General Quarters [Game Over]
- Thread starter Ltin
- Start date
Oh, forgot that foggy could be proven if he is right about that we will get split into different pms. Forget what I said there
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Okay, I just caught up with the discussion.
I want to say, in regards to this, and the fact that there are "ranks," E.g. the XO or Captain, I do believe the ranks are what our role-names are essentially called (and I just want to say, I went back to look at my role, I totally missed the fact that I too have a rank; holy hell how am I completely blind, how did I miss that).
Thus, I believe that is what will show up when a player dies, with a description of their abilities alongside it, like with what happened to hip.
That's just a theory anyways, because I know if I were to claim, I would claim myself as a vanilla role, because that is essentially what I know it to be, and how I would describe it as.
If the roles are tied somewhat tied to rank, which could also easily be doubtful considering Arelic was "promoted" (although do we know if promotions possibly lead to a change in abilities? Or if they serve a special purpose like with hips win condition/Foggy's ability?), but if they are, then me claiming my rank wouldn't say much at all to what my actual role is.
Okay I'm just making this all convoluted: I would say my role is vanilla, so it is possible, yes.
I can easily claim if you would like me to show what I mean; although I don't necessarily see a reason to do so at this point in time, though some might disagree in the future.
**********************************
Anyways, onto thoughts of the day?Honestly, I think we already know how this day is going to end, unless something drastically new happens, which could be possible, but I doubt it.
I trust HK; honestly I feel like there's been quite a bit of soft-claiming (I don't know if its purposeful or not) and I think I already have an idea on what role they are, or at least aspects from certain vanilla roles that HK might have. Some parts have me confused based on what I think HK's role might be, but otherwise I think it's a bit easy to read into. I don't think I'll say what I think it is since HK doesn't want to claim yet and fishing out wild ideas might not be the wisest thing to do to protect a possible town PR; but I think I have a fairly good read on it, and trust HK for the moment as I don't see it as very "incriminating."
E.g. see this by Notty:
I may have missed it, but I don't think I've seen Notty say anything wrong with HK visiting her last night; just that HK "visited."
But-- did anything happen? Usually visits in Mafia games result in either death from the hands of mafia/vig/etc, investigations from cop/etc, doctor protection, etc. But nothing happened that we know of.
Since we don't quite have enough information, although again I may have missed it because Inffy's posts have made me so confused this day, I don't see that as something that's incriminating at all at this point in time, and that's even if it's true in the first place. It's something we should keep in mind, but as its the very first day, and nothing else really points to HK at all, I don't see it as something we should really be worrying about at this moment.
If anything, it's just a misdirection/desperate bid to get attention elsewhere.
In other news; after Foggy said they can promote people and have multiple actions they can give to people (like... I dont know.. they assign tasks to lower ranks?) and since we knew Hip's role's goal was to become Captain--- I thought it was safe to assume Foggy would claim captain at some point, which did happen.
I'm... worried though. I imagine captain's the highest rank in the game based on hip's role, and thus one of the most powerful roles I'd imagine. If it can't be protected, then it might've been bad to claim so early, especially if certain roles specifically focus on player's ranks, like Hip's was; can certain people steal ranks? Maybe they change ranks by killing certain players? Again, I feel like ranks are inherently tied to our roles, so maybe our roles change as we gain ranks?
It's all speculation at this point (or I'm just reading too much into things that aren't there).
But at the same time, and I think either Inffy or myuser mentioned this idea earlier; the idea that Hip's condition was to becoming "acting" captain, so maybe if Foggy dies his abilities will pass along to the next person to become captain? Like its a changeable role that can be passed along; maybe becoming less/more powerful as the days progress?
If so, it's a very interesting idea for a mafia game role, and would be useful in weeding out anti-townies (although; I also wonder if acting captain can be passed along to mafiosos?)
...There's so much about the ranks that could happen; I'm really wondering how they actually work.
I--- don't think there's anything else to talk about?
I guess--- Arelic?
They're just sort of a pawn of Foggy at the moment; nothing really proves their alignment/etc. Just that Foggy's ability went through last night and explains how we got to this moment in the game.
Also,
Vote Notty,
because again, I think we know how this day will end already, and I feel like there's enough evidence/information there that doesn't quite add up to Notty being innocent.
VOTECOUNT
It looks like a ransom note.
Nottykitten - 6 - Foggy2406, Arelic, HKCaper, K1ngHoward, Webpaige, JKangaroo
Infected_alien8_ - 1 - Nottykitten
With 15 players it takes 8 to lynch and 8 to no lynch
This post is so much worse when not on tapatalk
It looks like a ransom note.
Nottykitten - 6 - Foggy2406, Arelic, HKCaper, K1ngHoward, Webpaige, JKangaroo
Infected_alien8_ - 1 - Nottykitten
With 15 players it takes 8 to lynch and 8 to no lynch
Okay, so I've read and caught up. I've had plenty of time to think this over, and I still think the only thing that fits is the bus driver theory. Hk will never be able to account for 100% of all scenarios, but if he is willing to guarantee it can't be a bus driver scenario then I feel safe voting for Notty. However, this puts it at a 50/50 between Notty and Hk, and if Notty flips up inno I think we can be '100% certain' Hk is mafia. I've no clues as to what HK's role could be, but it sounds like he has guaranteed a bus driver doesn't make sense, and that's good for me.
The votes on Notty are piling up, but before the day ends I'd like to put out some thoughts.
First: It's still possible Notty is a mafia sided tracker (but I have no clue why she'd lie about HK in this case)
Second:
Also, It's worth noting that I'm casting this vote despite the fact Notty is town telling, If she flips mafia I'd just like to comment how well she is playing, but at the same time I know she is very good at appeal to emotion strategies, so I'm going to have to overlook that as I believe she could easily be faking these town tells. Maybe this will look suspicious to some people, but I think this is in the best interest of the town right now.
Vote NottyKitten
The votes on Notty are piling up, but before the day ends I'd like to put out some thoughts.
First: It's still possible Notty is a mafia sided tracker (but I have no clue why she'd lie about HK in this case)
Second:
but you're assuming the tracker role specifically is part of this game, which we have no evidence for. Sure, It would be cool if the ranks foggy could promote people to were also roles we also had, but Isn't also equally possible that they actually appear in the game on the mafia team as the mafia varients and town has an entirely different set of power roles? or that the roles don't show at all and town has an entirely different set of power roles? It'd be nice if the town had a tracker, but there is nothing confirming there is a town sided tracker in this game (otherwise Notty would be 100% clear) I can't find the post where Foggy said what he could actually promote people to, but both of these options seem likely, especially since there are a lot of ways that having all of those roles could be pretty OP (especially if we can get the temporary roles on top of them)
Also, It's worth noting that I'm casting this vote despite the fact Notty is town telling, If she flips mafia I'd just like to comment how well she is playing, but at the same time I know she is very good at appeal to emotion strategies, so I'm going to have to overlook that as I believe she could easily be faking these town tells. Maybe this will look suspicious to some people, but I think this is in the best interest of the town right now.
Vote NottyKitten
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
I haven't read the past few games-- what do those roles do? x)
...Or are they the same as description on epicmafia that I just googled? https://epicmafia.com/role/429
Just wondering since I don't think I've been in a game with those before. (I think)
FINAL VOTECOUNT
Nottykitten - 8 - Foggy2406 (x2), Arelic, HKCaper, K1ngHoward, Webpaige, JKangaroo, Myusername22
Infected_alien8_ - 1 - Nottykitten
Nottykitten was accused of being among the mutineers. The crew executed her, and found their suspicions to be correct.
Just then alarms began to ring throughout the ship.
"ALL HANDS GENERAL QUARTERS. ALL HANDS GENERAL QUARTERS. THIS IS NOT A DRILL. ALL HANDS GENERAL QUARTERS."
The ship's crew rushed to their stations.
Enlisted 2nd Class Nottykitten was a mutineer assigned to engineering.
It is now Night 2. The ship is currently at general quarters. All roles please submit your actions.
Nottykitten - 8 - Foggy2406 (x2), Arelic, HKCaper, K1ngHoward, Webpaige, JKangaroo, Myusername22
Infected_alien8_ - 1 - Nottykitten
Nottykitten was accused of being among the mutineers. The crew executed her, and found their suspicions to be correct.
Just then alarms began to ring throughout the ship.
"ALL HANDS GENERAL QUARTERS. ALL HANDS GENERAL QUARTERS. THIS IS NOT A DRILL. ALL HANDS GENERAL QUARTERS."
The ship's crew rushed to their stations.
Enlisted 2nd Class Nottykitten was a mutineer assigned to engineering.
vanilla mafia role
It is now Night 2. The ship is currently at general quarters. All roles please submit your actions.
Last edited:
"Stand down from general quarters. Report."
"Two deaths sir. Enlisted 1st Class HKCaper, and Enlisted 1st Class TheWeakGuy48_."
Enlisted 1st Class HKCaper was the Mess Manager, and assigned to science.
Enlisted 1st Class TheWeakGuy48_ was the Sentry, and assigned to engineering.
It is now Day 2.
With 12 players it takes 7 to lynch and 6 to no lynch.
"Two deaths sir. Enlisted 1st Class HKCaper, and Enlisted 1st Class TheWeakGuy48_."
Enlisted 1st Class HKCaper was the Mess Manager, and assigned to science.
Blocks a player each night.
Enlisted 1st Class TheWeakGuy48_ was the Sentry, and assigned to engineering.
May either watch or kill a player each night.
It is now Day 2.
With 12 players it takes 7 to lynch and 6 to no lynch.
What's the game plan with general quarters? Should we announce who is in each division? That's what I'm tempted to do, but I figure you might have inside information on this.
Also, will make a post summarizing my current thoughts soon.
I'm in engineering. With notty dead it was just me, ender, and TWG. We didnt really discuss much of anything: TWG asked my role and I told him I didn't think it was a good time to be claiming yet. I said if he had anything he thought was important to share that he should share it, but he said nothing. Kind of wish we had all claimed now because he might've had information from watching someone 
, but it's just as likely he got nothing.
Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk
, but it's just as likely he got nothing.Sent from my XT1635-01 using Tapatalk