Why?
And don't you think it would be wiser to try to lynch someone else who not only has a much higher chance of being mafia, but also can have a role which, in contrast to purples (if she is godfather), can harm us the following days and nights.
Timeline of Dichotomous Flowers - Game Complete
- Thread starter Alisha
- Start date
And don't you think it would be wiser to try to lynch someone else who not only has a much higher chance of being mafia, but also can have a role which, in contrast to purples (if she is godfather), can harm us the following days and nights.
With Dess' ability being bounced off of inf, onto to notme, that takes a three target ability down to two- which says "these two players read as town." So with inf no longer included in that report, he and purple no longer need to read as the same alignment, which reopens the possibility that they're a team. (Geez, that's a thought process I've been trying to put into words for two or three days now.)
The first part of your question is rather loaded. It implies that purple has a very low chance of being mafia in the first place, which I disagree with. However, as for lynching someone with a more detrimental ability, yes that would be more beneficial. However, there's no way we can guarantee that, and we need to get all mafia members lynched anyway. The benefit of lynching a detrimental mafia role and the harm of lynching a helpful town role are not even close to equal; we're better off lynching the godfather than a cop, for example.
Added bonuses to lynching purple:
We determine whether inf is more likely to be mafia or town.
We can strengthen or disprove Dess' claim.
How many times do I have to vote purple before she dies??
Vote Purple
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
To add to this, generally the godfather tends to be the one carrying out nightkills so if theyre dead another Mafia would need to sacrifise using their night action in order to do the nightkill (unless a certain trash setup allows Mafia to do both). It will essentially remove one ability from Mafia.
Well, she either has a 1/14 (if godfather exist) and 0 chance (if a godfather doesn't exist) to be mafia. Any other player has a x/14 chance of being mafia where x is the number of mafias. Unless godfather is the only mafia role to exist purple has a way lower chance to being mafia than any unproven player.
Yes, thats correct, but should that be a reason to lynch the, unlikely but at best useless role for the mafias atm.
And the best way to do that by is to lynch the proven players?
Yes and how is that relevant. You are in fact voting for someone who has a higher chance of being PR, such as the cop, than the unproven.
Both of these added bonuses will be figured out anyway if one of Inf, Purple, Notme or Dess dies or for some reason gets their roles revealed, or any investigative role may get something so its almost surely we will get the bonuses tomorrow anyway by doing nothing.
There is also the possibility of a lawyer (chooses a target to show as being innocent on reports) being present, and if that's the case, than it's the most likely case for them to use that ability on Purple. I don't see it as any less likely that she is mafia than anyone else.
As Notty said, lynching the godfather forces the rest of the mafia to give up one of their abilities in order to preform the kill. I fail to see how that's a reason not to lynch them.
Who is proven? No one is proven until the claims that prove them have been verified.
It's relevant because that's what we're talking about? You're saying we shouldn't try to lynch a potential godfather because there are people we have no information about. Is that statement true, yes or no?
The mafia aren't going to just give us these benefits though; they aren't obligated to kill any of these players. If we want them, we're going to have to lynch someone.
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
Also considering dess has been pretty pro his lynch so far, rating posts agree and making no defence for his life it rings pretty suspicious to me.
Especially since inf has also been pushing hard for his lynch.
Especially since inf has also been pushing hard for his lynch.
That role is very rare, and I highly doubt Choco and Alisha would let there be both a Godfather and a lawyer due to balancing issues in the setup so I still think that is at most 1/14 chance.
Ok sorry let me adjust myself. Only useful if the entire mafia team are good PRs and mafias cannot perform two night actions at once, which totally is better than getting any of the other mafia roles which at worst will do the same.
Sorry: 93% proven.
Don't understand what you mean by people we have no information about part, but yes I think we shouldn't lynch an only potential godfather and instead lynch a potential Godfather, a potential Hooker, a potential Mafia role cop, etc.
We'll see.
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
I never said there was no other option except omni. I said I was considering switching to vy or kropp a while ago
I also never said brian wasn't 'that scummy', I just disagreed with you that he was hiding or not making sense. I still think he's pretty scummy but those aren't the reasons why, and at the time I thought omni was more scummy than brian. My feelings have changed a bit since then though, I can't point to a specific reason, they just did.
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Alerts broke for me which is why I've been MIA as far as rating posts agree go, I've done this once? And asfar as making no defense for my life half the time it's God damn near impossible to change inffy's mind once he scum reads somebody so I ultimately stop trying to and instead try to get back to scumhunting
Also please point me to the questions I need to answer, I know Omni is one of them and after rereading the thread I'm still confused. This is because he occasionally puts effort into his posts which makes me think he's town but it is also Omni so he could be Mafia and do this
Godfather, lmao. If I were godfather I would have killed Omni and Aqua, would have been thrown into a corner from how obvious my kills were, and then I'd be dead tonight. I'd be chillin if I were godfather, whomever that person is has had a nice relaxed run this whole time! As for the clock, I think I've said multiple times just in a softer indirect way, that it's not a person but various persons Weak being one of them who were town aligned, but please continue to make it easier for town to keep shoooting its smol army.
If Vy and Molten have abilities, there might be one who is mafia. Another thing that just occured to me, is that perhaps town PRs have the ability to choose who, but only third party win conditions have the ability to choose 'what' and that what could be the color (seems to be going in order but there's a posibility for it to be regardless of color, perhaps alternate conditions/actions in addition to color). So either Vy or Notme could be these and I would strongly hesitate to lynch them, however having them both be town aligned would give town too many roles I think. So I'm going to with the idea that both have 3rd party conditions, Weak and 2 other people being town aligned. Leaves town with 2-3 central roles, and 1 detective role, all of which of course, are at eachother's throats right now while mafia just chills at the sidelines. gg.
If you were mafia you'd have already killed two players by Day One?
You don't think Notme can be town despite having a town investigation result from the same source as your own?
And since you seem oh so convinced that all of the town PRs are trying to get each other lynched, and the mafia aren't doing anything, who do you think that mafia are, and how many of them do you think there are?
And why are you so confident that there are so few town PRs?
I'm leaving to my parent's house for a few hours, I won't be able to respond until I get home.