Good Skele
Member
We did mention it though. Nothing much was said, only a question about my reads that I uh, missed.
Mafia: Saints & Sinners - GAME OVER MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter Stranger from Myst Island
- Start date
- Status
Mostly because of there being no kill n1, and I'm not sure how that could be explained unless HK saved Aqua. Unless there is of course some hidden mechanic like people need to deal with devil for maf to get a kill or something but that seems inbalanced. Even in that case then I feel like HK would have to be in on it or Aqua was very lucky. That said I still consider it as a valid theory that Aqua or Aqua + HK are both evil but I'd like to wait what happens this night first.
From the very beginning I didn't rly like his actions. Actively pushing for sinners d0 even though they are the VT role of this setup while he can check them. Next pushing hard for a massclaim IMO too early to probably get rid of saints. To me it felt off at least, especially that part where he was trying to lynch sinners super early on. His claim also seems slightly hard to believe, seems weird he can just clear people like that plus the idea looked similar to Inffy's claim before that.
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
I alluded to my claim before him, but since I had so much to support my claim from day 0 and 1, I wanted inf and vat to claim first to prevent them from gaining info about the saint roles.
Which may have worked on inf as his name is the only name that isn't that of a real biblical saint.
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
if youre town, then you know deals are anti-town, because you prevent them
if my role undoes deals, why wouldnt that be a town role
plus if you really want tim to keep his ability in spite of the unforeseen consequences he can always deal again tonight and see if it gets accepted, though i advise against that
in that case tim would be able to say that tomorrow
like ive said already, the message tim gets is that the deal is undone, why would the devil keep the power if the deal is no more
twg contributes regardless of alignment, inactivity is irrelevant to that for him
my issue with it is 1) your defence was based on completely untrue statements such as how everyone was pushing fog, even though they werent, only like 3 of us were at that time, 2) your switch to thinking me/sessy are town was so random and conveniently timed right after the fog lynch was gaining traction and you never even gave a reason for why you think we're town, 3) just because me/sessy were town that doesnt mean we're correct about whos mafia, so us being town shouldnt have changed your mind on fog if you truly thought he was being pushed by everyone and that was the reason you scumread him, since that part hadnt changed just because your read of me/sessy had
mafia defend mislynches because they think it makes them look good all the time, so saying you defended fog means nothing to me
1) the action is only inherrently town if it's not a devil cover ive been over this
2) no dont try to deflect onto the setup again, theres a difference between misleading and not giving all the information
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
1) but it isnt a devil cover because that doesnt make sense, because:
2) but if stranger tells tim his deal is undone then that would be misleading him if the deal isnt undone. if its undone then why would devil keep their side of the deal
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
you think im scum yet are voting the person im voting because you 'give up'?
i swear if maf have poor sinners and im just ignoring your scummy behaviour for nothing and you end up winning from it
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
2) if you want to believe that, despite tim being told the deal isnt a thing anymore, the devil still keeps their power, then fine, but to me thats extremely unlikely/misleading
- Status