Tavern Arcana - Mafia Win
- Thread starter Jolterino
- Start date
ok i would point out how much sus stuff notty has said today but im going to bed rn cause its quarter to five so like if you lack independent thought look out for my post tomorrow otherwise vote notty thanks
Okay, So finally after all this time I'm caught up and understand what's happening. This game is stupid we should've lynched Notty Day 0, but we didn't and now Notty has killed aqua, who was probably being honest about his role. Notty's role is absolutely rediculous, there's no way it's true. That said, Notty makes up roles in most games regardless of alignment, so the fake role doesn't immediately suggest Notty is mafia. However, if Notty were town this role would probably be designed to scum hunt, and Notty hasn't once mentioned or shown a way this role helps the town. It feels more like Notty is just desperately lying to stay alive at this point. On top of that Notty's behavior was really scummy the entire way through. I'm not one to believe roles = alignment or roles != alignment, so I won't really comment on it from that perspective
For the longest time I found it weird that ender was supporting Notty. I was beginning to think that either we should definitely lynch him next because he must be Notty's mafia buddy, or he was the fool trying to look like Notty's mafia buddy to be the next lynch. It looks to me like Ender just picked the most suspicious person and tried to defend them as hard as possible, so I think it's safe to assume he's the fool. Especially now that Roobarb_Pie has just investigated him as a fool it's by far most likely that Ender is a vanilla fool trying to get himself lynched. The safest route to dealing with ender would be to kill him at night somehow, but since our town 1 shot just died and had already used his kill on inffy ( If you believe Aqua's claim, which I assume is a safe thing to believe at this point) it's unlikely that we as a town have another killing role, so we're kind of out luck there. The safest way to deal with ender at this point is probably to just not lynch him because I feel confident he's much more likely to be a vanilla fool than to be mafia (especially since he has the role of fool)
Since there's been no cop claim today I think it's safe to say there won't be a cop claim coming out suddenly saying Notty's innocent, so i'm just going to place my vote and suggest todays lynch.
VOTE NOTTY
For the longest time I found it weird that ender was supporting Notty. I was beginning to think that either we should definitely lynch him next because he must be Notty's mafia buddy, or he was the fool trying to look like Notty's mafia buddy to be the next lynch. It looks to me like Ender just picked the most suspicious person and tried to defend them as hard as possible, so I think it's safe to assume he's the fool. Especially now that Roobarb_Pie has just investigated him as a fool it's by far most likely that Ender is a vanilla fool trying to get himself lynched. The safest route to dealing with ender would be to kill him at night somehow, but since our town 1 shot just died and had already used his kill on inffy ( If you believe Aqua's claim, which I assume is a safe thing to believe at this point) it's unlikely that we as a town have another killing role, so we're kind of out luck there. The safest way to deal with ender at this point is probably to just not lynch him because I feel confident he's much more likely to be a vanilla fool than to be mafia (especially since he has the role of fool)
Since there's been no cop claim today I think it's safe to say there won't be a cop claim coming out suddenly saying Notty's innocent, so i'm just going to place my vote and suggest todays lynch.
VOTE NOTTY
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
I disagree, we have a gunsmith so if we want to get rid of the fool they could give out another gun and shoot Ender with it.
Excuse me what have I been doing day 0(Inf+Choco+Aqua), day 1(Choco + Aqua) and now day 2(Aqua + Unu as gut feeling). I've been scumhunting the entire time yet youve ignored my advances and voted for me instead. Not the worst idea since Choco turned out to be the doctor but I was right about the other 2.
I have a talent show to run at school so I'll post more in like 8 hours.
We've basically had it confirmed that Notty is not the fool at this point and they've done bunch of crazy stuff and claims. Whether they actually shot Aqua or not (I doubt they did since I feel like they would've done so real quick) they should be lynched.
vote Notty
We've basically had it confirmed that Notty is not the fool at this point and they've done bunch of crazy stuff and claims. Whether they actually shot Aqua or not (I doubt they did since I feel like they would've done so real quick) they should be lynched.
vote Notty
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Says you mr moon voice stealer.
Except I wanted to wait till he had claimed to make my final judgement which I thought was gonna be later in the day. But since he did it so fast and it was trash I murdered him.
Nope.
I don't think of you as any less suspicious for this, but that's a fair point, if this is a gunsmith situation (Which there are other possibilities, including you lying).
Speaking of which, was anyone gunned yesterday that didn't mention it? Because that could lead some credibility towards knowing if there are guns in this game or if something else killed aqua?
Please come forward if anyone else in this game has received a gun. It's possible the gunsmith just chose not to gun anyone though.
G
Guest35486
Guest
[BCOLOR=transparent]Day 2 - Vote Count [/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=transparent]Unusual_Dood (2): Unusual_Dood, Nottykitten[/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=transparent]Nottykitten (7): hipman500(x2), Fog, Jivvi, myusername22, erik5456, Iggish[/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=transparent]With 19 players alive, it takes 10 players to lynch and 10 players to no lynch.[/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=transparent]If the required vote amount is not reached by the deadline, the player with the most votes will be lynched.[/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=transparent]Unusual_Dood (2): Unusual_Dood, Nottykitten[/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=transparent]Nottykitten (7): hipman500(x2), Fog, Jivvi, myusername22, erik5456, Iggish[/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=transparent]With 19 players alive, it takes 10 players to lynch and 10 players to no lynch.[/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=transparent]If the required vote amount is not reached by the deadline, the player with the most votes will be lynched.[/BCOLOR]
???
How is this a valid point?
People don't know who the scum are, so saying that the fact choco died and flipped doctor, doesn't make notty any more guilty than if he had flipped town.
Also, why the fuck were you people so bloodthirsty? Choco didn't even get to claim but y'all just went ahead with a bandwagon anyway.
Ok, I lied, it's not one-shot, I just wanted to see if hip would lie about receiving it, therefore making me look scummy (looking back, it was a stupid plan that no scum would fall for.)
Yeah but I chose to message hip because I thought he could've maybe been scum *shrug*
Comp confirm that you received my message from the first night please.