Mafia Season 5

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
Odd.. First things first. I AM IN THE STORY WOOO xD

Second. Superstein didnt counter-claim the claim of endersteve as lyncher. Thats odd. Why would endersteve claim the lyncher. Perhaps because it is a safe spot because the mafia would bother attacking the lyncher and neither would the town lynch. Seems like a perfect deal.

I am not voting. [YET] but I am 60% sure I want to vote endersteve.

Third. Defiant attacked, probabily saved by the doctor. Old man attacked. Probabily the elite townsman, or the serial killer.

I think this day is going to be pretty easy. A choice between endersteve or old. I think thats our best option for today.
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
Odd.. First things first. I AM IN THE STORY WOOO xD

Second. Superstein didnt counter-claim the claim of endersteve as lyncher. Thats odd. Why would endersteve claim the lyncher. Perhaps because it is a safe spot because the mafia would bother attacking the lyncher and neither would the town lynch. Seems like a perfect deal.

I am not voting. [YET] but I am 60% sure I want to vote endersteve.

Third. Defiant attacked, probabily saved by the doctor. Old man attacked. Probabily the elite townsman, or the serial killer.

I think this day is going to be pretty easy. A choice between endersteve or old. I think thats our best option for today.
This ^

Well, if its not endersteve. I think I will be voting Old today. Old_Man_Oak_63 Tell us, what do you think of my story about you being the elite townsmen or the serial killer?
 

77thShad

Ayy lmao
Joined
Jan 12, 2012
Messages
1,079
Reaction score
1,035
I suppose lynching Oak is our best option right now. I wanna see what he has to say though before voting.
Pretty much this howeverrrr let's look at last night.
Oak- Most likely the skeleton or a bulletproof.
Defiant- Most likely saved by the doctor
Super- Just killed.

Firstly I want @Old_Man_Oak63 to explain himself.

Secondly and I find this quite odd that I am the first to do so, Defiant_Blob find anyone else out if you are truly the cop?
 

Sploorky

Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2011
Messages
1,890
Reaction score
3,656
What in the world.

First off, why in the world would you claim cop and screw with us if you aren't mafia?

Second, how would the vigilante give reasons towards shooting without revealing himself?

Third, I think the current crowd seems to be a bit too happy towards the idea of killing Oak, even though there is more of a chance of him being an elite than a skeleton.
 

Oak Milk

Kill Hungry Thirsty Dead
Mafia Host
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
1,267
Reaction score
1,922
What in the world.

First off, why in the world would you claim cop and screw with us if you aren't mafia?

Second, how would the vigilante give reasons towards shooting without revealing himself?

Third, I think the current crowd seems to be a bit too happy towards the idea of killing Oak, even though there is more of a chance of him being an elite than a skeleton.
My thoughts exactly, lets look at the people who were attacked tonight me super and blob, now Blob tries to take the role of cop and me and super are suspicous about it. Now Super is dead, I'm luckily still here and now Blob he retracted his early statement that he was the cop. Did me and super have a right to be suspicious, heck yes and we both have paid for it obviously. I think Defiant is the one you need to ask questions to first
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
My thoughts exactly, lets look at the people who were attacked tonight me super and blob, now Blob tries to take the role of cop and me and super are suspicous about it. Now Super is dead, I'm luckily still here and now Blob he retracted his early statement that he was the cop. Did me and super have a right to be suspicious, heck yes and we both have paid for it obviously. I think Defiant is the one you need to ask questions to first
Not really.
You forget that he can be a civilian as well. Trying to get us trought the first day without any dumb mistakes.
[Like lynching the real cop]
Defiant is very experienced, and this seems like a trick he would pull to help the town by faking the claim of the cop. So that perhaps he will be targeted at night, and not any other power roles. In which case I just revealed his plan [muwhahaha].
I think this is pretty much what happened.

So that leaves me with you Oak. Dont evade the question.
Are you an elite civilian, or not. Depending on how you will answer it I will choose to vote for you or not.

The way I see it you are just trying to get suspicion off yourself atm.
 

Oak Milk

Kill Hungry Thirsty Dead
Mafia Host
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
1,267
Reaction score
1,922
Not really.

I think this is pretty much what happened.

So that leaves me with you Oak. Dont evade the question.
Are you an elite civilian, or not. Depending on how you will answer it I will choose to vote for you or not.

The way I see it you are just trying to get suspicion off yourself atm.
I am an elite civilian, plain and simple and I can understand you need to clear the water, however my lynching will be a big mistake if it happens. But I'm a bit worried that you are trying to rush this voting, last time when you rushed the no-lynch I let it be, there wasn't enough evidence in the first place for myself to come to a vote on someone, and yet here we are again with the only evidence that I might be the seriel killer when its more likely I am an elite civillian, of which is this case. However there is one thing you should look at before you or anyone comes to a vote and that is, why was I attacked in the first place? If you do recall I threw quite a few things around in the first day in fact a lot of the same things as super, so obviously somewhere me and super were onto something either the mafia or the True seriel killer don't want us to catch onto or both. Not only that I suggest waiting before you vote Notty so we can see what the rest of the town thinks.
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,040
Reaction score
6,021
I am an elite civilian, plain and simple and I can understand you need to clear the water, however my lynching will be a big mistake if it happens. But I'm a bit worried that you are trying to rush this voting, last time when you rushed the no-lynch I let it be, there wasn't enough evidence in the first place for myself to come to a vote on someone, and yet here we are again with the only evidence that I might be the seriel killer when its more likely I am an elite civillian, of which is this case. However there is one thing you should look at before you or anyone comes to a vote and that is, why was I attacked in the first place? If you do recall I threw quite a few things around in the first day in fact a lot of the same things as super, so obviously somewhere me and super were onto something either the mafia or the True seriel killer don't want us to catch onto or both. Not only that I suggest waiting before you vote Notty so we can see what the rest of the town thinks.
I'd wait. BUT I KILL YOU D=
I will vote Old_Man_Oak_63.
Because you kill me on zombie :_:

But also because theres a 50/50 shot of you being the serial killer. Theres a 33% chance that defiant is the mafia. Meaning that you have higher chances of being bad. Plus I dont think defiant is bad.

Yes, it looks like I am rushing into things. But I gave this alot of thought. And it seemed the best option to me.
Why keep my option before me if I can show everyone by voting? =3

"Its more likely that I am an elite civilian" makes no sense to me. Since its a 50% chance, its not more likely. If anything it makes you more suspicious to me. Another reason I voted for you.


What I think is that you are the true serial killer, and attacked defiant this night. Which failed and you are now trying to find a way to lynch him at day. I also want to say that you are trying to take suspicion of youself by trying to give us other irrelevant leads. But anyone would have done that, so that doesn't make you more suspicious than you are already.
 

Defiant_Blob

( ̄^ ̄)ゞ
Donor
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,631
Reaction score
2,051
I wish I knew who attacked me.
Ask me any questions you want, I'll gladly answer.

While we wait, I'll provide some info:

If I am civilian, I claimed the role for the purpose Harmak mentioned earlier. I wanted to make sure no nonsense random lynching occurred. As well, as you can see it saved someone from dying as killer/mafia targeted me. The doctor WIFOM'd successfully, and we have one less death because of it.

If I am doctor, I claimed the role for the aforementioned reasons as well as hoping the mafia would fall for the WIFOM and attack me while I saved myself.

If I am cop, then I probably retracted to make it seem less like I'm cop, while I gather reports, since mafia and killer would believe I'm simply a citizen or so.

The rest of the roles would follow the same reasoning as Citizen, except Elite Citizen which would be to hope Mafia shot me.
 

Defiant_Blob

( ̄^ ̄)ゞ
Donor
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,631
Reaction score
2,051
I wish I knew who attacked me.
Ask me any questions you want, I'll gladly answer.

While we wait, I'll provide some info:

If I am civilian, I claimed the role for the purpose Harmak mentioned earlier. I wanted to make sure no nonsense random lynching occurred. As well, as you can see it saved someone from dying as killer/mafia targeted me. The doctor WIFOM'd successfully, and we have one less death because of it.

If I am doctor, I claimed the role for the aforementioned reasons as well as hoping the mafia would fall for the WIFOM and attack me while I saved myself.

If I am cop, then I probably retracted to make it seem less like I'm cop, while I gather reports, since mafia and killer would believe I'm simply a citizen or so.

The rest of the roles would follow the same reasoning as Citizen, except Elite Citizen which would be to hope Mafia shot me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top