Trouble in the West: Pirates vs Cowboys [Finished]
- Thread starter Prizyms
- Start date
- Status
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
You might wanna read Samlen's post with a little more attention. He's obviously not asking you to defend yourself or attacking you in any way, he's asking the bandwagoners to come up with some reasoning for their votes.
HypeBurst
Just Fabulous
So this is my earliest post referencing Jivvi, so I didnt actually start that bandwagon at all and Jivvi is not being honest trying to make it seem like ive been trying to kill him throughout this game, with this "relentless attack" that he cant seem to find.
So Jivvi is actually not correct because he was trying to say I started his bandwagon and have been relentlessly attacking him. When it is clear, that I didnt.
Mooglie
The Local Cow
Keeping my vote on Fiestaguy even though it just a gut instinct. I was the original vote (go back and check if you must) and then people followed me but then I unvoted and voted Jivvi which turned out to be a misunderstanding so I went back to Fiesta.
Call gut instinct scummy all you like, isn't going to stop me from using it \o/
Call gut instinct scummy all you like, isn't going to stop me from using it \o/
Fiestaguy
The man with 8 fingers.
If the other things around it didn't. That one thing still did.
There is a field full of raddishes. And one carrot.
Who cares about the fucking carrot. Everything else is still a bloody raddish right?
"A third-party role you can do without." How is that so? I claimed today for the exact reason of everyone staying away from me for the town PRs' safety. Also, a Bomb would be a ridiculous 3P role, as what happens once you blow up? You killed one person? What would your win condition even be? Bombs are almost always town. The mafia version is the Terrorist, but they blow up when lynched.
As for only rebuking Hype, Hype was the only one who actually decided to argue the point thoroughly. The rest of you were pretty much set-and-forget in your votes.
And lastly, this flipping reference to the Innkeeper from last game. While Inns were being discussed, I threw that comment to suggest that there may be a role that affects inns directly upon death again. I'm not sure what you hope to achieve by pressing this point.
... Then I kinda doubt there being an innkeeper, considering that's what they were used for last time.
Unless, of course, there is one, and if they die, then the inns would probably just shut down in general, then. o. o
This is what I was thinking, I hypothesise that the innkeeper of an inn being killed would result in everyone getting kicked out of the inn. This is pure hunch, though, got nothing to base this theory on.
Meh. I've explained my reasoning, I don't need to explain myself over and over. What I've wanted to do was highlight how suspicious you've been. Perhaps you are a similar version to the Town-Sided Bomb. Perhaps you're the third-party Anarchist (which seems unlikely) or the Mafia Terrorist (which seems more fitting to the description of your claim than the other two). Then again, this is a close setup game and I believe that Priz would have manipulated roles.
HypeBurst
Just Fabulous
The irrelevant messages quoting some of my posts makes me believe that no one is actually reading what I'm typing tbh. People simply rehashing the points that I have already stated or passing judgements of things that they seem uneducated on is really starting to annoy me, when I get home ill explain but this is irritating
Look, I'm just not taking Jivvi's explanations at face value. He has a winning condition that benefits Town or Mafia. And all this, "Hey Mafia, you better watch out or I'm gonna getcha" sounds undoubtedly town sided, but it also leaves town at a disadvantage to investigate who he truly is.
Sure, later on in the game there can be a Cop claim and we can have the Doctor protect him/her, that's one plan. Then again, we'd be discussing new theories and suspicions and it'd seem like a waste of an investigation on someone that's already claimed.
As for Swate and Fiesta - they seem more than capable of getting themselves in to trouble.
Sure, later on in the game there can be a Cop claim and we can have the Doctor protect him/her, that's one plan. Then again, we'd be discussing new theories and suspicions and it'd seem like a waste of an investigation on someone that's already claimed.
As for Swate and Fiesta - they seem more than capable of getting themselves in to trouble.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
Oh, don't fret. I've read everyones posts and I know exactly what you're saying. I just don't understand what the heck is happening in your brain. Yeah, he's said a few things that are contradicting but I don't think he's mafia. I have no proof, it's simply a hunch that he's town. Maybe 3P.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
Call me crazy for all I care, but I have a feeling that there isn't a cop or doc. I mean on EM there are plenty of setups that have no cops/docs (they generally have at least one or the other, unless there's like a orc related setup. I'm getting off track now so..), so it's not like it's completely impossible.
- Status