this isn't me saying im "willing to vote them", it's me saying that if the report is true then that's what i'll end up doing.
i didn't say you were scum for sussing me \o/. i said it feels like youre literally making up reasons because everything you said was incorrect/a reach
ive only got this specific feeling once before, and it was in that game where it was me vs sob soooooo
"He's been voting the easy lynch all game"
>implies i was voting hip, and calls themself the easy lynch. one vote on you doesn't make you an easy lynch
"althought they both claimed to have no reasoning at the time"
incorrect
"i feel like he just bandwagoned off of mis actually trying to scum hunt and voted me because i had traction."
i didn't do anything differently than mis, and there's no reason to call mis there scum hunting and me not. (you have changed to mild sus on mis for that, yeah) again, one vote doesn't give you traction
"then later he claims to actually sus me but doesn't provide any reasoning."
incorrect
"Also he said he was willing to switch to a hip vote who coincidentally was also the most popular vote at the time, he just generally seems to be looking for an easy lynch this game instead of going by his own reads like he does as town"
ignores the fact that hip had a report on them, which was the main reason i was going to vote them (the other being overdefending you). second part is a little fair. i had actually wanted to look into you before mis voted and was just going to watch you but when mis voted i figured i might as well do it that way as well.
so no, basically none of these points are valid.
it's true these are much better
but sure, i could have a reason to vote you from d0 or night. ive gotten good vibes from shorter things than that d0 before
what i said did echo and i had thought it before mis voted but you wouldn't be able to tell that, no
and youre still overplaying the thing with hip. i was willing to vote hip at the time if notty kept pushing but you act like like i should ignore one of hip/notty lying even if that happened
nothing lol. but notty feels normal now
saying 'I'll probably vote them' means youre willing to, its literally the same thing
I'm not making anything up I just have a lot of vibes from you because of all of this stuff and I'm having trouble conveying my points
you said you would probably vote hip- pretty much the same thing too
point is, as town you go out and find your own sus' and then vote them when this game you've just been voting with other people and not really scum hunting as much as you normally would imo
I'm was referring to when you voted earlier, I thought you agreed with mis when they said there was no reasoning?
you didnt do anything different from mis, that's the thing, you copied them to look like you were scum hunting and I do sus mis, just not as much as you atm. One vote is traction, just not a lot, when I say 'traction' I mean you only seem to be voting people who have already been voted
I already realized that the point about you not explaining your sus on me was wrong, I just forgot that you did (probably because it echoes mis)
a claim isnt a reason to automatically vote someone imo, people lie about claims a lot and in this case it didnt really make sense for hip to lie at all imo
no I think thyere pretty valid still
theres literally no reason for me to believe you both thought the same thing and I think its very very unlikely that you did
i didnt say ignore them I said I didnt find it very townie of you to 'probably vote hip' and I dont think you've been trying because of both the vote on me and then later with hip, its not just the hip thing, its mainly a pattern I'm seeing here.
Other people voted you, I dont really get why you haven't addressed them yet nor the same way youre addressing me
Vote boo Because, I'm not voting poke and I'm not really against a vote against boo. I'm not against sacrificing a lost cause as mafia, it's way easier to just let them die than support them and have everyone taken down. Anyone from past games with me would know that so you can use this against me if you wish but know I'm usually more subtle with my support.
wdym by take everyone down?
Ender - I'm getting a 3p read from him largely because of his weird font antics. His scumhunting seems pretty legit so I don't think he's mafia, but his weird antics are telling me he's either not town or just fucking with us.
Moog - I've had my eye on Mooglie ever since they suggested piling onto hip to put pressure on them. I got the feeling that that was a coordinated effort with Notty to push a mislynch, and I really havent seen anything else that's convinced me otherwise.
Ltin - Town/neutral read. What little he has contributed has been helpful, but also I haven't seen enough from him to say I'm fairly confident that he's town.
HKCaper - Neutral read. Im getting the feeling he's falling back on lurking which always makes me scum read him Tbh. I'd lij
Notty - Im solidly convinced she's scum. The whole lying about getting a report of hip visiting the machine and then later admitting to lying sounds too much like a ploy to achieve some strange objective. Further more, I don't buy her claim that she did so "to start conversation" for a second. There are much better ways to start conversation (e.g. asking questions, posting reads or annoying Sir Mars Bar).
hip - I'm getting a pretty solid town read from him. Admittedly part of this might be compassion for him being bullied by Notty, but even reading his posts I really see someone talking from a townie perspective.
Inffy - Im generally getting the impression that he's a townie now that he's actually started scumhunting and tunelling people like I'd expect. I'm not 100% convinced he's town yet, but probably about 80% convinced.
Mulb - Needs to speak up more
Boooo - Im getting the feeling she and Poke are townies who really just can't see eye to eye on anything. They havent said anything that makes me think either of them are scum, their arguments are pretty logical and I dont get the impression that they know anything beyond what a townie would know.
Mischief - Strong scum Or 3p feeling from Mis. Beyond the fact that she's Been kinda lurk-y and hasnt provided much explaination for her votes unless pressed, her rationale doesnt really make sense from a townie perspective. Like even her recent post (#529) feels very much like she's apathetic and generally disconnected from the outcome of the game.
Sir Mars Bar - Bad first impressions aside, I'm pretty sure he's town. The fact that he said hes pretty solidly set on lynching myself or Pokes tells me that he's not worried about what his opinion is going to look like later if the group opinion changes. Plus I can follow his logic for scumreading me, even if I dont necessarily agree with it.
Pokes - See Boooo
Jace - He's way too confused about whats going on to be mafia Tbh, so likely town
Comp - Speak up dude
ive never seen you give so much input in mafia before, its a litter deterring
