Tavern Arcana - Mafia Win

[hipmeow]

He did say he each night learn a random role but only IF HE WASNT VISITIED

???

 

[Mooglie]

???

did you not see infs claim

 

[Enderfive]

Enderfive CLAIM. YOUR. CARD.

no

 

[hipmeow]

did you not see infs claim

yeah but i thought it was a fake claim

 

[Aqua]

no

CLAIM. YOUR. CARD.

 

[Nottykitten]

yeah but i thought it was a fake claim

It was but Unu is saying that during the night we didn't know that for sure yet, and hes speculating why Inf even died which is a pretty valid point since hes a good lynch target as he almost died yesterday.

 

[Enderfive]

CLAIM. YOUR. CARD.

no

 

[Aqua]

no

CLAIM. YOUR. CARD.

 

[Mooglie]

CLAIM. YOUR. CARD.

Arelic Jolterino

can we get a modkill on aqua for spamming!! <3

 

[Enderfive]

CLAIM. YOUR. CARD.

no

 

[Unusual_Dood]

If a vig actually killed Inf there’s a high chance either a doctor saved an anti-mafia/SK or roleblocker blocked mafia/SK

 

[Dess]

Can somebody detail why aqua is pushing ender so much

 

[Enderfive]

If a vig actually killed Inf there’s a high chance either a doctor saved an anti-mafia/SK or roleblocker blocked mafia/SK

or maybe not every game needs to have an sk

 

[Danni122112]

example of?

A mafia game without a cop.

There seems to be a general opinion that we have a cop, but if you can't find any, that makes your claim bad.

Thanks to Uny for finding one, I still stand by that it's highly unlikely that we do not have a cop.

 

[Nottykitten]

Can somebody detail why aqua is pushing ender so much

Inf, the Hermit, is not actually dead but murdered Aqua and is now wearing his skin. It's the only explanation for this

 

[Aqua]

Can somebody detail why aqua is pushing ender so much

Because he's defending notty an unreasonable amount and trying to undermine my arguments against her to make me look like I'm scum trying to tunnel vision notty.

 

[Unusual_Dood]

or maybe not every game needs to have an sk

Yes, that’s why I only said ‘high chance’

 

[Nottykitten]

Because he's defending notty an unreasonable amount and trying to undermine my arguments against her to make me look like I'm scum trying to tunnel vision notty.

Hes actually the most rational person in this game right now and I love him for it

 

[Danni122112]

Righto, this is my standpoint on things:
I don't want to lynch Notty today, reasons stated a million times before, but boils down to that she can be a PR role, and we do not have strong enough evidence to lynch her today, when we can (most likely) do it safe tomorrow. I am all for lynching her tomorrow.

I like the way ender and the weak guy state their arguments. Unu is fine, notty is fine. I do not like the way Aqua states his. I am always happy with lynching Aqua D 1, but I'm vibing him town.

I still think we should investigate choco more, and some others.

I like the discussion on Aqua, not necessarily in support of a lynch though.

For the record, I do not 100% think notty is innocent, but we will know tomorrow or tomorrow night, and I do not want to lynch a potential PR now.

 

[Mooglie]

tbh its difficult to say why choco isnt as susp as notty when he seems to have disappeared and made 0 attempt to defend himelf

i still think we should lynch notty today

 

[hipmeow]

tbh i think we gain some valuable info if we lynch notty because if she flips maf then theres a good chance that we know the rest of the maf will have scummy cards. if she flips town then we know that scummy cards can be given to townies.

 

[TheWeakGuy48_]

Honestly I'd very much like if we could all claim our rolenames, it could give us more info, and I doubt there will be any big downsides of claiming it today.

 

[Nottykitten]

tbh i think we gain some valuable info if we lynch notty because if she flips maf then theres a good chance that we know the rest of the maf will have scummy cards. if she flips town then we know that scummy cards can be given to townies.

tbh i think we gain some valuable info if we lynch aqua because if he flips maf then theres a good chance that we know the rest of the maf will have acted super scummy aswell. if he flips town then we know that acting super scummy can be done by townies.

 

[Aqua]

Honestly I'd very much like if we could all claim our rolenames, it could give us more info, and I doubt there will be any big downsides of claiming it today.

No mass claiming. For the 10000000th time.

 

[Mooglie]

Honestly I'd very much like if we could all claim our rolenames, it could give us more info, and I doubt there will be any big downsides of claiming it today.

tbh until its PROVEN that cards -> alignments (surprise im NOT SAYING ITS A DEFINITE THING BUT ITS A VERY LIKELY THING WE CAN FIND OUT BY LYNCHING NOTTY) i'd say it's more of a risk since u never know what roles exist!!