Republic - Completed

[Aqua]

They do make sense though since killing dictator pushes her towards 1/3 win cons, and since it makes town in a bad spot, although she'd be suspected of being anti-town, she can claim rev to stop town killing her at night

The only way for her to win after claiming rev is to make it to the final 3 which neither town nor mafia would allow her to get anywhere close

 

[Infected_alien8_]

The only way for her to win after claiming rev is to make it to the final 3 which neither town nor mafia would allow her to get anywhere close

Claiming rev doesn't make her unable to do any of the other win conditions

 

[Aqua]

Claiming rev doesn't make her unable to do any of the other win conditions

Overthrow the state yourself by being installed as dictator without being killed or overthrown, witnessing three dictators being killed or overthrown resulting in a council of fewer than three, or surviving to the final day.

Explain how she could achieve any of these with town and mafia both being fully aware of who rev is? (Without town and mafia just giving her victory or being completely retarded because surprisingly there are some of us here who aren't.)

 

[Nottykitten]

Ooglie101 I think you're oversimplifying what the 'real rev' would do. Killing notty would be the safe play, but I think trying to snipe a mafia member would be the winning play, and I'd imagine if notty is not rev the 'real rev' would go for the winning play

What are you saying here? Sounds like youre saying I'm not Mafia because the 'real' revo would try to snipe a Mafia and clearly in that scenario im fake claiming which would make me a guarantreed target for the revo yet you say the revo would try to snipe a Mafia instead of me?

 

[Aqua]

What are you saying here? Sounds like youre saying I'm not Mafia because the 'real' revo would try to snipe a Mafia and clearly in that scenario im fake claiming which would make me a guarantreed target for the revo yet you say the revo would try to snipe a Mafia instead of me?

Because you're being lynched hun so there's no need to target you <3

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Explain how she could achieve any of these with town and mafia both being fully aware of who rev is? (Without town and mafia just giving her victory or being completely retarded because surprisingly there are some of us here who aren't.)

She couldn't have done the 1st anyway, claiming doesn't stop her being kept alive and guessing dictator correctly (since it's in our benefit to keep her alive and she can't be killed by maf) and she makes the 3rd one easier

 

[Aqua]

She couldn't have done the 1st anyway, claiming doesn't stop her being kept alive and guessing dictator correctly (since it's in our benefit to keep her alive and she can't be killed by maf) and she makes the 3rd one easier

So we don't install a dictatorship and as town why would you not lynch her soon enough that she couldn't get close ot being one of the last 3?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

So we don't install a dictatorship and as town why would you not lynch her soon enough that she couldn't get close ot being one of the last 3?

because she's confident she isn't gonna let that happen

but I think she's mistaken

I agree with you that claiming rev wasn't the optimal play but I don't see how it's like 'there's nO WAY she did this as rev'

 

[Aqua]

I agree with you that claiming rev wasn't the optimal play but I don't see how it's like 'there's nO WAY she did this as rev'

Ok but it's unlikely, it's far far more likely she'd do it as maf. If we don't kill her tonight and she is maf then we will probably lose anyway. I literally don't understand why you trust her so much. I swear you're just doing it out of spite because you were completely wrong day 1 and fucked up the game.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

it basically was a weighing up of 'likelihood town will try to kill me at night' vs 'how well am i able to keep them in mylo'

 

[Danni122112]

If she thought she could be nightkilled by town then she had a reason to claim, to ensure that never happened. After last night she said she thought she'd be suspected (and she was, by the Assassin) and thus was worried about being killed by them in the night or killed by the dictator. Claiming in this scenario makes complete sense, provided she didn't think she could be Mafia night-killed

Honestly, I’m not gonna trust someone’s claimif their sole defense is stupidity. This is a principle in most mafia games, and it’s notty, notty is smarter than this, realize this, our get a bloody mafia stamp when her role is revealed. Your choice is now.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Honestly, I’m not gonna trust someone’s claimif their sole defense is stupidity. This is a principle in most mafia games, and it’s notty, notty is smarter than this, realize this, our get a bloody mafia stamp when her role is revealed. Your choice is now.

their sole defence isn't stupidity, read my posts

 

[Aqua]

their sole defence isn't stupidity, read my posts

Claiming ignorance doesn't = innocence

 

[Danni122112]

They do make sense though since killing dictator pushes her towards 1/3 win cons, and since it makes town in a bad spot, although she'd be suspected of being anti-town, she can claim rev to stop town killing her at night

She is claiming she did anti town action, to fuck town so hard sideways to the wall that they are practically begging for it, you want to tryst this person??? This does not make sense for a rev to do, and even if she was rev, her only interest is fucking the game.

Stop being stupid inf, you are better than this.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Claiming ignorance doesn't = innocence

I'm not saying she's proven I'm saying there is a reasonable reason as to why she'd claim rev, as rev

 

[Infected_alien8_]

She is claiming she did anti town action, to fuck town so hard sideways to the wall that they are practically begging for it, you want to tryst this person??? This does not make sense for a rev to do, and even if she was rev, her only interest is fucking the game.

Stop being stupid inf, you are better than this.

do you realize what the rev win con is? she needs town to be on the verge of losing to win as rev in order to be kept alive if she claims

 

[Danni122112]

I’m not gonna type more tonight, since I’m on my way to get shitfaced, and it won’t end well.

Stop being stupid.

Kill notty.

 

[Aqua]

I'm not saying she's proven I'm saying there is a reasonable reason as to why she'd claim rev, as rev

But there's far more reason why she'd claim it as maf and far more reason she'd be in this predicament in the first place if she was maf. Notty isn't dumb inf, it wouldn't surprise me if she had learnt the roles and rules of the game better than anyone. A basic error costing her entire position based on "misreading her role" is an insane assumption.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

But there's far more reason why she'd claim it as maf and far more reason she'd be in this predicament in the first place if she was maf. Notty isn't dumb inf, it wouldn't surprise me if she had learnt the roles and rules of the game better than anyone. A basic error costing her entire position based on "misreading her role" is an insane assumption.

I'm not assuming she's rev, I'm saying it's bad to assume she's not

If we aren't sure if she's rev or not it makes more sense to keep her alive just in case she is

 

[Mooglie]

bit disappointed i claimed and noone else has tbh

 

[Aqua]

I'm not assuming she's rev, I'm saying it's bad to assume she's not

If we aren't sure if she's rev or not it makes more sense to keep her alive just in case she is

I am sure, to a very high degree. Based on all the evidence I've presented against her and how I've been spot on about her the entire game I deserve to be confident.


Besides if she is rev, the small chance she is, it isn't negative towards the town when she's threatening to target ender. You have to realise town can win without notty and relying a wild card who can't realistically win and has no reason to help you is insane.

 

[Danni122112]

bit disappointed i claimed and noone else has tbh

I’m civilian, or whatever it is, how useful.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I am sure, to a very high degree. Based on all the evidence I've presented against her and how I've been spot on about her the entire game I deserve to be confident.

And what about the evidence brought against you?

Besides if she is rev, the small chance she is, it isn't negative towards the town when she's threatening to target ender. You have to realise town can win without notty and relying a wild card who can't realistically win and has no reason to help you is insane.

Except she does have a reason to help us since her win con relies on it

The only thing I'm against with Notty is that I disagree with her scumreads which makes me doubt keeping her alive will in fact help us tbh

 

[Danni122112]

And what about the evidence brought against you?


Except she does have a reason to help us since her win con relies on it

The only thing I'm against with Notty is that I disagree with her scumreads which makes me doubt keeping her alive will in fact help us tbh

She is not the fucking rev, wether her win condition as rev, goes towards helping us is irrelevant. A rev would not play the way she has, she did not play he way a rev would before her claim. Why the actually unholy fuck so you believe her?? The only reason you believe her is because she said so. Why the duck so you trust her?? It doesn’t add up to how you play, and if you weren’t an un cced townie, I would have lined you up next.

Like check in your mind, try and imagine literally anyone else as rev, and it would be more likely, why the hell do you think it’s notty.

Because you are an un cced townie, I trust you are town, but holy fuck STEP UP YOUR GAME INFFY.
You are embarrassing yourself.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

She is not the fucking rev, wether her win condition as rev, goes towards helping us is irrelevant. A rev would not play the way she has, she did not play he way a rev would before her claim. Why the actually unholy fuck so you believe her?? The only reason you believe her is because she said so. Why the duck so you trust her?? It doesn’t add up to how you play, and if you weren’t an un cced townie, I would have lined you up next.

Like check in your mind, try and imagine literally anyone else as rev, and it would be more likely, why the hell do you think it’s notty.

Because you are an un cced townie, I trust you are town, but holy fuck STEP UP YOUR GAME INFFY.
You are embarrassing yourself.

until you actually read and consider my posts and stop calling anyone who disagrees with you stupid, even though you're wrong, im just going to ignore you from here on out