MEDIEVAL MAFIA: INTRUSION [DAY 8]
- Thread starter MarsKid
- Start date
- Status
How does a doc save prove innocence?
If a doctor saves someone, that person could ask 'Who saved me last night.' If no one answers, no one can be proven innocent, if one person answers, then that person is a most likely a doctor (the only exception is when the doctor wants to remain silent for want of safety), and thus is innocent (but, if revealed, is also most likely dead the next day.) If more than 2 people answer, then you know one of them isn't telling the truth, and one is (assuming the previously mentioned scenario isn't occurring.)
Mooglie
The Local Cow
Which means it could of been a mafia (accidently pressed post reply last post without finishing)It is possible that the person being protected was hit by a third party role
It is most certainly in the mafia's best interest to kill every night, especially with this many players and such little information. Doc should always he on PR claims when/if they arise. Never lynch a doc claim.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
Exactly my current train of thought, it doesn't clear the player as it may be mafia/3rd partyWhich means it could of been a mafia (accidently pressed post reply last post without finishing)It is possible that the person being protected was hit by a third party role
In a game like mafia, rules like that will lose the game. Your acting kinda suspicious
No, you're quite mistaken. If there are two doc claims, the only thing that can happen with a lynch is bad.
- Real doc is lynched. Fake doc survives another night and can perform their night action with the mafia.
- Fake doc is lynched. Real doc is killed during the night and town is screwed over in regards to protection.
Please forgive my lack of posting, internet was crappy this morning.
From what it seems the most suspicious people are Pim and Priz?
Please correct me if I'm wrong. Also I see that people are pushing for a Lynch, and I guess whatever the group decides is best is probably best because there are people here with more experience than I have.
From what it seems the most suspicious people are Pim and Priz?
Please correct me if I'm wrong. Also I see that people are pushing for a Lynch, and I guess whatever the group decides is best is probably best because there are people here with more experience than I have.
Just going to be blunt here and tell you to stop agreeing with what everybody else is doing and make your own mind up. Not contributing and simply going with everyone else is toxic to the game, and results in the stronger players being killed off, leaving the less vocal players able to be swayed easily by the mafia and third parties. Suspicion is not some value that can be measured on a scale or whatnot - I may be a top FoS for some, but may also be a purely vocal player to others with no suspicion. I'm not just saying this because I'm considered suspicious - I would have said this if it was anybody being suspected through hive mentality alone.
So just double checking, if that deadline isn't met than is it whoever has most votes, or just auto no lynch? Can we get a vote count MarsKid
My point of view:
- Pim seems suspicious for reasons mentioned by endersteve, but partially defends himself
- nitasu appears to want to bandwagon (which is understandable since he's new to the game)
As for the doctor issue, there are other possible outcomes with multiple claims if neither are lynched.
- The quoted outcomes
- Neither is lynched, but vigilante kills fake doctor while real doctor survives,
arousing suspicion(never mind, roles are released upon death) - Same situation, but real doctor is accidentally killed by vigilante
- Vigilante kills fake doctor, real doctor is mafia-killed
- Neither is killed overnight; town is slightly stunned
- Status