I suppose our lack of an undertaker is part of what is supposed to make this game confusing =S Was hoping someone was going to try and protect OMO after he claimed such a role... Ooglie's claim is an interesting way to start a day, looks like we're a bit closer to finding a Pirate, assuming we trust Ooglie's claim, though the possibility of him being paranoid or lying is there. If he's legit, we get a Pirate lynched today. If he's Paranoid, we'll probably lynch a Pirate tomorrow. If he's lying, then he's a Pirate/anti-town and we lynch him. Of course, if he is lying, then we don't want to spend 3 days worth of lynching to find that out. I'm waiting here for now and re-scanning pages before I come to anything conclusive.
Trouble in the West: Pirates vs Cowboys [Finished]
- Thread starter Prizyms
- Start date
- Status
I believe that Ooglie is telling the truth.
Look.
If you believe his claim and his investigation, then fine, vote for me. All I can say is that I am, for a fact, part of town. I'm Abhorrent Adam. My role in some ways makes me invincible, and yes, I do have the ability to potentially hurt or kill someone. BUT - let me reassure you that none of the night kills (so far) were my doing.
I read thoroughly and try to take in to account suspicions and hunches that come with proper explanations. Let me tell you now that I'm very particular with how I work my role and treat it with the utmost amount of responsibility.
That is my truth.
So @Ooglie101 how exactly do your abilities work? Do you just give a name and then you're given a guilty or not guilty answer?
Look.
If you believe his claim and his investigation, then fine, vote for me. All I can say is that I am, for a fact, part of town. I'm Abhorrent Adam. My role in some ways makes me invincible, and yes, I do have the ability to potentially hurt or kill someone. BUT - let me reassure you that none of the night kills (so far) were my doing.
I read thoroughly and try to take in to account suspicions and hunches that come with proper explanations. Let me tell you now that I'm very particular with how I work my role and treat it with the utmost amount of responsibility.
That is my truth.
So @Ooglie101 how exactly do your abilities work? Do you just give a name and then you're given a guilty or not guilty answer?
Pre-Note: I'm writing this post as I go through, things may become obsolete, ignore those things. Things also may be slightly incoherent, if you would like clarifications for such things, ask and I will provide. Citations will be included for anyone that wishes to see the quotes in their given context, as the little hyperlink arrow that comes with proper quotes will not be present. That said, on to the post.
Pre-Note-Post-Writing: This was intended to be a compilation of anything I found suspicious, but after 25 pages...All I really found was Swate o-o I will continue reading, but I feel that all this this is plenty enough to warrant a vote on Swate....and pretty much all of this is from D1....HOW DID NO ONE FIND ANY OF THIS SOONER?
- Ansoro #251 P11
-Swate #541 P2
-Swate #548 P22
-Swate #554 P23
Samlen said stuff, too!
Samlen, presumably in response to my apparent confusion, elaborated with:
-Swate #587/8 P24
-Samlen #591 P24
-Swate #594 P24
So to finish this post off:
I believe Swate to be mafia, and Ooglie to be the paranoid cop, and by extension, Digi to be cleared.
Pre-Note-Post-Writing: This was intended to be a compilation of anything I found suspicious, but after 25 pages...All I really found was Swate o-o I will continue reading, but I feel that all this this is plenty enough to warrant a vote on Swate....and pretty much all of this is from D1....HOW DID NO ONE FIND ANY OF THIS SOONER?
This is more or less a stand alone. I have nothing to add to this, but I agree with it.nsor said:
- Ansoro #251 P11
***
ivv said:
Yes, he included a jest, but that doesn't make the whole thing ok....Endersteve also noticed this, I applaud him. Swate's response was as follows:wat said:What resources?our time? Our money? Our goshdern armadillers boi?
His explanation was that he missed part of the post...a one line post....I'm not buying it. Neither did Ender, further applause ensues. Ender stated that he would be keeping his vote on Swate, Swate responded with what I read to be an appeal to emotion.wat said:
-Swate #488 P20wat said:
-Swate #541 P2
-Swate #548 P22
***
While I'm on the subject of Swate, he didn't voice any of his own suspicion until 77 did. Let's have a look at this statement:
It just sounds to me like he's trying to agree with him by saying "seems a little scummy I guess," but saying that he doesn't really find him all that scummy, "he doesn't necessarily appear overly scummy." And then that last part, Swate and Fiesta are good friends, aren't they? I don't know Fiesta all that well, but even I know that that's just Fiesta's personality, hell he even said so D0. It went something along the lines of "I'm an impatient bastard when it comes to this."wat said:
-Swate #554 P23
***
Samlen said stuff, too!
Swate's initial response was:amle said:
He said he didn't want to respond because it would give people more stuff to use against him...Well, I'm using that against him, how Ironic. That last part didn't even make sense..."I'm gonna shut up so others talk so it's fair" ...How does defending yourself make it unfair to other players? I feel that's just an excuse to divert attention. However, Swate very quickly retracted that response, before anyone could even respond to it:wat said:
The following post was me being really stupid....wtf did I even mean by it? I assume I just misunderstood Samlen's post, but looking back now it makes sense x3wat said:
Samlen, presumably in response to my apparent confusion, elaborated with:
Instead of responding with the promised "legitimate, intelligible response" referenced above, Swate simply changed the subject with another appeal to emotion (see my first section on Swate) and a vote on OMO. From what I can tell, this went unnoticed. Until now...dun dun dunamle said:
-Samlen #586 P24Swate said:Ah hell, I really want to vote for OMO as he was my main suspicion yesterday too, but I'm afraid to show my opinion which is just as valuable as the opinions of the other four people that have already voted for him.I feel chained, I can't do a single thing without people cherry-picking ways as to how what I do is "mafia-like." Don't care. Voting for him as he continues to give off the Mafia vibe to me, alongside other suspicious things that happened yesterday which I'm too lazy to type (also in class so I'm trying to finish this comment quick), the biggest tip-off for me though is the still-unexplained slip-up.
Vote Old_Man_Oak_63
-Swate #587/8 P24
-Samlen #591 P24
-Swate #594 P24
So to finish this post off:
I believe Swate to be mafia, and Ooglie to be the paranoid cop, and by extension, Digi to be cleared.
Ansoro2112
Hottie
Omg finally not all the cops die in the beginning of the game! So even if Ooglie's paranoid it will still help is a lot. Now, I'm hoping we really have a doctor.
Digi's post seem real to me but before I vote for someone I think we really need to hear from @Swate
Digi's post seem real to me but before I vote for someone I think we really need to hear from @Swate
HypeBurst
Just Fabulous
Its insane or something, just not paranoid. I still have memories of @ansoro2112 's first mafia game where he claimed paranoid cop which was extremely silly and funny at the same time.
HypeBurst
Just Fabulous
Yes, but you seemed certain in your statement that Ooglie was the insane one, whereas your postzilla is simply mild suspicions. Swate has made some suspicious posts which did trigger my FoS, but I'm certainly not 100% certain that he is evil or not.
I don't want to claim yet I could get killed in the night.
Awhh..
I am Warden Warren, from what I read he is the equivalent of the Jailer role. Each night, I get to basically "abduct" a person and have a night meeting where only I and them are the people in the meeting. If I want, I can also kill them, but I don't learn their alignment or role from the meeting.
This means that, unless Ooglie's cop readings are that cop type which is completely randomised, Digi is definitely Mafia.
Vote digitalmez
I could get killed in the night.Awhh..
I am Warden Warren, from what I read he is the equivalent of the Jailer role. Each night, I get to basically "abduct" a person and have a night meeting where only I and them are the people in the meeting. If I want, I can also kill them, but I don't learn their alignment or role from the meeting.
This means that, unless Ooglie's cop readings are that cop type which is completely randomised, Digi is definitely Mafia.
Vote digitalmez
Woah! Hold on...I don't want to claim yet
Awhh..
I am Warden Warren, from what I read he is the equivalent of the Jailer role. Each night, I get to basically "abduct" a person and have a night meeting where only I and them are the people in the meeting. If I want, I can also kill them, but I don't learn their alignment or role from the meeting.
This means that, unless Ooglie's cop readings are that cop type which is completely randomised, Digi is definitely Mafia.
Vote digitalmez
How am I definitely Mafia? Your lack of experience shows when you don't consider the other options. I can DEFINITELY tell you now that I am DEFINITELY not Mafia.
I'd like to know how Ooglie's role works.
Hey look! Another appeal to emotion!I don't want to claim yet
Awhh..
I am Warden Warren, from what I read he is the equivalent of the Jailer role. Each night, I get to basically "abduct" a person and have a night meeting where only I and them are the people in the meeting. If I want, I can also kill them, but I don't learn their alignment or role from the meeting.
This means that, unless Ooglie's cop readings are that cop type which is completely randomised, Digi is definitely Mafia.
Vote digitalmez
But Swate, I was more looking for you to dissolve my argument rather than just claim.
This is a bit of a weaker point, but in running with the theme, we already have two sheriffs, I think they'd be able to handle the jail themselves.
And if I may, I'm going to pick at your words to say why I think your claim is fake.
"I am Warden Warren, from what I read he is the equivalent of the Jailer role."
"From what I read he is the equivalent"
"He is"
"He"
.....Sorry, buddy, but until you actually refute the evidence I've gathered, my vote stands.
GmK
International Man Of Cake
Oh hey Sheriff Ooglie, I don't doubt your claim, even though I personally would have recommended waiting just a biiiiiiit longer and trying to hide your role within posts, instead of going all guns blazing. Hoping there is a doc to save you from potential harm!
I was first going to support the idea of @Samlen that said "We lynch Digi to see if Ooglie is potentially insane, and afterwards we know if to kill Swate", but then timdood posted and digi posted and then you, @Swate , posted, with the most phony claim I have read in a long time.
Let's give you the benefit of the doubt for a moment, and ask:
Can you talk with that other person / Are they aware they are with you in a closed meeting?
I was first going to support the idea of @Samlen that said "We lynch Digi to see if Ooglie is potentially insane, and afterwards we know if to kill Swate", but then timdood posted and digi posted and then you, @Swate , posted, with the most phony claim I have read in a long time.
Let's give you the benefit of the doubt for a moment, and ask:
Can you talk with that other person / Are they aware they are with you in a closed meeting?
Hoho, hold up there. Don't dare use my 'lack of experience' against me, maybe tell me what "other options" there are as a defense against yourself instead of acting as if they are so obvious to everyone in the universe?
And I'd like to know too, but unfortunately the only way to do that would be to have someone capable of finding out roles investigate him, and no-one knows if one even exists .-.
It was not an appeal to emotion at all
more me whining to myself, like you know Gil from The Simpsons. Sorta. I dunno, just trying to find a comparison point. I can attempt to 'dissolve' your argument, as you say. Keep in mind I do answer these truthfully and to the best of my ability, and I naturally have a weird way of explaining things, so if you find something "odd" then don't go making any rash moves before I elaborate further to clear up any confusion.I'm just gonna send this comment, then the explaining of what Timdood is say will be in a post after this.
I can talk with them if I wish, but they do not know where they are as they are blindfolded. Prizyms sends all my messages to them for me in a private message that just that person and Prizyms are in, so they didn't even know it was me when I jailed them, and Prizyms had a separate convo up with just me and him where he would paste all of their replies. This was done so that they would not know I am the jailer.
- Status