[GAME OVER] Formula Mafia

[Nottykitten]

oh

Still I think it's good to keep the votes off me untill Unu has claimed, I see no reason to delay his claim till tomorrow. For me especially since I'd rather you guys make a decision having all the cards out in the open.

 

[Mooglie]

Now that Okx has claimed does this change my future prospects in your eyes?

not really?
like youre literally immune to penalties its essentially confirmed that youre scum as much as i would want to believe that youre not
argue for okx's guiltiness go!

and same i want UNU to claim before day end

 

[Nottykitten]

not really?
like youre literally immune to penalties its essentially confirmed that youre scum as much as i would want to believe that youre not
argue for okx's guiltiness go!

What about Hk's obviously scummy vote on me =(

Okx is guilty because having two exactly the same town messenger roles, in addition to Alisha, is very unlikely. Them having a day ability perfectly opens them up to also being able to do the nightkill.

 

[Mooglie]

Okx is guilty because having two exactly the same town messenger roles, in addition to Alisha, is very unlikely. Them having a day ability perfectly opens them up to also being able to do the nightkill.

valid tbh

 

[Ltin]

Votecount
NOT - [3] - STR, DUF, HKC
OKX - [2] - NOT, BOO
With 10 players it takes 6 to lynch and 5 to no lynch.

Spoiler: Running Order

_________GAP
| 1. NOT -
| 2. ALI 8
| 3. MOO 6
| 4. DUF 16
| 5. STR 11
| 6. BOO 17
| 7. OKX 1
| 8. GOO 0
| 9. UNU 2
|10. HKC 2
|11. INF
|12. HIP
|13. MAR
|14. TIM

The deadline is Monday, November 18th at 23:59 GMT

 

[Alisha]

hey im basically a vanilla with a last statement dont throw me in with those nerds

 

[Alisha]

screw it since 2 exact same power roles is dumb;

vote okx

 

[Boooo]

If notty is scum I think alisha might be
Also if moog is scum I don't think notty is and vice versa

 

[Duffie]

If notty is scum I think alisha might be
Also if moog is scum I don't think notty is and vice versa

Just like if Stranger is somehow scum, same with you

But yeah, lots of vice versas here

 

[Duffie]

On my break, time to properly read

 

[Boooo]

I could also see alisha with moog lol

 

[Duffie]

I could also see alisha with moog lol

Sounds like a complicated love triangle.

 

[Alisha]

Sounds like a complicated love triangle.

please play every future mafia game from now on

ily

 

[Alisha]

If notty is scum I think alisha might be
Also if moog is scum I don't think notty is and vice versa

hey you hit agree on my post when i changed my vote GEEZ

 

[Boooo]

please play every future mafia game from now on

ily

I'm jealous

 

[Good Skele]

I expected more to happen.

I don't exactly see why mafia would claim the same role that is already known and was more or less confirmed by another person. Surely, if we lynch them and they flip mafia (without ability to send these messages) then Moog is probably lying too and is scum, but if it goes the other way, then well, mislynches aren't a good thing I must say, whenever it's obvious or not.
Also why is an existence of same two roles with some message ability looks unlikely to you, while 2 RBers doesn't seem like something bothering more than that?
With that being said, Moog as I see it was planned by Stranger, should RB me or Okx, and I agree on that, still I don't fully trust Okx, but first -inactivity doesn't tell me anything, and second - Notty seems like a better lynch to me
Vote Notty

 

[HKCaper]

i dont see inf and okx' role as strong at all, so i could see two town with that role being in the same game. much less could i see two roleblockers in the game, even less so 3. Seeing how stranger is 'confirmed' since i beleive boo, and i trust moog more than i do notty, they seem like the logical choice here.

 

[Nottykitten]

I expected more to happen.

I don't exactly see why mafia would claim the same role that is already known and was more or less confirmed by another person. Surely, if we lynch them and they flip mafia (without ability to send these messages) then Moog is probably lying too and is scum, but if it goes the other way, then well, mislynches aren't a good thing I must say, whenever it's obvious or not.
Also why is an existence of same two roles with some message ability looks unlikely to you, while 2 RBers doesn't seem like something bothering more than that?
With that being said, Moog as I see it was planned by Stranger, should RB me or Okx, and I agree on that, still I don't fully trust Okx, but first -inactivity doesn't tell me anything, and second - Notty seems like a better lynch to me
Vote Notty

Because multiple messengers add no value to the town while multiple roleblockers do. Thats why multiple roleblockers have atleast a chance of existing.

Then again you are likely scum too so you not voting Okx makes kinda sense to me.

 

[Nottykitten]

i dont see inf and okx' role as strong at all, so i could see two town with that role being in the same game. much less could i see two roleblockers in the game, even less so 3. Seeing how stranger is 'confirmed' since i beleive boo, and i trust moog more than i do notty, they seem like the logical choice here.

Disagree there is no reason for town to have two of Infs role, atleast the roleblocker roles are different.

 

[Good Skele]

Because multiple messengers add no value to the town while multiple roleblockers do. Thats why multiple roleblockers have atleast a chance of existing.

Then again you are likely scum too so you not voting Okx makes kinda sense to me.

They do, so yeah that's just a no, friend

 

[Nottykitten]

They do, so yeah that's just a no, friend

What is this value you see them adding?

 

[Good Skele]

What is this value you see them adding?

Spreading information that may be useful to town, and confirming themselves to others. And no I don't believe that there would a mafia role with literally same ability + some another wacky thing, that's just dumb

 

[Nottykitten]

Spreading information that may be useful to town, and confirming themselves to others. And no I don't believe that there would a mafia role with literally same ability + some another wacky thing, that's just dumb

Why cant they just spread information in the game thread like all other players? The message is day only which is only really useful for a Mafia who wants to secretly talk to another Mafia about who to vote or something. There is no point in 2 town roles being able to talk behind the towns backs.

 

[Good Skele]

Why cant they just spread information in the game thread like all other players? The message is day only which is only really useful for a Mafia who wants to secretly talk to another Mafia about who to vote or something. There is no point in 2 town roles being able to talk behind the towns backs.

There is. There might be information that from the point of the sender of message should not be known by scum

 

[HKCaper]

What is this value you see them adding?

im not sure what hip's role was about exactly, but these roles seem to have some purpose in that sense. to me they could just be vanilla like roles, put in just to not have vanilla townies and to work nicely with hip's role.