Mafia Season 5
- Thread starter The Road to Ruin
- Start date
- Status
Defiant_Blob
(￣^￣)ゞ
I was talking to Dessern who was saying you were clear.
I vote to lynch Old_Man_Oak63, as we don't know Notty's role, and lynching a civilian is not as bad as lynching potential doctor/cop/vigilante.
Defiant_Blob
(￣^￣)ゞ
Old_Man seems to be really sidestepping around me.
Their vote is based on me being mafia, but why aren't the just voting me? I think it's one of two options:
A) They are scared that if they vote me and I AM the cop they'll immediately be lynched.
B) One of them is the contact, they found the killer, and are trying to finish him off in the hope that it makes them look innocent along with defeating a threat.
Their vote is based on me being mafia, but why aren't the just voting me? I think it's one of two options:
A) They are scared that if they vote me and I AM the cop they'll immediately be lynched.
B) One of them is the contact, they found the killer, and are trying to finish him off in the hope that it makes them look innocent along with defeating a threat.
Oak Milk
Kill Hungry Thirsty Dead
Pretty sure its based on you and notty both being Mafia if you read my whole post, if you looked you'll see only one needs to be lynched to prove what the other is. The reason why they prefer to vote notty instead of you is only because of your cop claim, and they are still wary of what your true role may be.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
First of all, lynching me would be a bad idea. Lynching defiant would be a bad idea. I think defiant knows why I defended him so much. And therefor doesnt vote for me. I truely believe that defiant is innocent.
Second, back to sploorky being suspicious. I dont think that sploorky is bad either. I have a good feeling that sploorky is town-sided. And not mafia. [I didnt say not serial killer beacause I think oak is that] Even tought this suspiciousness of sploorky has droppped, I just still had to say that I think hes innocent.
Third. Lynching oak seems like a good idea to me. All of you are saying that I am rushing into voting oak. Even tough I have good reasons to vote for him. And if I have good reasons.... Why wouldnt I vote for him...
The "pushing into voting oak" thing is just nonsense. He is the best shot we have at killing an enemy, and instead you choose to lynch me or defiant. That makes no sense.....
I have the feeling I will die tonight if we dont lynch oak. Either the vigilante, or serial killer[Still oak I think] will kill me. However if you lynch me now, and you find out it was a mistake, I hope you all lynch oak the next day as more victims came that night because oak is still alive.
Also oak, sacrifising yourself is the worst idea ever. You now even look more suspicious. Why would anyone who is a civilian risk himself to "sacrifise" himself. This only means that you are out of the game. Which I dont suppose you want. But it also means that the town-side lost another member. Which makes it good for the mafia or serial killer. I don't think a civilian would really do this. Thus making me think that as serial killer you pulled this to try and make yourself look innocent.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Hmmm. Some very interesting theories here. The three most suspicious to me are Oak, Notty and Blob at this moment. They all have some pretty good theories as well.
Right now though, I vote for lynching Nottykitten.
The reason for that is that first of all, Oak is more likely to be an elite citizen than the serial killer. Second, although Defiant seems to be acting suspiciously, he is a very experienced player and could still be the cop, or some other townie. So I wouldn't lynch him either.
Which leaves us with Notty. As Oak said already, when we lynch Notty and find out who he was, we can be quite sure about which faction Defiant is in as well, which is also one of the reasons I'm voting for Notty.
Right now though, I vote for lynching Nottykitten.
The reason for that is that first of all, Oak is more likely to be an elite citizen than the serial killer. Second, although Defiant seems to be acting suspiciously, he is a very experienced player and could still be the cop, or some other townie. So I wouldn't lynch him either.
Which leaves us with Notty. As Oak said already, when we lynch Notty and find out who he was, we can be quite sure about which faction Defiant is in as well, which is also one of the reasons I'm voting for Notty.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Thats.... pretty stupid. [Sorry =3]
You want to lynch me and from my role you determine wheter defiant and oak are bad or not. How does that seem like a good idea? It means that you will lynch a person you have almost no idea of what role he/she has.
While we all know that oak has a WAY higher chance of being the serial killer than I have on being mafia.
If you lynch oak instead, theres a way higher chance the town will get something good out of this, and from that you determine wether I am innocent or not.
This also means that if he is the serial killer, [which I think he is], then there will be 1 less murder that night. Doesnt that sound good? :_:
Hey guys, regarding Defiant, did you ever think of this?
If the real detective did investigate Defiant and it turned out he was mafia, then they probably would've spoken up because Defiant is a strong player. Since no cop has counter claimed yet, and Defiant saying he might not be cop and just used the reason to save himself from dying, I think Defiant isn't a bad role.
If the real detective did investigate Defiant and it turned out he was mafia, then they probably would've spoken up because Defiant is a strong player. Since no cop has counter claimed yet, and Defiant saying he might not be cop and just used the reason to save himself from dying, I think Defiant isn't a bad role.
Yeah, but that's a 1 in what, 11 or 12 chance? He's more likely to be a power role or civilian than the godfather.
- Status