Supernatural Hotel [Finished]

[GmK]

Coolio - just as a tip, dont base arguments on 'I know what I am so the following is true', that doesnt work in mafia. Because even if what follows makes perfect sense, it's weakened a lot by saying 'I know I am Guest' and by defending with 'you lose if you lynch me'

 

[cooliorules]

I HIGHLY doubt that they would do that because that would mean they're losing one of their team?

 

[Hunter]

where even is hype
i don't recall him being active

 

[cooliorules]

Coolio - just as a tip, dont base arguments on 'I know what I am so the following is true', that doesnt work in mafia. Because even if what follows makes perfect sense, it's weakened a lot by saying 'I know I am Guest' and by defending with 'you lose if you lynch me'

Only the truth, my friend

 

[Jivvi]

@GmK but equally if he was mafia, why would he block the sleeper if they don't do anything? Could just have easily been testing if he was the rough sleeper.

Either way, neither him visiting the sleeper as mafia or as town makes a lot of sense..

I was confused as to how the Rough Sleeper worked; I assumed that my role would be revealed.
Also confirming Hunter, although mafia did that for me. I suppose that it would have been better to take a stab in the dark, but at the time this seemed like the best idea.

Also, GmK, you haven't disclosed your actions, which would be helpful to know.

 

[Hunter]

I

this is an important quote

 

[cooliorules]

(My mafia list as of right now: Ooglie, Hype and GmK)

 

[cooliorules]

this is an important quote

Wait what?

 

[GmK]

I was confused as to how the Rough Sleeper worked; I assumed that my role would be revealed.
Also confirming Hunter, although mafia did that for me. I suppose that it would have been better to take a stab in the dark, but at the time this seemed like the best idea.

Also, GmK, you haven't disclosed your actions, which would be helpful to know.

Blocked Ooglie last night and Coolio this night, hoping to stop a mafia kill if it was one of them executing it, going aling with my theory theyre both maf with you

 

[Hunter]

vote cooliorules

 

[cooliorules]

vote cooliorules

I'd like reasoning

 

[cooliorules]

(no I'm not voting myself with the quote T.T)

 

[Sploorky]

Lets give the guest list a go.

vote Ooglie101

Coolio is throwing both town members under the bus, a very unmafia thing to focus on if she was actually mafia. Instead a mafia member would be more focused on paying attention to the barman claims.

 

[Hunter]

assuming gmk's not lying that means it's narrowed down to either ooglie/hype, and hype was innoed
so gmk would vote either ooglie/jivvi
so. from gmks pov who executed the kill?
answer would be ooglie-that'd be confirmed
this means if gmk blocked coolio and jivvi visited me then hype/ooglie would do the kill
and he innod hype!
therefore gmk has confirmed ooglie as the one who killed the alien last night for himself.

 

[cooliorules]

Lets give the guest list a go.

vote Ooglie101

Coolio is throwing both town members under the bus, a very unmafia thing to focus on if she was actually mafia. Instead a mafia member would be more focused on paying attention to the barman claims.

I have touched on the barman thing, though, because I had an amazing revolution as to why Hype was coming up as innocent. Two, actually. But yeah, I'm just trying make us wiiinnnnn ;-;

 

[cooliorules]

Except I'm not mafia so that makes no sense to me whatsoever let me read that 10 times over

 

[Hunter]

in other words, gmk has confirmed one mafia with irrefutable evidence and has denied to share that or go on his vote, potentially throwing the game

(if he is bartender)

otherwise he is mafia scum and should die

 

[GmK]

2am for me, need sleep. Excited to see whats happening till I get up!

 

[Sploorky]

assuming gmk's not lying that means it's narrowed down to either ooglie/hype, and hype was innoed
so gmk would vote either ooglie/jivvi
so. from gmks pov who executed the kill?
answer would be ooglie-that'd be confirmed
this means if gmk blocked coolio and jivvi visited me then hype/ooglie would do the kill
and he innod hype!
therefore gmk has confirmed ooglie as the one who killed the alien last night for himself.

1. Its a 50/50 shot if gmk is lying or not, don't make assumptions.
2. If gmk confirmed ooglie as the one who killed the alien, why would you vote coolio?

 

[Hunter]

I had an amazing revolution as to why Hype was coming up as innocent.

amazing revolution

 

[cooliorules]

in other words, gmk has confirmed one mafia with irrefutable evidence and has denied to share that or go on his vote, potentially throwing the game

(if he is bartender)

otherwise he is mafia scum and should die

Exactly where my thingy comes in, where he is mafia and used the ball from Notty but disregarded it to protect, in a way, his fellow mafia.

I'm staying on my vote for Ooglie, though.

 

[Hunter]

1. Its a 50/50 shot if gmk is lying or not, don't make assumptions.
2. If gmk confirmed ooglie as the one who killed the alien, why would you vote coolio?

this argument only applies if gmk is the actual bartender and that was mentioned
as for coolio, just look at her reactions

 

[cooliorules]

Yes. I had a revolution. It's stated in the above comment from me

 

[cooliorules]

My reactions are because I don't want town to lose.

Look at my first game of mafia, Ansoro died but I saw logic in what he said and I followed through for him, and although I was lynched, I defended myself like FUCK.
I was blue then.
What am I doing now?
Defending myself like FUCK.

 

[Hunter]

she even mentioned the lockpicker again.- seems to be panicking now.
someone please explain why coolio isnt mafia