(After the Kylie posts started to go, I was going to post this, but never really had the chance)
Kylieanna said:
About my logic of not voting off the serial killer, well, I don't believe I'm the only one who thought this, I just tried to express the idea as much as I could because it seems people simply skimmed over it when someone else posted it and I actually thought it was a good opinion and could work. It was also me trying my hardest to not let someone die when they had a much, much higher chance of being innocent.
Actually, you are very much true, because I believe I was the first person to actual state such an opinion, in fact, if you all want reference, go all the way back to Page 3 of this thread, and toward the end of that page, my lengthy post should be prevalent and known in regards to that opinion, because I do believe in that opinion.
Here is the whole post with the actual statement of believing the serial killer was a potential asset in bold for those of you who don't want to flip all the way back there.
So honestly, if Kylie must be put up onto the chopping block, then I believe so must I, because I was indeed, the first person to do so.
And honestly, I am VERY surprised Kylie was picked as scapegoat for this suspicion in the first place, over myself, seeing as I believe I did state such an opinion first, and so early in the game.
But besides that, at the moment, the argument against Kylie is rather... well... flawed, because as Kylie already stated, I don't quite remember Kylie ever hinting or stating that she was a power-role, primarily that of the doctor in any way.
Alpha102 said:
I actually think voting Kylieanna is a good choice.
Her reasoning of not voting off the serial killer in day 1 makes me confident she's not the doctor. Why would a doctor want more night killings to happen, when they can only save one person?
Vote: Kylieanna.
In fact, everything apart of Day 1 was essentially focused on protecting Digi against what appeared to be a very flawed argument proposed by Notty.
I believe you are getting the "doctor" idea from the idea that digi, because she had survived the previous night, could be one of 4 scenario's:
1) Digi is an Elite Civilian
2) Digi is the Serial killer
3) Digi is either Mafia or a non-2 life role and was saved via. Doctor
4) Digi IS the doctor and decided to save herself.
First, may is stress the latter scenario's, 3 and 4, which involved the doctor's role. Note that this was a debatable topic in terms of actually defending digi originally again'st Notty's accusations, and at the moment, could still be a possibility. However, this was really the only time the "doctor role" ever came directly up from conversation from what I remember.
Also we must stress the serial killer scenario.
Digi could still be the serial killer, but honestly, if we look back over posts already previously written as well as using normal logic, we can believe that digi, out of all the current players (well, at the time), was relatively quite slim and really not that big of an idea to really jump on that automatically sets digi as a lynching target, at least, that was what the atmosphere was back on Day 1.
However, digi could have been the serial killer, and still can be right now, hiding under our noses.
But to me, such an idea (since it seems im trying to cover every possibility and that I'm on a rant thanks to reading over Day 1 again) that Kylie would be anti-town just because she has a specific opinion in terms of the Serial killer, doesn't directly make her suspicious to me.
Everything else about day 1 was supposed to somewhat show additional ideas in your flaw/argument (unless you give evidence of Kylie and the doctor), but I'm not entirely sure if I made a point or not/if it was clear.
At the moment, I don't see myself voting off Kylie(or digi, seeing as I tended to stray toward her a lot in that >.<) any time soon with that argument.
Honestly. despite myself stating No Lynching isn't a very good idea at this point,
seeing how the arguments have progressed thus far, and how little some people seem to be participating, nothing is really getting done this in-game day, and really, I'm tempted just to No-Lynch to get this day over with. We aren't getting anywhere with these arguments (at least, it seems that way to me).
We still need more activity from the quieter crowd.
