Could you point to when you think I made a quick assumption about a read so I can explain what was going through my head at the time?
I already pointed out examples. If you don't agree that those are the assumptions, then alright.
I don't think I did reconsider him as such after my long post and his posts afterwards, or at least not more than a quick doubt in my mind that I dismissed because TWG being mafia made so much sense, no, and I didn't have much reason to reconsider him in my eyes. Him claiming blocker didn't make me doubt myself since people were posting statistics of how unlikely that claim is and it's not as though it would be surprising to see mafia claim a PR like that either, so nothing really happened to make me go 'oh wait maybe I'm wrong' after that point. I wouldn't say it was a feeling of certainty either, and there were moments where I thought his posts sounded quite townie and I remember saying well done to him for that if he was mafia, but I had reasons to think he was mafia that outweighed those moments and I felt confident enough about it to push for his lynch and nothing happened to make me change my mind.
Fair enough.
unless she was expecting a partner to cc, which didn't happen, and if she was expecting it then I'd think that it was planned, which doesn't seem to be the case.
Fair enough - however it seemed to be it was a deliberate attempt to try to frame and then because it failed she backed off from it unwittingly. I don't know how to argue with this.
I think the fact that I only had a maximum of 3 suspects per day is probably the best argument I've got against that.
Is that not a wide range of suspects though? I wasn't talking about you suspecting like six or seven people, just an area of around 3 people, throwing sufficient shade, and then when the wagon caught on you followed suit.
This quote right here kinda illustrates what I mean:
few other people as kind of background suspects until right at the end when I switched it to TWG
I think I was the first to suspect TWG actually
You and Alisha were both quick to jump on the TWG, first off suspecting him big time and turning it into a huge readfest in Day 0. I got Fantome to give a read on him since I trusted Fantome not to be Mafia. TWG was under huge suspicion on Day 0 and seemed like an easy target to pick on Day 1, especially after Fantome was dead.
What I'm referring to here was before TWG actually revealed himself to be the roleblocker, not after.
I don't remember it going like that but that game was a while ago so you may be right. From memory even after I died people kept ignoring fog until several days later when they eventually lynched him but I don't think that was because of my reads. I don't remember what happened to notty. Even if in that game people did use my legacy reads, in most games I don't see them being used, and I don't put stock in them myself unless I actually agree with it
This is what I'm not okay with. You're not a proven safe by any means. TWG has died and has flipped Town - what was revealed cannot be possibly false but what you are saying right here can be false.
