TBD [Status: GAME OVER]

catgirl12466

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
66
Reaction score
270
I targeted catgirl night 1.
Hmm, no. I'm going to have to disagree and put on my skeptacles there, 77.

Alpha targetted me night 1. Nobody targetted me night 2. That's all that happened. If it wasn't obvious by my statement on the last day correcting the speculation on Alpha's actions and a thing I said in the inn last night about you knowing what happens to me, I can see who targets me at night. There's more to my role but I'd rather not claim yet, sorry.

Of course, I'm a bit fuzzy on the details so you could've been, say, roleblocked and I wouldn't have seen your name pop up. Then again, Alpha died on us and I still got a notification. Shoot, now I wonder...

Don't really know what else to say. Just... figured I had a duty to point that out. Your claim seems sound so far, I'm just puzzled about this.
 

digi

-
Donor
Contributor
Joined
Sep 15, 2011
Messages
961
Reaction score
2,827
Hmm, no. I'm going to have to disagree and put on my skeptacles there, 77.

Alpha targetted me night 1. Nobody targetted me night 2. That's all that happened. If it wasn't obvious by my statement on the last day correcting the speculation on Alpha's actions and a thing I said in the inn last night about you knowing what happens to me, I can see who targets me at night. There's more to my role but I'd rather not claim yet, sorry.

Of course, I'm a bit fuzzy on the details so you could've been, say, roleblocked and I wouldn't have seen your name pop up. Then again, Alpha died on us and I still got a notification. Shoot, now I wonder...

Don't really know what else to say. Just... figured I had a duty to point that out. Your claim seems sound so far, I'm just puzzled about this.
saywhaaaaaaaat?
 

Enderfive

sarcasm incarnate
Mafia Host
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4,802
What did I say people, what did I say.
Le said 'lets back off ltin and target duffie' but ohhhhh no.
Glad.

Anyways persons left on my fos for pushing ltin so hard.

vote jivvi
That makes absolutely no sense at all. First you imply that people voting for Ltin knew he was town, which we didn't, since we're also town and town doesn't know the other townies and secondly, Jivvi was the one saying that he thought Ltin was a townie, even though he screwed up. I don't recall him even placing a vote on him.

You better explain yourself better next time, otherwise we will keep on lynching townies that have played like we would expect scum to play and who knows, the suspicion may fall on you next, if you make such wild statements.
 

Lee_scar

Geezuslike
Donor
Joined
Aug 8, 2011
Messages
715
Reaction score
596
That makes absolutely no sense at all. First you imply that people voting for Ltin knew he was town, which we didn't, since we're also town and town doesn't know the other townies and secondly, Jivvi was the one saying that he thought Ltin was a townie, even though he screwed up. I don't recall him even placing a vote on him.

You better explain yourself better next time, otherwise we will keep on lynching townies that have played like we would expect scum to play and who knows, the suspicion may fall on you next, if you make such wild statements.
That's the fact, he KEPT saying how big of a towntell was going on. Either he was scum covering his own arse by saying 'jee I think ltin is towntelling, thus on my side' While in fact jivvi being scum would in fact know ltin was a town. If ltin rolled third party 'oh well I guess those towntells were right'

I wanted to back off ltin because I saw the mafia bandwagon too late. I even made sure to pick a much better target considering we might bee knee deep in lies, but at least he had the resolve to try and lie to us rather then 'teehee ima just here! no need to worry bout me!' and giving us jack and shit.
 

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
Welp I think we now know why Duffie didn't want Alpha to be lynched:
Duffie - Third Party Cultist
(Meets with other cultists every odd night and decides on a person to convert. Wins if Cultists reach a guaranteed vote majority)
Alpha must have also been a cultist and was one of those to help gain a vote majority!
...That or she just didn't want Alpha to die. Or maybe some other reason. *shrug*

And I'm curious about what catgirl said, because it seems... out of place.
I'm curious because even though cat claims she can see who visits her each night, I can't help but feel 77 is also telling the truth about killing the cultists, and thus, having visited cat the previous night. Someone has to be lying... or perhaps both are in fact telling the truth. Maybe we don't have all the information on this. Perhaps 77's night action doesn't quite count as a "visit" unless he actually kills a cultist. Idk.

That power itself is a bit curious: "able to tell who targets me each night;" sounds roughly along the lines of some kind of Rough Sleeper, Watcher combo or whatever.
 

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
I wanted to back off ltin because I saw the mafia bandwagon too late.
And who's to say you aren't just Mafia trying to back out on a vote you knew was going to result in a lynch and didn't want to quite be roped into those who voted off a townie? ;) Who knows?...
Though really that's just some silly speculation for a silly reason that tends to be brought up in games, though it could be a possibility~
Although I guess that could also apply to Jivvi or anyone else not voting given that idea.
-----
But that does give me a chance to quote something I said in my inn last night:
I also think its safe to say we'll probably find most if not all Mafia lynching Ltin yesterday since it was a fairly runaway lynch by the end of the day with little opposition. Possibly some not on the lynch or on others, but really that's a safe bet to imagine on Ltin (even if that is a bit of a bad line of reasoning or theorizing but it's just a general idea of things)

Ltin - 11 -CoffeusKittus, nottykitten, endersteve5, Ooglie101, 77_is_the_best, timdood3, samlen, xXxFruitNinjaxXx , cooliorules, the road to ruin, Defiant_Blob

We know 3 of the 11: CifKat, Knotsberry, and Slenderman, Caff claiming Jailer-Doctor something, alignment up for debate; Notts claimed Third-party Inventor, and Endersteve was "cleared" by notty's invention (which I still feel is true from the same reasoning as I said in the thread).

I'm almost certain about Notty/Ender, unsure about Caff.
Then there's the other 8 people. I suspect at least 5 to 6 mafia(in the game total) based on general Mafia-to-Total Players ratio thats usually around in these games, so at least 3 is in this group.(rough estimate)
So my general stance would be to look at people yesterday~
----
However in terms of Lee's vote on Jivvi:
That's the fact, he KEPT saying how big of a towntell was going on. Either he was scum covering his own arse by saying 'jee I think ltin is towntelling, thus on my side' While in fact jivvi being scum would in fact know ltin was a town. If ltin rolled third party 'oh well I guess those towntells were right'
I ended up reading back to roughly page 70, and as far as I can see, I feel like you're example here isn't very good to go off of without some better reasoning.
I only found 2 instances (I believe I saw a third but couldn't find it again my 2nd time reading back) of Jivvi ever saying he thought Ltin was "towntelling;" once on page 72, and a second time on page 77, neither times saying it was a big towntell, rather it was from "his point of view" and the second "slightly less towntelling" (due to the lies iirc from what I read).
----
And though I do not necessarily condone or support the vote, I feel like, given the circumstance, I can also quote something I talked about in my inn last night because I'm still generally wary of alignments despite role claims (exceptions are Notty and Ender of course, but that's just me):
I just realized something that, in my opinion, is a bit suspicious, namely Jivvi and his role:
I missed that one too, dear <3

Used the bleed on hunter, so I'm guessing I was visited

(didn't want to risk blocking him)
I know he says that he probably was visited... but now that I look back on it... I'm not so certain to believe in that. It's like when Ltin claimed that he was "probably roleblocked" (even though that all ended up in being lies+Ltin being town); it itself seems kind of flimsy.

Even though Jivvi has been fairly talkative, he's also been somewhat on the sidelines, not really being focused on too much. Especially his claim, it was never really touched on, like everyone essentially ignored it with no real questioning of it. Everyone elses claims have been fairly blown up.

So I'm kind of suspicious of that.
Which frankly isn't that strong of a reason to be skeptical(or a basis for a lynch because I don't really see any point in lynching Jivvi since there hasn't been much of a reason to do so), It's only something I thought was curious and worth keeping in mind (since we never can be sure of a roleblocker actually existing until investigated or dead by some means, which was also a thing which made people skeptical of Ltin in the first place).

But that's just my opinion on the subject.
I would also love to know what everyone did last night, like
Notty's invention was used or Jivvi's Jack-of-all-trades usage or something, since those roles already claimed could give us some insight onto why we only had 1 kill last night (namely by 77)
I would imagine someone at least has to have bulletproof or something similar, or was roleblocked, or anything along those lines. Or maybe they can only kill every other night since we've only had 2 nights... I don't know.
 

77thShad

Ayy lmao
Joined
Jan 12, 2012
Messages
1,079
Reaction score
1,035
Perhaps 77's night action doesn't quite count as a "visit" unless he actually kills a cultist. Idk.
This. In my mind I said that when I said this but I now see that it wasn't clear at all ._.

if they are a cultist, they die, and if not then I merely know that they are not a cultist and I choose someone else the next night.
If I target someone who is not a cultist, then I do not visit them and nothing happens. I kind of 'scout them out' before I kill them/dont kill them. I think that's the best way to explain it.
 

catgirl12466

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
66
Reaction score
270
Well, hmm.
I'm not quite sure how to say this. I want to believe your claim, considering it's harmless enough, but this really isn't adding up from my point of view.It's not the "visit" that counts. It's whether or not I was targeted at any point by the person. Insistent on the terminology, I suppose. Also, as a correction to what I said before, I will still see a roleblocked person's target on me. That means that, unless there's an incredibly obscure role in the game that can block my specific sight on someone or something to that effect, there's something fishy going on here.But yeah, um, I don't want to invoke LAL considering what happened last day (and the fact that we're already down 1/4 of the initial players, and none have been mafia so far). I just want to get to the bottom of this.also wow I misspelled a lot of things last post, criiinge
 

Samlen

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Messages
187
Reaction score
353
.... why does there have to be a cult :C
I don't completely know what to do about the cult, especially since the only person Duffie seemed to be 'teamed' with was Alpha(Whom didn't come up as a cultist.. so I'm wondering if Duffie did have something related to Alpha and just got converted n1 or if he was just trying to throw us off...) though I think he did try to keep other third-parties from being lynched (Don't know for sure, haven't double checked this yet, though it might not even amount to anything, given how he reacted about Alpha...).
In other thoughts, Notty, you probably won't tell me, but did you take my suggestion from our room for your invention? =p
Also, Lee, you seem to sorta be jumping a little quickly to conclusions about Jivvi, though I understand the idea of not completely trusting anyone. Dunno if there's much else to say about it other than to wait and see how Jivvi responds, though I do wonder what role might have visited him n1 to have activated his 'paranoia' and what he did tonight...
About the catgirl/77 contradiction, I think I'll need to think about it more before I come up with anything more concrete other than that neither seems to be blatantly lying... but I would certainly prefer to think about it more before I come to a solid conclusion, if such a thing exists in this game =/
 

77thShad

Ayy lmao
Joined
Jan 12, 2012
Messages
1,079
Reaction score
1,035
I could have done that but I didn't want to risk putting myself out there until I hit someone however I was planning on coming out today anyway because I do agree that the cult is a problem but it's only a problem late game after power roles have been converted which is why I held my tongue until now.
 

Jivvi

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
2,769
Reaction score
4,596
I could have done that but I didn't want to risk putting myself out there until I hit someone however I was planning on coming out today anyway because I do agree that the cult is a problem but it's only a problem late game after power roles have been converted which is why I held my tongue until now.
it's a lot nicer if you tell us before we lose prs and it becomes a problem so we can avert exactly that situation

why wait for it when it would have been possible to preempt it? >.>

you could have at least brought up the possibility of a cult, or fake claimed cat's role or something similar to at least warn us that there is a cult
 
Top