The Red Scare [Game Over]

[Aqua]

I agree with ender.
Nottykitten I rated your post confusing because I genuinely didn't understand what you meant btw, although I don't really agree with the whole inf thinking hip is vig bit, I still don't really get your point at all.

I can't find the quote but I'm fairly sure inf said earlier this game his reason for suspecting hip was that he was being awfully quiet, and since inf knows hip very well and knows his play style, he found that scummy af. HOWEVER, last game hip only posted once or twice every day just to vote for people iirc and he was townie, if I'm right and inf did say that (WHICH I SWEAR HE DID, BUT I CAN'T FIND THE QUOTE); that seems pretty damn bs to me.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Ngl there are more but quite busy atm, maybe if I'm free will have a better look. But the first page I turn to and I see this, you were being grilled by multiple people and seemed almost desperate to throw suspicion to me using the same point you had previously brought up over and over. The fact you underline it and put it in bold seems almost theatrical you drama nerd. If you were actually townie I odubt you'd try and shift focus onto someone like that, it seems desperate. IDK, I might be wrong, I haven't put much thought into this tbh.

ANYWAY POINT IS, UR ACTING SCUMMY AF NGL WITH UR HUNTER-ESQUE PLAY STYLE SO FUCK YOU SCUMMY MCSCUMFUCK

Yes because as a townie when I'm getting lynched for stupid reasons I'm totally not going to call people out on said stupid reasons and be suspicious of people who have points against them and point them out to everyone in an attempt to lynch an actual mafia this game. All of that is mafia behavior kaappa

People keep comparing me to hunter but like, pretty sure hunter just tunnel visioned people and acted aggressive. I've been kinda an asshole this game and passive aggressive I admit (and am sorry for) but I'm not tunneling anyone - for that I'd suggest looking into a mirror.

yeah i haven't had the time to catch up with this properly right now but i will say that notty is being nitpicky to the point of absurdity right now

it was pretty straightforward to me that when foggy talked about inf thinking hip acted strangely, then he was referring to the whole playstyle argument he'd had against him day 0, even if "strange" wasn't the precise word he used

I mean yes this is what he meant, but he's basing his argument on assuming that I found hip to be acting strangely, strangely including the fact he could be PR, but there is no reason for him to think this at all, because I simply pointed out that hip was acting as he did when he was mafia last time (and if you guys need proof on that then go read past games and see for yourself0

 

[Nottykitten]

it was pretty straightforward to me that when foggy talked about inf thinking hip acted strangely, then he was referring to the whole playstyle argument he'd had against him day 0, even if "strange" wasn't the precise word he used

I mean he did underline it the word felt pretty important. Sure I'm being nitpicky I just dont find Foggy's arguments to be anything other than nonsense and a gut feeling.

Speaking of gut feelings and being nitpicky.

I forgot Jivvi was a cop.... ignore me

Am I the only one who feels as if this was scripted? People townread Iggish because he made a mistake about the setup and Aqua is trying to do the same here.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I agree with ender.
Nottykitten I rated your post confusing because I genuinely didn't understand what you meant btw, although I don't really agree with the whole inf thinking hip is vig bit, I still don't really get your point at all.

I can't find the quote but I'm fairly sure inf said earlier this game his reason for suspecting hip was that he was being awfully quiet, and since inf knows hip very well and knows his play style, he found that scummy af. HOWEVER, last game hip only posted once or twice every day just to vote for people iirc and he was townie, if I'm right and inf did say that (WHICH I SWEAR HE DID, BUT I CAN'T FIND THE QUOTE); that seems pretty damn bs to me.

No, last game hip was a lot more vocal, which was partly the basis for my argument, if you bothered to read the thread.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Am I the only one who feels as if this was scripted? People townread Iggish because he made a mistake about the setup and Aqua is trying to do the same here.

Actually yeah I didn't think about that... I mean it's highly unlikely aqua would actually forget we lynched the cop. It's been said like 10000 times this game.

 

[Fog]

for that I'd suggest looking into a mirror.

OOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHH BUUUUUUUUUUUUUURRRRRRRRRNNNNNNNNNN!

 

[Iggish]

I called TWG out for seemingly trying to slip under the radar and just ride the game out. I feel that I can't have nay integrity if I don't do the same to Mooglie.
Mooglie (like TWG) has only really responded when asked a question and his opinion has been a bit sheepish (IMO).
Is anyone else a bit suspicious of him aswell or is it just me getting those vibes off him?

 

[Enderfive]

I mean yes this is what he meant, but he's basing his argument on assuming that I found hip to be acting strangely, strangely including the fact he could be PR, but there is no reason for him to think this at all, because I simply pointed out that hip was acting as he did when he was mafia last time (and if you guys need proof on that then go read past games and see for yourself0

i mean i haven't really kept up with what he's really saying

i just found it odd that notty was being so excessively agressive about the exact wording of the argument, even when the meaning was clear as something else

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I called TWG out for seemingly trying to slip under the radar and just ride the game out. I feel that I can't have nay integrity if I don't do the same to Mooglie.
Mooglie (like TWG) has only really responded when asked a question and his opinion has been a bit sheepish (IMO).
Is anyone else a bit suspicious of him aswell or is it just me getting those vibes off him?

I mean to be honest I've been a bit confused about moog this game, because, he has been acting in a very similar way (vibe-wise) to how he acted in Zambie (in my opinion), which was the only other game I've been mafia with him in so far. But obviously this is subjective and I was wrong about hip's playstyle thing so I'm not exactly trusting of this right now, and also the things oog has said have made me town-read him (maybe because he's come to the same conclusions as me most of the time (if not all the time), which suggests he's having the same thought processes as me, which suggests he has the same win condition as me. So I kinda town-read him but I do think his activity and posts are interesting. There are definitely bigger suspects than him in my eyes though so I'm not willing to lynch him today.

 

[Nottykitten]

i just found it odd that notty was being so excessively agressive about the exact wording of the argument, even when the meaning was clear as something else

I'd argue that acting 'strange' and acting 'the same as before' are quite the opposite things, and I'm being nitpicky about it because I find it shows how Foggy is just making up things to try and justify his vote.

 

[Fog]

the only other game I've been mafia with him

so the plot thickens

 

[Infected_alien8_]

which was the only other game I've been mafia with him in so far.

which was the only game I've been in where he was mafia so far*

I was town in that game

 

[Deleted member 4601]

Did I consider the fact he was PR? How was I supposed to know he was cop? Same goes with everyone who voted for him? There was a small chance he was PR, we were unlucky.

I forgot Jivvi was a cop.... ignore me

What kind of a slip is this

 

[Iggish]

and also the things oog has said have made me town-read him (maybe because he's come to the same conclusions as me most of the time (if not all the time), which suggests he's having the same thought processes as me, which suggests he has the same win condition as me.

Or he could just be trying to fit in by agreeing with people.

 

[Aqua]

No, last game hip was a lot more vocal, which was partly the basis for my argument, if you bothered to read the thread.

absolute bullshit, the two days before he died he posted like 5 messages total p.sure

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Or he could just be trying to fit in by agreeing with people.

Maybe but the person who he's agreed with in the past was me when I was looking to be lynched, so if he was just trying to fit in I imagine he'd vote against me with the others, which is probably also why I town-read him

 

[Aqua]

What kind of a slip is this

A "not a slip" kind?

 

[Deleted member 4601]

A "not a slip" kind?

Do explain how you managed to forget about it though

 

[Iggish]

Do explain how you managed to forget about it though

Maybe someone was tired again

 

[Aqua]

Do explain how you managed to forget about it though

I just came home from 3 hours of lecture, I opened escr I saw that, I thought that, I wrote it without thinking.

I don't understand how that could even be conceived as scummy unless you thought I was actually trying to convince people he was a cop while knowing full well jivvi was the only cop, which is kinda... stupid?

 

[Aqua]

Maybe someone was tired again

I don't want to take shit from a child >:[

 

[Infected_alien8_]

absolute bullshit, the two days before he died he posted like 5 messages total p.sure

That's irrelevant? He was more vocal last game on day 0 than this game at least, which is what made me suspicious (though looking back I don't think he was that much more, which I guess explains how he's innocent and suggests my memory failed me a little bit)

 

[Deleted member 4601]

I just came home from 3 hours of lecture, I opened escr I saw that, I thought that, I wrote it without thinking.

I don't understand how that could even be conceived as scummy unless you thought I was actually trying to convince people he was a cop while knowing full well jivvi was the only cop, which is kinda... stupid?

Nah, just clarifying.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I don't understand how that could even be conceived as scummy unless you thought I was actually trying to convince people he was a cop while knowing full well jivvi was the only cop, which is kinda... stupid?

Am I the only one who feels as if this was scripted? People townread Iggish because he made a mistake about the setup and Aqua is trying to do the same here.

 

[Aqua]

That's irrelevant? He was more vocal last game on day 0 than this game at least, which is what made me suspicious (though looking back I don't think he was that much more, which I guess explains how he's innocent and suggests my memory failed me a little bit)

How's that irrelevant, the reason he was very inactive last game towards the end probably was because there was so little to go on, that's the same with day 0's, he may have been more active day 0 last game but so was I, it's such a medial difference and you were against him with such confidence that he was scummy, it seems forced.