Spaghetti Mafia - Game Complete
- Thread starter TheWeakGuy48_
- Start date
- Status
Ok so I'm going to reiterate this. I got major scum readings from teh. I know he claims that he was "just testing" people's reactions to a godfather claim but there's something I can't quite shake off how terrible a plan that is as a villager.
I can't really gauge much from aqua buts thatthats because he's been mostly quiet this whole game
I can't really gauge much from aqua buts thatthats because he's been mostly quiet this whole game
I honestly can't argue for anyone else, they all seem suspicious, but I am 100% no doubt a villager. I'm being serious. I don't know how I can prove it but it'd be really odd if I was actually godfather and I said that like what how would that help me?
Glad to see there was no kill last night. Unfortunately we still can't mislynch.
Here are some of my thoughts on people.
Beta - Often pretty lowkey but a great player who notices things others often don't. I trust Beta right now more than anyone else.
Unu - Not really acive, does come in with some useful points for town every once in a while. I think he's town.
Roob - Seems like he's not really paying a lot of attention. Weird doctor claim thing. Could possibly be a mafia with his little voting switch, voting TehBrian as if testing out the waters and then switching to enderfive... That's a little far fetched though. I get the feeling that roob is a villager.
Aqua - Can you explain yourself? Hammering Ender right at the end like that (and then reacting to the message saying he was a villager with "winner") With really no discussion on your part... I'm not sure if that's more like confused or erroneous mafia play, or sloppy/joking villager play.
TehBrian - Honestly seems most mafia like to me. He's actually a pretty good player in werewolf (granted this game is different) and he seems to have been playing rather sloppy this game.
I wrote this a little while ago just posting it now.
Here are some of my thoughts on people.
Beta - Often pretty lowkey but a great player who notices things others often don't. I trust Beta right now more than anyone else.
Unu - Not really acive, does come in with some useful points for town every once in a while. I think he's town.
Roob - Seems like he's not really paying a lot of attention. Weird doctor claim thing. Could possibly be a mafia with his little voting switch, voting TehBrian as if testing out the waters and then switching to enderfive... That's a little far fetched though. I get the feeling that roob is a villager.
Aqua - Can you explain yourself? Hammering Ender right at the end like that (and then reacting to the message saying he was a villager with "winner") With really no discussion on your part... I'm not sure if that's more like confused or erroneous mafia play, or sloppy/joking villager play.
TehBrian - Honestly seems most mafia like to me. He's actually a pretty good player in werewolf (granted this game is different) and he seems to have been playing rather sloppy this game.
I wrote this a little while ago just posting it now.
I agree with you. I can’t why a villager would come up with such an
idea, and it would in almost all cases lead to himself getting lynched.
Anyway I find Aqua more suspicious at the moment, especially because his inactivity and seemingly random votes.
It’s very interesting that there was no kills this night. Either the doctor is still alive and saved someone, or the mafia for some reason chose to not kill. The benefits no-killing is that there are now 4 town vs 2 mafias instead of 3 town vs 2 mafias which give us a slightly smaller chance of lynching mafia. This is a common strategy in werewolf, so that kinda makes me believe Roob isn’t godfather as all others alive play/played werewolf.
I’ve been rereading the thread and i found this:
QUOTE="Comp, post: 425867, member: 6904"]
Also remember we do have a goon (cultist) so keep an eye out for any mafia-goon subliminal messages goin on[/QUOTE]
When Comp said i was thinking...
During the night, Mafias can talk to each other except with the traitor. So i was thinking, in order to give the traitor a big wink is by giving lowkey/subliminal messages to each other while still looking innocent?
Example:
I hope i’m not overthinking this, but that’s what i think; Him being a traitor. Brian you can disapprove this theory if it’s inaccurate.
QUOTE="Comp, post: 425867, member: 6904"]
Also remember we do have a goon (cultist) so keep an eye out for any mafia-goon subliminal messages goin on[/QUOTE]
When Comp said i was thinking...
During the night, Mafias can talk to each other except with the traitor. So i was thinking, in order to give the traitor a big wink is by giving lowkey/subliminal messages to each other while still looking innocent?
Example:
Notice Chocofox gave a command to TehBrian while focusing on the subject about Okx so it won’t look sudden/out of subject.
TehBrian was easily persuaded by ChocoFox and followed the order impulsively without thinking - Also he did not change his mind about his vote and stayed the same throughout Day 2.
I hope i’m not overthinking this, but that’s what i think; Him being a traitor. Brian you can disapprove this theory if it’s inaccurate.
When Comp said i was thinking...
During the night, Mafias can talk to each other except with the traitor. So i was thinking, in order to give the traitor a big wink is by giving lowkey/subliminal messages to each other while still looking innocent?
Example:
Notice Chocofox gave a command to TehBrian while focusing on the subject about Okx so it won’t look sudden/out of subject.
TehBrian was easily persuaded by ChocoFox and followed the order impulsively without thinking - Also he did not change his mind about his vote and stayed the same throughout Day 2.
I hope i’m not overthinking this, but that’s what i think; Him being a traitor. Brian you can disapprove this theory if it’s inaccurate.[/QUOTE]
QUOTE IS BROKEN
When Comp said that, i was thinking**
Ignore Above!
(QUOTE IS BROKEN I’M REUPLOADING A BETTER VERSION SO IT’LL MAKE SENSE WITHOUT BEING GLITCHY AND UNORGANIZED)
I was rereading the thread and i found something:
During the night, Mafias can talk to each other except with the traitor. So i was thinking, in order to give the traitor a big wink is by giving lowkey/subliminal messages to each other while still looking innocent?
I hope i’m not overthinking this, but that’s what i think; Him being a traitor. Brian you can disapprove this theory if it’s inaccurate.
( I am so tempted to delete that post but it’s not allowed. Is this how OCD feels like
)
(QUOTE IS BROKEN I’M REUPLOADING A BETTER VERSION SO IT’LL MAKE SENSE WITHOUT BEING GLITCHY AND UNORGANIZED)
I was rereading the thread and i found something:
When Comp said that, i was thinking...
During the night, Mafias can talk to each other except with the traitor. So i was thinking, in order to give the traitor a big wink is by giving lowkey/subliminal messages to each other while still looking innocent?
Notice Chocofox gave a command to TehBrian while focusing on the subject about Okx so it won’t look sudden/out of subject.
TehBrian was easily persuaded by ChocoFox and followed the order impulsively without thinking - Also he did not change his mind about his vote and stayed the same throughout Day 2.
I hope i’m not overthinking this, but that’s what i think; Him being a traitor. Brian you can disapprove this theory if it’s inaccurate.
( I am so tempted to delete that post but it’s not allowed. Is this how OCD feels like
)Actually, I just realized that mafias nightkill also could have been stopped by a bulletproof villager
I think we're at the point in the game where nolynch is near pointless. We mislynch on any day, regardless of the odds, we lose.
I do, however think it may be worth a shot.
I came up with the idea to get some more information because nothing fun was happening and no one was giving any good reads, and plus if I was mafia, why would I even WANT to make conversation? If anything if you're mafia you would want to stay quiet and not be so suspicious.
My goodness gracious! If it wasn't me in the example I would 100% believe you, that sounds like super brilliant scum reading.Ignore Above!
(QUOTE IS BROKEN I’M REUPLOADING A BETTER VERSION SO IT’LL MAKE SENSE WITHOUT BEING GLITCHY AND UNORGANIZED)
I was rereading the thread and i found something:
When Comp said that, i was thinking...
During the night, Mafias can talk to each other except with the traitor. So i was thinking, in order to give the traitor a big wink is by giving lowkey/subliminal messages to each other while still looking innocent?
Notice Chocofox gave a command to TehBrian while focusing on the subject about Okx so it won’t look sudden/out of subject.
TehBrian was easily persuaded by ChocoFox and followed the order impulsively without thinking - Also he did not change his mind about his vote and stayed the same throughout Day 2.
I hope i’m not overthinking this, but that’s what i think; Him being a traitor. Brian you can disapprove this theory if it’s inaccurate.
( I am so tempted to delete that post but it’s not allowed. Is this how OCD feels like
Yes, I've been playing sloppy. I didn't really pay much attention before I did the whole godfather deal but the reason I did that was so I would be more involved, because instead of having to read a bunch of old messages that aren't even relevant and trying to scum read off of that, I could get some new scum reads.
And on top of that, for one of the scum reads, I was right. I said to vote Alisha first, we did vote Alisha first, and surprise surprise, the one I said to go for FIRST was the ONLY mafia, which was Alisha. That makes no sense as a mafia to try to say two people are mafia and then vote for one of them FIRST which WAS THE MAFIA!
I really haven't played anything in favor for the mafia, I've been a bit sloppy, I wasn't paying attention before I did the godfather deal, but I don't think it matters that much, because no one whose mafia would care if I claimed as mafia, they'd see right through it.
However, I do think that the mafia know I'm catching up and I think they tried to kill me last night. Maybe I'm the bulletproof villager? I don't know, it didn't tell me.
Either way, I know I'm a villager. You guys don't know that, but I haven't done literally anything to indicate I am mafia, other than some sloppy gameplay strategies to find out who IS mafia, and then end up being right and KILLING a mafia.
Actually a no-lynch will only lead to the mafias killing the villagers who are the least likely to get lynched anyway. So it doesn’t really help us eliminate one ‘suspect’ as one could think. I have changed my mind. I think we should lynch today.
Regarding that, I went back and checked the vote counts by day ends and especially TehBrian caught my eyes. I found out he:
Day 1 - didn’t vote
Day 2 - voted okx, when it was choco (mafia) against okx (watcher)
Day 3 - voted Alisha, but it is noteworthy that he first had his vote on Rune (cop) then switched to Alisha 2 votes before she was getting lynched.
Day 4 - voted Ender
Actually I had be very suprised if a villager did so many mafia favourable votes. Every time except maybe day 3, which perhaps was to clean himself, he did the most beneficial vote for the mafias. This plus that he did that weird godfather claim and have had some really strange posts make me believe he is mafia.
Regarding that, I went back and checked the vote counts by day ends and especially TehBrian caught my eyes. I found out he:
Day 1 - didn’t vote
Day 2 - voted okx, when it was choco (mafia) against okx (watcher)
Day 3 - voted Alisha, but it is noteworthy that he first had his vote on Rune (cop) then switched to Alisha 2 votes before she was getting lynched.
Day 4 - voted Ender
Actually I had be very suprised if a villager did so many mafia favourable votes. Every time except maybe day 3, which perhaps was to clean himself, he did the most beneficial vote for the mafias. This plus that he did that weird godfather claim and have had some really strange posts make me believe he is mafia.
Basically this yes. So no-lynch may not be such a good idea after all.
- Status