unlike many others, or ignoring the other suspects in the game who actually have decent points made against them by myself or unusual or igg?

Sorry if this post comes off as a bit aggressive but I'm just so bewildered by what is happening and can't believe how yet again I am going to be lynched early on for trying to help town. Loads of people jumped on the jivvi bandwagon, even when I contradicted their views on lynching, but no, let's vote for the only person who tried to stop town from killing the cop kappa. Lots of people have been lurking or had points made against them but no let's get inf because he sure talks a lot and helps a lot and so he must be Mafia kappa. Oh he made a joke, must be Mafia kappa. Oh he wondered why hip of all people was killed, must be justifying his kill in the thread or if we don't like that idea lets come up with a super convulted theory as to how it possibly *could* be inf and roll with that. Then let's make empty points against him which are recycled from others and make no sense and kill him off. Like seriously is no one seeing what is happening? I'm losing hope
 
Top