MEDIEVAL MAFIA: INTRUSION [DAY 8]

[myusername22]

myusername22

The last posts you have really gotten into a strong "Poor me towny, I can't really make out anything anymore, it's so confusing" stance. Not sure yet what to make of it, but it doesn't seem particularly reassuring...

that's not quite what I was going for. I didn't think any arguments of mine would actually be taken seriously while I was myself a suspect so I didn't really defend myself all that much.

I had a strong lack of suspicions on anyone really except for hypeburst. However I've noticed from past seasons I had a tendency to just attack the people who voted for me (then again it turned out neither of those people were town ) and it ended up with nothing either than me trying to go at them with nothing only to get killed for being a threat to the mafia. because of this I'm going to withdraw my vote on hypeburst no matter how suspicious I find them and try to find something else hopefully others will agree with me on.

unvote

I think I've gone slightly off the topic I intended to write here, So let me get back on track.

because I didn't think any of my arguments would really work, and I didn't want to suddenly disappear from the thread due to having no opinion I ended up just writing in whatever I could which instead of being anything concrete I'll admit might have just been emotional.

But, As master GmK wishes I shall defend myself and then post all of my thoughts later today when I get around to it and have time to gather the evidence.

 

[MarsKid]

Announcements:

-The main post has been updated to show previous events.
-Three players are scheduled to be killed the next night do to inactivity/dropping out of the game: Digitalmez, Thymos, and Watermelon1388. Replacements would be greatly appreciated, as these slots will be closed by the next day's beginning.

 

[MarsKid]

Don't make me start singing to bring you back. I WILL sing.

 

[Fruit]

Too lazy to quote, so I'll tag
GmK VS Nottykitten

I think you're both innocent.

If notty was mafia, she would have been persuading the other mafia members to kill GmK, and he would be dead.

If Gmk was mafia, he would do the same to her.

However I may be wrong on this assumption.

If one of them dies during the night, that makes the other look extremely suspicious, and will then be lynched more than likely.

Also, notty had voted for jivvi on day 0 after jivvi had voted for GmK, but on day one after the whole nitasu thing, notty has really just stuck with that suspicion on Gmk.

That's a rather quick vote you have there Jivvi. And with no explaination at all. Sort of makes you suspicious. Ofcourse one would say that a mafia member would never do such a move because it would make them suspicious. And therefor a mafia member could do it in order to seem town-like.


Vote Jivvi

I'm just going to put this out there because this is the only thing that I got.

Why would GmK vote for nitasu if he was town sided? That's right, he wouldn't!


Vote GmK

Either they're both innocent, or Gmk's mafia. If notty was mafia, they would have gotten more support on a vote to lynch gmk, in my opinion.

Also, IF gmk is to get lynched, and he is indeed mafia, then I will have a large suspicion on HypeBurst because of this:

Ahh why is there two pages in the space of one hour?!

Ok well Im still confused with this GmK and Nitasu thing. Can someone quote the post that tells us that Nit chose GmK for his freelance role? I must have missed it while I was reading.

Anyway with that being said, I believe that GmK would vote for Nit in that Day 0 lynch if he was town.

If he was town, lynching a third party role would be a safe move. No town PR's or villagers would be killed. It wouldnt exactly benefit town too well, but it would show the first voting styles and bandwagon-ing, to get a better understanding of the players.

If he was mafia, I dont think he would vote for Nitasu. Why? because if he died, there would be another mafia in his place to help the mafia win. Even dead mafia still want their team to win.

I can understand GmK voting for Nitasu and him being town.


And with Ltin. I'm really nervous about you. This 'bang' stuff is pretty cryptic and It would be nice if you explained it. I'm not in a position yet to vote to lynch you but I would like to hear your explanation for all of this.

Hypeburst really defended Gmk there. So, IF, gmk ever dies, and we discover he is mafia, then I believe it would reasonable to put a suspicion on hype as well. And IF Hype dies and we discover he's mafia, then I'd be 100% sure on Gmk, because why would mafia protect an innocent?

REMEMBER: that last bit is an IF. Just linking them together IF the other turns out to be mafia.

 

[Fruit]

So,
F.O.S on Hype and Gmk

 

[Ansoro2112]

Since the doc is still alive, I think the cop should claim today. Since when all PR's claim, there is a chance that the cop dies tonight. It's better to do it now before it is to late. Opinions?

I'm not really sure about this idea. I'll tell you why. If the PR out today mafia members and serial killer will already have a list with a bunch of people they migh want to kill. Now, I understand Prizym's plan. About going after the blues and then getting rid off the cc's, etc.

But here's where I see the problem. We don't really know if the doctor or doctors (Since the King and Queen can also protect) are already dead. Or if even the Cop is dead already.

RESULTS:

-Day info has been blocked by Spy!
-Alpha102 was killed
-Brownlee123 was killed

That's all for today.


DAY 2 HAS BEGUN!!!

All this information was blocked. We don't know what Alpha and Brownlee's roles were.

Plus, there is Digitalmez, Thymos and Watermelon. Which at this point we haven't found someone to replace them. So all their roles will be lost. There might exist a possibilty there's PR there as well.

MarsKid, are you going to show what were their roles if there's no replacements?

Lets just say the Cop outs. We are thinking like the doctors might still be alive. But we don't really know that. I found this plan risky.

 

[Fruit]

Spoiler

Since the doc is still alive, I think the cop should claim today. Since when all PR's claim, there is a chance that the cop dies tonight. It's better to do it now before it is to late. Opinions?

Spoiler

I'm not really sure about this idea. I'll tell you why. If the PR out today mafia members and serial killer will already have a list with a bunch of people they migh want to kill. Now, I understand Prizym's plan. About going after the blues and then getting rid off the cc's, etc.

But here's where I see the problem. We don't really know if the doctor or doctors (Since the King and Queen can also protect) are already dead. Or if even the Cop is dead already.

RESULTS:

-Day info has been blocked by Spy!
-Alpha102 was killed
-Brownlee123 was killed

That's all for today.


DAY 2 HAS BEGUN!!!

All this information was blocked. We don't know what Alpha and Brownlee's roles were.

Plus, there is Digitalmez, Thymos and Watermelon. Which at this point we haven't found someone to replace them. So all their roles will be lost. There might exist a possibilty there's PR there as well.

MarsKid, are you going to show what were their roles if there's no replacements?

Lets just say the Cop outs. We are thinking like the doctors might still be alive. But we don't really know that. I found this plan risky.

This is a good point. If the cops comes out with his information, the doctor could be one of the inactive members. Heck, the cop could be one of those people. Them being inactive really puts us at a disadvantage. Or a possible advantage if one of them is mafia.

 

[Ansoro2112]

Since the doc is still alive, I think the cop should claim today.

Also Notty, how are you sure the doctor is still alive?

 

[MarsKid]

When they die, yes, their roles will be revealed.

 

[Da Jinks]

Will have a more proper post in the morning, but MarsKid if any of the inactive players are important power roles would it be possible to give there power role to someone with a less important role?

 

[HypeBurst]

GmK VS Nottykitten
I think you're both innocent.

So,
F.O.S on Hype and Gmk

Umm contradiction much

 

[Fruit]

GmK VS Nottykitten
I think you're both innocent.

So,
F.O.S on Hype and Gmk

Umm contradiction much

Either they're both innocent, or Gmk's mafia.

There's part of me that thinks he's innocent. If I truely thought he was mafia, I would have voted to lynch him. But there's still a part of me holding me back. But I do still have my suspisions, which is why I have a F.O.S. on him.

 

[HypeBurst]

GmK VS Nottykitten
I think you're both innocent.

So,
F.O.S on Hype and Gmk

Umm contradiction much

Either they're both innocent, or Gmk's mafia.

There's part of me that thinks he's innocent. If I truely thought he was mafia, I would have voted to lynch him. But there's still a part of me holding me back. But I do still have my suspisions, which is why I have a F.O.S. on him.

Ok thanks for the clarification I was like ummm what :m

 

[Fruit]

asdfdsa I saw the typo and forgot to fix it. I don't know why I feel the need to fix it but, truly*

 

[Nottykitten]

Lets just say the Cop outs. We are thinking like the doctors might still be alive. But we don't really know that. I found this plan risky.

I find it way more risky that we are letting the mafia get a free chance at the cop, if he only outs as PR and not cop.

The way I see it, four things can happen:
Cop outs, we know 3 investigations and the doc protects him at night. Then he can make an investigation the next day.
Cop outs, we know 3 investigations and the cop dies that night due to doctor being dead.

Cop doesn't out, he gets killed in the night and we don't know anything.
Cop doesn't out, one of the other PR's gets killed and he is free to tell us 3 investigations + make another one that day.

So if the cop outs, we atleast know three of the investigations. If he doesn't out there is this chance that we won't know anything at all. I find that way more risky as the information can be really important.

Since the doc is still alive, I think the cop should claim today.

Also Notty, how are you sure the doctor is still alive?

I don't know if he is alive, but I think he is.

 

[MarsKid]

I don't want to have to put a time limit in place.

 

[Prizyms]

I don't want to have to put a time limit in place.

I really would, at this stage. Nobody is really doing anything.

 

[Pim]

Too lazy to quote, so I'll tag
GmK VS Nottykitten

I think you're both innocent.

If notty was mafia, she would have been persuading the other mafia members to kill GmK, and he would be dead.

Why kill players that can be seem suspicious? I think people that havent been found suspicous are mostly killed these last nights, just because of the fact that there is a really small change for their lynching.
GmK has been put in the spotlight for quite some while by Notty, and people (like you) are getting suspicious of him because of it. It would be quite stupid to kill him during the night, while he is a possibility for lynching the next day.

Ahh why is there two pages in the space of one hour?!

Ok well Im still confused with this GmK and Nitasu thing. Can someone quote the post that tells us that Nit chose GmK for his freelance role? I must have missed it while I was reading.

Anyway with that being said, I believe that GmK would vote for Nit in that Day 0 lynch if he was town.

If he was town, lynching a third party role would be a safe move. No town PR's or villagers would be killed. It wouldnt exactly benefit town too well, but it would show the first voting styles and bandwagon-ing, to get a better understanding of the players.

If he was mafia, I dont think he would vote for Nitasu. Why? because if he died, there would be another mafia in his place to help the mafia win. Even dead mafia still want their team to win.

I can understand GmK voting for Nitasu and him being town.

Just as said here.

I can't find any argument against him except for this. Though as Hype said, not voting him could be both positive for both sides. And maybe it's smarter to not-know who nitsau would be when GmK dies, for both first and second party.

All this only makes me have a suspicion on you, as you taking Notty's side without any reasoning to Be on her side, and with very little evidence to be Not on GmK's side.

 

[Nottykitten]

All this only makes me have a suspicion on you, as you taking Notty's side without any reasoning to Be on her side, and with very little evidence to be Not on GmK's side.

I'm confused. Are you saying Fruit is suspicious for taking my side and not GmK's side?

 

[GmK]

All this only makes me have a suspicion on you, as you taking Notty's side without any reasoning to Be on her side, and with very little evidence to be Not on GmK's side.

I'm confused. Are you saying Fruit is suspicious for taking my side and not GmK's side?

I think that is what he is saying. But I must admit, it also doesn't make as much sense to me, even if it was an argument in my favor...

 

[Ansoro2112]

I understand no one wants the cop to get killed at night before he even tells us his/her previous investigations. Since we all need them. I guess it's better safe than sorry.

But again, then there's no need for every single PR to out. Not this early in the game at least.

Also, keep in mind the cop might be dead already OR maybe the investigations he/she already have are from players who already died. It just depends on the cop, if he/she thinks its worth it to out at this point.

Since the doc is still alive, I think the cop should claim today.

Also Notty, how are you sure the doctor is still alive?

I don't know if he is alive, but I think he is.

And Notty, I don't think you "think" the doctor is still alive. I can see by that line, "Since the doc is still alive, I think the cop should claim today". That sounds like a very sure person talking. And perhaps you made a mistake there.

 

[Nottykitten]

Also Notty, how are you sure the doctor is still alive?

I don't know if he is alive, but I think he is.

And Notty, I don't think you "think" the doctor is still alive. I can see by that line, "Since the doc is still alive, I think the cop should claim today". That sounds like a very sure person talking. And perhaps you made a mistake there.

I don't see any mistake there

 

[Ansoro2112]

I don't know if he is alive, but I think he is.

And Notty, I don't think you "think" the doctor is still alive. I can see by that line, "Since the doc is still alive, I think the cop should claim today". That sounds like a very sure person talking. And perhaps you made a mistake there.

I don't see any mistake there

Like I mentioned before, the spy blocked the information when Alpha and Brown were killed. Maybe one of them was the doctor.

It's just something we don't know. But you are sure the doc is alive. How can you be so sure?

 

[Nottykitten]

And Notty, I don't think you "think" the doctor is still alive. I can see by that line, "Since the doc is still alive, I think the cop should claim today". That sounds like a very sure person talking. And perhaps you made a mistake there.

I don't see any mistake there

Like I mentioned before, the spy blocked the information when Alpha and Brown were killed. Maybe one of them was the doctor.

It's just something we don't know. But you are sure the doc is alive. How can you be so sure?

The spy doesn't get told what their roles were.

 

[Ansoro2112]

I don't see any mistake there

Like I mentioned before, the spy blocked the information when Alpha and Brown were killed. Maybe one of them was the doctor.

It's just something we don't know. But you are sure the doc is alive. How can you be so sure?

The spy doesn't get told what their roles were.

;O Pfff. I'm a noob then. I thought the spy blocked the information but he was told what their roles were.