Trouble in the West: Pirates vs Cowboys [Finished]

Status
Not open for further replies.

GmK

International Man Of Cake
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
2,987
Reaction score
5,686
Disclaimer: I was eating dinner and haven't reread anything yet.

Why did Jivvi even claim? From (unrelieble . _. ) memory, didn't he claim in response to one of JK's posts or something?
He started the day by saying he was blocked (iirc) and later on said something about being a danger to scum if touched. That turned him into a suspicion to some people, leading to his claim. Will try to find who put the focus on him, but first need some sleep.
 

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
Disclaimer: I was eating dinner and haven't reread anything yet.

Why did Jivvi even claim? From (unrelieble . _. ) memory, didn't he claim in response to one of JK's posts or something?
He started the day by saying he was blocked (iirc) and later on said something about being a danger to scum if touched. That turned him into a suspicion to some people, leading to his claim. Will try to find who put the focus on him, but first need some sleep.
I believe I was the one that was suspicious of Jivvi because it was strange to claim to be "roleblocked" basically when he didn't need to, and then randomly claiming afterward, again, with no clear reason to other than "putting it out there."

Let me go and find the actual post.
And jeeze, that was a long night. What was that... 5 days at least?
 

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
Here we go, this was my post (cut out the response I made to GmK which was in the beginning of said post. Post #575 on thread page 23 if you're wondering):
I do have a question though:
Actually it would be helpful to know if any items are in play at all. Since this is a very role-specific setup, I have my doubts. Regardless~
I guess the assumption is obvious: what is a closed set-up game probably is based around roles (as is any Mafia game), but why role specific? How do you know that it is? I would say you wouldn't exactly know, because we have no idea if there are more items in play or that multiple roles could occur.
Honestly, I feel like I'm just blowing this out of proportion, but I'm always skeptical whenever someone makes a "concrete statement" about something in a closed set-up game unless specifically said by the host (like with Oak where Prizy basically said the Pirates didn't know who each other was through story, so I'm not entirely convinced on the Oak vote based on this "concrete statement" idea)

Following that "concrete statement" idea, I also recall Oak and Jivvi both believing there is a Janitor role this time around, which is curious. It wouldn't have been my first thought certainly, so I'm curious as to why they believe a Janitor is present in this game. (I mean, obviously it's just an assumption, I just thought it was weird that they both thought it) (also note that since I can't find the posts themselves due to slow page loading/some pages just don't load correctly due to my current Internet connection, it might not have been Jivvi who said that; I'm only going off memory here, but I know Oak said that earlier, juts unsure about jivvi)
After that, Jivvi went on to say a bunch of strange and random statements that, really, did not seem to make sense to really "claim" at the time, as it just add a bunch of information irrelevant to the time at hand, including that of the "roleblock" as well as stating out of the blue:
But just a hint for mafia; you may not want to see what happens if you target me again
This was all prior to Oak's posts and claim.
Jivvi claimed "Mad Mike" shortly after Oak (if I'm not mistaken).

Then became a conflict between Jivvi and Fiesta as a lynching target that night, where Fiesta was lynched but Jivvi was killed last night: but both turned up innocent so I guess everyone was wrong!

That would be a rough chronology of the situation with Jivvi.
 

Timdood3

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
2,339
Reaction score
2,824

Timdood3

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
2,339
Reaction score
2,824
This was all prior to Oak's posts and claim.
Jivvi claimed "Mad Mike" shortly after Oak (if I'm not mistaken).
I do believe it was the post directly after OMO.

As for Jivvi's quote at the beginning of my last post, it decided I didn't want to say anything about it....From that quote, (I know this is sorta meh, I've been looking for Hype's posts but it's taking a while) it seems that Hype was the only one really pushing pushing for Jivvi, though I could be wrong.
 

Timdood3

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
2,339
Reaction score
2,824
JK, couldn't you have posted instead of rating it confusing so I don't feel bad about posting a million one liners in a row? Dx

In any case: Hype said she didn't trust the claim (neither did quite a few others), or his warning...She disregarded the fake warning, and now Jivvi is dead. Coincidence? I don't think so.

I believe those who play epicmafia a lot might call this a slip. I'm not very familiar with what exactly defines a slip, but this sure seems like one to me...I'm probably being incoherent again, it just feels ....off, you know?
 

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
I do believe it was the post directly after OMO.

As for Jivvi's quote at the beginning of my last post, it decided I didn't want to say anything about it....From that quote, (I know this is sorta meh, I've been looking for Hype's posts but it's taking a while) it seems that Hype was the only one really pushing pushing for Jivvi, though I could be wrong.
I disagree. From what I read, I thought Hype and Digi were both pushing pretty hard, not just Hype.
I would've pushed more, but that whole weekend was Graduation weekend here on Oahu, so I had a lot of graduations+graduation parties to attend, plus exams that following week as well, so I never got to post toward the end of that day. v_v Did push it toward the beginning though.
Don't think Jeer really pushed? I don't remember much of Jeer's posts toward the end of that day.
JK, couldn't you have posted instead of rating it confusing so I don't feel bad about posting a million one liners in a row? Dx

In any case: Hype said she didn't trust the claim (neither did quite a few others), or his warning...She disregarded the fake warning, and now Jivvi is dead. Coincidence? I don't think so.

I believe those who play epicmafia a lot might call this a slip. I'm not very familiar with what exactly defines a slip, but this sure seems like one to me...I'm probably being incoherent again, it just feels ....off, you know?
Haven't I said I take forever to post anything? >:c
It takes me like, 5 minutes just to post a sentence or two, I'm slow, don't judge me. ;~;

I put confusing because I didn't understand what your post had any significance to, but since you explained it more, now I understand xD
Of course, I don't think it's a slip, of course, if you mean Hype doesn't believe his "warning" to the Mafia aka. this post:
But just a hint for mafia; you may not want to see what happens if you target me again
Because I called this out as well, because if he really was a town role, especially the one he claimed: "Mad Mike," be better NOT to claim? I think so, because if we was "Mad Mike" as he initially claimed, it would have been better to have stayed hidden to get a possible Mafia, especially if he was roleblocked by a Mafia that night (since I guess we can assume that he was truly roleblocked as he was the cop and claimed that).
Even since he was actually Cop, it would have been better to stay hidden and NOT draw this much attention, right?

At the time, it made no sense, but it doesn't feel "off" to me that Hype said he didn't believe Jivvi, It made no sense at the time.
...
Unless you mean a different warning, then everything I said doesn't make sense in regard to the quote.
If it's a different warning please tell me, I don't remember much about stuff past Oak's claim and my vote on Jivvi due to the length of the night and me not really reading much into stuff after the day ended... (again, graduation weekend+exams ;A;... which I'll probably go ahead and read now/soon x) )
 

Timdood3

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
2,339
Reaction score
2,824
I disagree. From what I read, I thought Hype and Digi were both pushing pretty hard, not just Hype.
I would've pushed more, but that whole weekend was Graduation weekend here on Oahu, so I had a lot of graduations+graduation parties to attend, plus exams that following week as well, so I never got to post toward the end of that day. v_v Did push it toward the beginning though.
Don't think Jeer really pushed? I don't remember much of Jeer's posts toward the end of that day.
I actually read through their posts before I put that there, I promiseok I didn't...

Because I called this out as well, because if he really was a town role, especially the one he claimed: "Mad Mike," be better NOT to claim? I think so, because if we was "Mad Mike" as he initially claimed, it would have been better to have stayed hidden to get a possible Mafia, especially if he was roleblocked by a Mafia that night (since I guess we can assume that he was truly roleblocked as he was the cop and claimed that).
Even since he was actually Cop, it would have been better to stay hidden and NOT draw this much attention, right?
What I'm trying to say is instead of saying "you're warning is rubbish and you shouldn't have bloody done it," she basically said "I don't believe you."
 

HypeBurst

Just Fabulous
Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
450
Reaction score
1,165
JK, couldn't you have posted instead of rating it confusing so I don't feel bad about posting a million one liners in a row? Dx

In any case: Hype said she didn't trust the claim (neither did quite a few others), or his warning...She disregarded the fake warning, and now Jivvi is dead. Coincidence? I don't think so.

I believe those who play epicmafia a lot might call this a slip. I'm not very familiar with what exactly defines a slip, but this sure seems like one to me...I'm probably being incoherent again, it just feels ....off, you know?
Frankly something tells me that post was preplanned. Like you had already prepared a basic thought process to attack me when you saw that Jivvi was killed. After the heated arguement with Jivvi that I had, it would be easy for someone to knock out one of us and put suspicion on the other.

Btw, Hi, Im a boy tbh. EVERY SINGLE FUCKING SEASON SOMEONE CALLS ME FEMALE.
 

Timdood3

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
2,339
Reaction score
2,824
Frankly something tells me that post was preplanned. Like you had already prepared a basic thought process to attack me when you saw that Jivvi was killed. After the heated arguement with Jivvi that I had, it would be easy for someone to knock out one of us and put suspicion on the other.

Btw, Hi, Im a boy tbh. EVERY SINGLE FUCKING SEASON SOMEONE CALLS ME FEMALE.
Sorry, just your avatar throws me off :c

and Pfft....when have I ever planned a post? I was looking back to try to find why Jivvi claimed and I saw that, and it felt wrong to me.
 

Enderfive

sarcasm incarnate
Mafia Host
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4,802
JK, couldn't you have posted instead of rating it confusing so I don't feel bad about posting a million one liners in a row? Dx

In any case: Hype said she didn't trust the claim (neither did quite a few others), or his warning...She disregarded the fake warning, and now Jivvi is dead. Coincidence? I don't think so.

I believe those who play epicmafia a lot might call this a slip. I'm not very familiar with what exactly defines a slip, but this sure seems like one to me...I'm probably being incoherent again, it just feels ....off, you know?
What

This isn't even pulling at straws, I don't have any clue what this is. Basically, what you're saying is Hype called his bluff because it seemed absolutely illogical. Today Jivvi is dead. Thus, Hype is maf.

This makes absolutely no sense. I'm pretty sure there were others who were suspicious of Jivvi's claim, myself included, and being suspicious of his claim obviously meant you were suspicious of his warning, because without the claim, there could be no explanation to the warning. Does that make us all mafia? Of course not. Just because someone was suspicious of someone who later turned up as town does not mean they're mafia. Us town don't know who other town are, and with mafia working behind the scenes, it's more than likely that some of our suspicions will be incorrect.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top