Mafia: Saints & Sinners - GAME OVER MAFIA WIN

[Timdood3]

thoughts on a massclaim + are you poor sinner tom?

A massclaim sounds fine at this point with so many claimed sinners.
And yes I'm poor don't bully me.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Also I'm going to ammend myself saying that Alisha and Fog could both be scum, I don't think they both are. I think at most one of them is.

why?

After betas insta claim on the prefix I'm pretty sure he's town same with Tim.

im confused

you think maf were given the sinner role claim but not what the role name was? why??

After betas insta claim on the prefix I'm pretty sure he's town same with Tim.

If there's only one more unclaimed sinner it makes lynching a lot eaiser.

Timdood3 thoughts on a massclaim

realistically are you going to want to lynch anyone other than fog/alisha today even if everyone claims, unless cop has a report on someone? whats the point of massclaiming when we already have leads

if you think maf need to take all sinners souls then the remaining hidden sinners are your only hope of us winning, why are you wanting them to out???

 

[BetaPanda]

more possible names:
Poor Sinner [Name]
Saint [Name]
[Name]the Devil
[Name] the voodoo ??

 

[Aqua]

realistically are you going to want to lynch anyone other than fog/alisha today even if everyone claims, unless cop has a report on someone? whats the point of massclaiming when we already have leads

I'm not 100% sure on either, tho very confident on fog

a massclaim would give me that confidence if I am right and would also allow any town PRs a better selection for their night actions.

if you think maf need to take all sinners souls then the remaining hidden sinners are your only hope of us winning, why are you wanting them to out???

I mean at this point, assuming they know 3 and have to find 1 more they're probably going to win in 4/3 turns anyway so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I'm not 100% sure on either, tho very confident on fog

a massclaim would give me that confidence if I am right and would also allow any town PRs a better selection for their night actions.

how would a massclaim change your confidence on fog/alisha other than if a cop has a report on one of them

and yeah it'd give PRs a bit of a better pool but it could also easily lead to them getting blocked/killed in which case it wouldn't be useful anyways

I mean at this point, assuming they know 3 and have to find 1 more they're probably going to win in 4/3 turns anyway so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

again this is a bizarre assumption to make

even if they only need 1 more there's 0 reason to out them anyway when that could be our only chance at winning

 

[Aqua]

how would a massclaim change your confidence on fog/alisha other than if a cop has a report on one of them

and yeah it'd give PRs a bit of a better pool but it could also easily lead to them getting blocked/killed in which case it wouldn't be useful anyways


again this is a bizarre assumption to make

even if they only need 1 more there's 0 reason to out them anyway when that could be our only chance at winning

In 3-4 days time the mafia will very likely know who the final sinner is either thru them claiming or by mafia means.

PRs getting killed/blocked isn't the worst issue if we know the 3 mafia are all in a pool of 4-5 players

 

[Infected_alien8_]

In 3-4 days time the mafia will very likely know who the final sinner is either thru them claiming or by mafia means.

not necessarily?

PRs getting killed/blocked isn't the worst issue if we know the 3 mafia are all in a pool of 4-5 players

there could easily be like 4 town sinners + 3 maf sinner claims, making the pool 3/7, 2/6 if we lynch scum today which i think is 99% likely

that's not worth throwing away the hidden sinner(s) when they could easily stay hidden, or losing cop n1 when we could get 2 more reports before they need to out themselves yet

 

[Alisha]

im also not in favor of a massclaim unless somebody knows why there was a nokill

 

[Infected_alien8_]

im also not in favor of a massclaim unless somebody knows why there was a nokill

why will you be in favour of one if someone knows why there was a no kill

or do you mean you want that person to out and noone else

 

[Aqua]

there could easily be like 4 town sinners + 3 maf sinner claims, making the pool 3/7, 2/6 if we lynch scum today which i think is 99% likely

Sure but I'm 100% confident Tim and Beta are town so that gives us a 3/5

not necessarily?

not necessarily, but statistically likely.

Do not go down this road with me again brother

 

[Alisha]

why will you be in favour of one if someone knows why there was a no kill

or do you mean you want that person to out and noone else

i want that person to out if they know why (and are not a doctor)

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Sure but I'm 100% confident Tim and Beta are town so that gives us a 3/5

why?? if maf were given the sinner role i am 99% sure they will have been told what the role name is because the whole point of giving it to them would be to let them have a decent claim, and the role name would be part of that

 

[Aqua]

1. Alisha
2. HKCaper
3. sessybessy
4. Infected_alien8_
5. Aqua
6. Timdood3
7. MarsKid
8. Fog
9. BetaPanda
10. Unusual_Dood
11. Good Skele
12. Vatumok

Howdy boys and girls it's time for everybody's favourite game:

SHOULD WE MASSCLAIM?

Vote now in the comments below (merch in bio)

 

[Infected_alien8_]

no

 

[Aqua]

why?? if maf were given the sinner role i am 99% sure they will have been told what the role name is because the whole point of giving it to them would be to let them have a decent claim, and the role name would be part of that

The exact nomenclature of the name? Sinner definitely Poor Sinner maybe, tho it could easily be confused with flavour text but the x sinner x formula? They won't have been outright told nah

 

[Alisha]

no

 

[Fog]

Alisha Fog Timdood3 I guess you guys should all claim ur role names

I am Poor Sinner Dupree

 

[Infected_alien8_]

The exact nomenclature of the name? Sinner definitely Poor Sinner maybe, tho it could easily be confused with flavour text but the x sinner x formula? They won't have been outright told nah

'Poor Sinner <name>' is all theyd have needed to be told

alisha gives mafia rolename hints, stranger learnt hosting with alisha as her co-host, in fact pretty sure she gave the last team the rolename structure too though alisha can confirm that

 

[Fog]

Also I feel that a mass claim this early without any SOLID evidence is more detrimental to the town

 

[Aqua]

'Poor Sinner <name>' is all theyd have needed to be told

alisha gives mafia rolename hints, stranger learnt hosting with alisha as her co-host, in fact pretty sure she gave the last team the rolename structure too though alisha can confirm that

I doubt it would be that blatant my dude and eitherway my trust of Tim and Beta come from their reactions. Betas reaction to my post seemed pretty innocent and Tim's reaction to beta was also genuine + everything Tim has said since the Alisha train has been very town imo

 

[Aqua]

Also I feel that a mass claim this early without any SOLID evidence is more detrimental to the town

what

Solid evidence of what?

 

[Alisha]

alisha gives mafia rolename hints, stranger learnt hosting with alisha as her co-host, in fact pretty sure she gave the last team the rolename structure too though alisha can confirm that

im having nothing to do with how this game was made and im still getting meta'd GOD

 

[Aqua]

Also Infected_alien8_ two mafia have agreed with ur anti massclaim sentiment, ur on the wrong side of history bud

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I doubt it would be that blatant my dude

what do you mean 'blatant'

you literally said earlier maf would be given the claim to help them blend in just like when hosts give players the actual role PM of the 'common town role' so maf can claim it properly

has your alignment just switched or something im baffled

 

[Alisha]

'Poor Sinner <name>' is all theyd have needed to be told

alisha gives mafia rolename hints, stranger learnt hosting with alisha as her co-host, in fact pretty sure she gave the last team the rolename structure too though alisha can confirm that

also idk i feel like it goes against the spirit of the current game to give this info out or not