[GAME OVER] Formula Mafia

[Nottykitten]

There is. There might be information that from the point of the sender of message should not be known by scum

Which is rare, and that is what inf was for. Two of them is useless.

im not sure what hip's role was about exactly, but these roles seem to have some purpose in that sense. to me they could just be vanilla like roles, put in just to not have vanilla townies and to work nicely with hip's role.

I think thats just ignoring the obvious and simple explanation that Ltin added one scum one town messager.

 

[Boooo]

? sipsip

 

[HKCaper]

Which is rare, and that is what inf was for. Two of them is useless.


I think thats just ignoring the obvious and simple explanation that Ltin added one scum one town messager.

could well be, but id feel much more comfortable going for you first, who, I atleast, find more likely to be scum.

 

[Good Skele]

Which is rare, and that is what inf was for. Two of them is useless.

You don't talk about chances here, this is mafia, and literally everything happens. First of all - Inffy is dead, second of all - more townies are not useless at all

 

[Boooo]

Skele/moog/alisha(?)
Or skele/moog
OR
notty/no idea lol

 

[Nottykitten]

You don't talk about chances here, this is mafia, and literally everything happens. First of all - Inffy is dead, second of all - more townies are not useless at all

You do talk about chances, such as the chance Ltin chose to make another messenger town instead of another roleblocker

 

[Boooo]

HKCaper if you trust more people on the okx vote then maybe you should vote him instead since you mentioned trusting me, I really can't see it being notty and even if we do Lynch her it doesn't give us much info

Good Skele make my life a lil easier and just vote okx, I don't think it's notty

 

[HKCaper]

HKCaper if you trust more people on the okx vote then maybe you should vote him instead since you mentioned trusting me, I really can't see it being notty and even if we do Lynch her it doesn't give us much info

Good Skele make my life a lil easier and just vote okx, I don't think it's notty

Its just you and notty tho. Yes i trust you, but because of your claim. By that logic i still trust more on the side of the notty vote, in addition to myself.

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

im not sure what hip's role was about exactly, but these roles seem to have some purpose in that sense. to me they could just be vanilla like roles, put in just to not have vanilla townies and to work nicely with hip's role.

That's an interesting possibility, but it does make sense. The ability to send (but not receive) messages to other players could work as a vanilla type role, seeing as it doesn't allow very much sharing of game relevant information. Plus with two innkeepers in play it makes sense that this would give these roles some use if they coordinate with the innkeepers, though again to a very limited degree.

You do talk about chances, such as the chance Ltin chose to make another messenger town instead of another roleblocker

What are the chances of having 3 townies with roleblocking abilities in play though?

make my life a lil easier and just vote okx, I don't think it's notty

What argument do you have against lynching Notty beyond vibes?

To me it feels like people are going after Okx more because he's an easy target than anything else. Also, if he was actually scum I feel like he wouldnt claim to have the same role as a dead townie.

 

[Nottykitten]

What are the chances of having 3 townies with roleblocking abilities in play though?

Low. But in my actual opinion, higher than the chances we have 2 town day messengers.

Also Okx probably just claimed his actual role since he was too inactive to be able to come up with anything else.

 

[Nottykitten]

Would you consider going for Okx, Stranger? If anything with Boos investigation and me proving my roleblock ability atleast youll have more info to lynch between me/Oog tomorrow.

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

Would you consider going for Okx, Stranger? If anything with Boos investigation and me proving my roleblock ability atleast youll have more info to lynch between me/Oog tomorrow.

Not now, because I don't really have a good read on either of them. Id much rather have Boooo investigate one of Unu/Okx tonight since we have less info on them. At least between you and Oog I have plenty to base my reads on.

 

[Unusual_Dood]

What is the current votecount? Also did okx claim his fole before Infected died?

 

[Unusual_Dood]

Role*

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

What is the current votecount? Also did okx claim his fole before Infected died?

4 votes to lynch Notty, 3 votes to lynch Okx I think

No, okx didn't claim until after Inffy died

Also claim please. Or else.

 

[Unusual_Dood]

Vote Okx

 

[HKCaper]

What is the current votecount? Also did okx claim his fole before Infected died?

He got confirmed by moog tho, which i guess is only useful if you trust moog.

 

[Unusual_Dood]

He got confirmed by moog tho, which i guess is only useful if you trust moog.

Didnt moog claim blocker?

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

Didnt moog claim blocker?

Yes, but Notty has a one-shot roleblocking ability as well.

 

[HKCaper]

Didnt moog claim blocker?

As in, okx send a message to moog which was confirmed (like happend today).

 

[Nottykitten]

Didnt moog claim blocker?

Okx sent a message to Oog and Oog claimed to have gotten it today.

 

[Nottykitten]

Unu voting for Okx instead of me gives me an instant townread btw

 

[Nottykitten]

Since the vote is 4-4 atm, I'm gonna ask the adorable Mooglie for their final decision on me vs Okx. Im assuming ill be lynched anyways because Okx+Hk can vote me out, but I hope someone else (Stranger) might change their mind.

 

[HKCaper]

Its just you and notty tho. Yes i trust you, but because of your claim. By that logic i still trust more on the side of the notty vote, in addition to myself.

I was wrong, alisha is also voting okx. I guess that evens it out a bit more. Id rlly like moog to place a vote then.

 

[Boooo]

That's an interesting possibility, but it does make sense. The ability to send (but not receive) messages to other players could work as a vanilla type role, seeing as it doesn't allow very much sharing of game relevant information. Plus with two innkeepers in play it makes sense that this would give these roles some use if they coordinate with the innkeepers, though again to a very limited degree.


What are the chances of having 3 townies with roleblocking abilities in play though?


What argument do you have against lynching Notty beyond vibes?

To me it feels like people are going after Okx more because he's an easy target than anything else. Also, if he was actually scum I feel like he wouldnt claim to have the same role as a dead townie.

I think the reasons for wanting to lynch notty are baseless so I have no reason not sus her therefore no reason to wanna lynch her, + my vibes of course.
I don't think there's two of the exact same roles in one setup that are both town aligned, it's just not how these set ups usually go. I rather wait to lynch notty or moog as I'm quite sure if one of them is scum the other isn't, therefore if I investigate moog tonight and he comes back as town then I'd want the lynch notty then. If he comes back as scum, easy lynch. Personally I'd rather wait but if it comes down to it I'll switch for the sake of hammering

Didnt moog claim blocker?

Claim or we'll switch to you, literally everyone else had claimed, there's no reason for you not to