I’ve won the game as Town, maf and third party. I play the game how I enjoy playing the game and when there’s only like 3 people contributing its more fun to try and cause a discussion. It’s not my fault you have your head so far up your own ass and such a high opinion of how you play the game that you can’t appreciate the beauty of the game <3
Mafia: Saints & Sinners - GAME OVER MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter Stranger from Myst Island
- Start date
- Status
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
people weren't online end of day yesterday so we ended up nling, alisha almost got lynched though. today fog seems to be the most agreed upon suspect
tim, beta, fog and alisha all claimed to be a sinner, able to make deals with the devil during the day. the deal gives them an ability, but has an unforeseen consequence
all of them claim they didnt make a deal yesterday except fog claims he tried to get an ability to send mail to another player but that his deal got denied
unu claims to be someone who makes a nightchat with another player, visited fog, fog confirms. fog and unu are argueing over whether unu said he would reveal he was in a chat with fog today or not (fog says he said that and thus is suspicious for not outing it until fog kinda forced him to, unu said he didnt say that in the chat and so fog is throwing shade at him based on a lie, fog seemed to admit that unu was right on this, but now is saying he did again)
we have about a day until the deadline
this is like an episode of a bad sitcom I stg
one of the messiest mafia games I’ve played and it’s absolutely brilliant
The primary reason for the mafia as a whole knowing the identity of the devil is so they don't accidentally kill him.
Though thinking about it, another solution to that problem is to make the devil bulletproof....
Wait a minute...It just occurred to me that that's a possible explanation as to why there was no kill.
Good Skele
Member
Yeah, no. I just finished reading the pages.
I've already explained the alisha thing.
Making a deal with the devil could be good in some scenarios, though, as it appears the devil can reject a deal. If the devil is a player and can choose to accept it, it means that's making deals will most likely never be in our favour.
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
what about on day 0 though when we didn't know if the devil could reject a deal, do you think it would've been a good idea to make a deal back then or not? do you think a sinner should have made a deal day 0, stepping in their shoes in that moment?
would we know a devil could reject a deal if I hadn’t atrempted
It’s just annoying that playing the games it’s always the active players that get lynched cause they contribute
IMO not because it was clear there are multiple sinners and you can't expect what the others would do. If multiple people make a deal it could've been very bad. Ideally one sinner would've tried it out to see if anything happens but it'd be impossible to coordinate that.
Good Skele
Member
Can anyone please remind when's the deadline?
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Good Skele
Member
Thank you Englishman
hk, vat, alisha, tim, beta, skele, unu, fog, aqua, inf, mars/twg, sessy
okay, I'm not the best at read lists so I'll try.
Inf: Neutral/Town, I agree with many things that he says and disagree with other things. Many things he says seem to be in favour of town but Inf can be a sneaky mafia player.
Aqua: Neutral too, I'm leaning more towards town however. Many things said in favour of scumhunting and town winning but mafia could have ulterior motives.
Vat: Potential scum, avoiding questions asked, giving the vaguest answers possible and being inactive in general (life gets in the way though so I understand.) (slightly answered some questions whilst I was typing this)
Alisha: Town, idk her claim just seems really genuine now that I've seen others try to claim roles.
Fog: Scum or maybe a third party, the whole night messaging thing is a big disaster and they seem kinda panicked at being in the spotlight. Grasping at straws when saying the reason they claimed was because they were in the spotlight on Day 0 when they were barely mentioned as far as I'm aware. Third party because of the "My role doesn't benefit town or mafia".
Unu: Scum/potential 3p, same with the night messaging thing. I believe Unu more since Fog has just dug themselves a massive grave at this point.
Beta: Neutral but leaning towards a townread. I've not really heard much from Beta today but the whole last minute claim thing just rubbed me the wrong way. I know I'm being judgy based on one thing but it just didn't settle right for me.
Tim: Town but maybe leaning towards neutral. I've not really read much from him and I don't remember any particularly scummy thing happening other than the Day 0 claims where everyone kinda believed him lmao.
HK: Neutral, I feel like I'm neutral reading so many people. Tbh I don't have anything for or HK being town or mafia, I can't remember anything that stuck out to me as definite scum or definite town
Sessy: absolute angel, best player here, so useful to town, we love her, not a sheep at all, queen <3
TWG/Mars: Really quiet, I guess inactivity can be down to life but I don't have any strong feelings for them either.
Skele: Another neutral read I know they're active so potentially a lurking mafia type, from what I've seen they're just kinda going with the flow which I do too. No strong feelings either way.
I think that's everyone :x
Ignore this, was me trying to make sure I got everyone lmao
- Status