TBD [Status: GAME OVER]

[Defiant_Blob]

I still think notty is a third party that can win with mafia, similar to the third party cop.

 

[Ltin]

You implied that YOU were protecting hunter as a doc would, so why on earth would ANOTHER doc have protected him?
Not trusting this, honestly.

Vote Ltin

I hope I didn't. I implied that I would try to protect him. I did saw it wasn't fool proof.
And I also asked any docs to also protect hunter.
I was intending myself to be a failsafe just in case there were no docs.

 

[Ltin]

Well the mafia could have assumed you really were a doc from all of the confusion from yesterday... and of course they would want to kill a role like that right away. Logically, Hunter had enough suspicion on him from his actions from yesterday, so why not go after someone that claimed they could protect people and let the suspicious person die the next day? I dunno what other people think, but I think that it makes perfect sense that an anti-town role would want a plausible protective role dead over an extremely suspicious person that was likely to get lynched anyways.

I don't recall the specifics of his role, but investigative roles can do much more damage to mafia than a doc. And since they knew hunter wasn't maf, they belived him.

 

[The Road to Ruin]

I also think Notty is third party. With a bulletproof vest you can survive a night just as well and with the watcher bit you can tell town who tried to kill you thereby preventing an innocent person from being lynched. Bomb only really serves as a deterrent (though a better one at that) leading me to believe the bit about staying alive is the only motivation for the Hercules role.

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

I don't recall the specifics of his role, but investigative roles can do much more damage to mafia than a doc. And since they knew hunter wasn't maf, they belived him.

What he was saying is, mafia likely wouldn't have bothered trying to kill him, because he had a huge chance of being lynched today. Thus you were a much better target for said kill.

 

[Ltin]

What he was saying is, mafia likely wouldn't have bothered trying to kill him, because he had a huge chance of being lynched today. Thus you were a much better target for said kill.

But he could also have info. On the maf.
If I were maf I would kill hunter too.

 

[Enderfive]

I still think notty is a third party that can win with mafia, similar to the third party cop.

That doesn't mean she has to win with the mafia, and considering we're on her like hawks anyway, I don't think she'll try anything funny at least now, so as far as I'm concerned, we might as well keep her alive.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

That doesn't mean she has to win with the mafia, and considering we're on her like hawks anyway, I don't think she'll try anything funny at least now, so as far as I'm concerned, we might as well keep her alive.

She's way too risky to keep alive, because it's so easy for her to totally tip the scales in the mafia's favor.
That is, if she IS the Inventor.
Why would she even claim cop if she was inventor, that's just asking to be killed at night while their role requires being alive.

 

[Ltin]

is, if she IS the Inventor.
Why would she even claim cop if she was inventor, that's just asking to be killed at night while their role requires being alive.

That is a good point
Could she be townsided and just not want to claim town to save herself from maf?

 

[Defiant_Blob]

Notty:
• threatened to mafia side
• claimed cop D1 with no useful report
• claimed inventor when called into question
• has a suspicious win condition
This vote is staying.

 

[Ltin]

Notty:
• threatened to mafia side
• claimed cop D1 with no useful report
• claimed inventor when called into question
• has a suspicious win condition
This vote is staying.

Point taken.
But she can't have had a report d1.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

Point taken.
But she can't have had a report d1.

Then why claim?

 

[Ltin]

Then why claim?

Uhh I don't remember her rational.

 

[Samlen]

Notty claimed because, according to her, she had a bomb that would kill anyone that would try and kill her.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

There's still no reason to claim.

 

[Nottykitten]

Notty claimed because, according to her, she had a bomb that would kill anyone that would try and kill her.

Yeah, or maybe I'm lying like defiant is saying and instead I claimed because I'm trying to blow up a certain person that needs to kill hercules. Or not. Who knows, Notty is confusing. But either way still wins with the town.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

Yeah, or maybe I'm lying like defiant is saying and instead I claimed because I'm trying to blow up a certain person that needs to kill hercules. Or not. Who knows, Notty is confusing. But either way still wins with the town.

Or wins with mafia. Or has an entirely made up win condition.
Why would you make a detective badge that only tells you guilty or not guilty?
Why not something that tells you their exact role?

 

[Ltin]

I don't know you tell me! My name is Hercules, and I am the cop. I can investigate one person each night and claiming cop on day 1 is my strategy. I will not blow up when someone kills me during the night and I too, have Amnesia.

Initial claim.
Very much looked like a joke. Hunter and a few others didn't realize this, and pressed it.

Hes not mafia either in his claim.

Not entirely relevant, but here she is defending a third party for the reason that he is not mafia. She had not claimed yet, but she might have been trying to further her interests if she did claim.

Ok there has been controversity my roleclaim. So I guess I will end it once and for all.

I lied about the claim being fake. As some of you suspected the claim was real. And I am, infact, Hercules the cop. I can investigate one person each night, and claiming cop on day 1 was indeed my strategy. Why would I claim you ask? Well all I'll say right now is that this is not part of a plan to have a Mafia watcher watch whoever visits me in the hope the Doctor protects me so that the Mafia find out who he is.

K. This is suspicious.
There wasnt actually that much confusion. It was unprecedented. And I have a feeling now that there might not actually be duplicate roles.

 

[Ltin]

Or wins with mafia. Or has an entirely made up win condition.
Why would you make a detective badge that only tells you guilty or not guilty?
Why not something that tells you their exact role?

Maybe it wasn't allowed?

 

[Nottykitten]

As I said, some things that are deemed too overpowered[like a button that kills all mafia or a knife that magically finds mafia] I cannot make. Finding out someone's role was deemed that way. Aswell as finding out wether someone was Third Party or not. All I could get was either innocent or guilty. So I can't make too big things.

 

[Nottykitten]

As for Ltin, why did you not Bodyblock and investigatethingy? Either you'd save him or get his results. Would of been way more efficient. And one of the reasons why I don't really trust your claim.

 

[Ltin]

As for Ltin, why did you not Bodyblock and investigatethingy? Either you'd save him or get his results. Would of been way more efficient. And one of the reasons why I don't really trust your claim.

I would rather he had been alive for two nights rather than one. I was fairly sure he would have been protected. I obviously forgot about roleblockers.

 

[Nottykitten]

This has nothing to do with roleblockers. It seems like you're telling a fake story and try to blame it on roleblockers.

 

[Ltin]

This has nothing to do with roleblockers. It seems like you're telling a fake story and try to blame it on roleblockers.

I answered your question. Then I want on my own. Problem?

 

[Nottykitten]

I answered your question. Then I want on my own. Problem?

Well yes, you seem to blame it on roleblockers, why do you think they had anything to do with hunters death?