Mafia Season 5
- Thread starter The Road to Ruin
- Start date
- Status
Sploorky
Member
Ok, I'll say it again.
@players voting no lynch....why? The game's been open for a day, we've had literally no discussion besides some back and forth stuff. What's happened so far: Endersteve is lyncher(UN CC'D) and defiant is cop(UN CC'D). If defiant isn't the real cop, then the real cop should reveal himself and have the doctor protect him. If that doesn't happen, assume defiant is cop.
If he's fake claiming, he's a bad guy. Why wouldn't you two try to vote for him or give some argument then
? And yes, we need more time. The way we get this time isn't no lynching.
). I already have suspicions on people, it's how they act, who they vote for. Noone seems completely innocent, everyone has some evidence against them. How is the point of the game to ignore this evidence and pick a person at random to die? Discussion go.
@players voting no lynch....why? The game's been open for a day, we've had literally no discussion besides some back and forth stuff. What's happened so far: Endersteve is lyncher(UN CC'D) and defiant is cop(UN CC'D). If defiant isn't the real cop, then the real cop should reveal himself and have the doctor protect him. If that doesn't happen, assume defiant is cop.
Wouldn't the most suspicious people try to lay low?defiant_blob said:
Odds are against it, but perhaps.Old_Man_Mak63 said:
Then why wouldn't you vote for him?Nottykitten said:
Again as before ^nitasu987 said:
If he's fake claiming, he's a bad guy. Why wouldn't you two try to vote for him or give some argument then
? And yes, we need more time. The way we get this time isn't no lynching. Nobody's going to have a slip up where they say they are mafia(unless it's on purposeballoon98 said:
). I already have suspicions on people, it's how they act, who they vote for. Noone seems completely innocent, everyone has some evidence against them. How is the point of the game to ignore this evidence and pick a person at random to die? Discussion go.
zezmi
The noob himself
I am sorry I have not posted in this thread, I have been very sick, I am now getting over it so I will be active from now on.
I agree with Sploorky, I don't wan't a no-lynch, it seens that no lynches tend to help the Mafia. I also think that Defiant is not the detective, seeing as he came straight out and said it and that is never a good move as you would be an instant target unless you are the Mafia, he is also pushing everyone into a no-lynch.
I agree with Sploorky, I don't wan't a no-lynch, it seens that no lynches tend to help the Mafia. I also think that Defiant is not the detective, seeing as he came straight out and said it and that is never a good move as you would be an instant target unless you are the Mafia, he is also pushing everyone into a no-lynch.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Sploorky
Because I might be wrong. Even tought I think he is not the cop, theres always a chance he is.
I know, I did say I didnt think he was cop at all. But I am having a small thought that he may be. So I prefer a no-lynch. Because I dont feel like lynching someone that might be cop on day 1.
[Inb4 almost all mafia's before this]
So yeah, Thats why I dont vote for him. Not that big of an argument but its good enough to convince myself to vote no-lynch.
Because I might be wrong. Even tought I think he is not the cop, theres always a chance he is.
I know, I did say I didnt think he was cop at all. But I am having a small thought that he may be. So I prefer a no-lynch. Because I dont feel like lynching someone that might be cop on day 1.
[Inb4 almost all mafia's before this]
So yeah, Thats why I dont vote for him. Not that big of an argument but its good enough to convince myself to vote no-lynch.
zezmi
The noob himself
No lynch gets us nowhere, it helps the Mafia because they get to kill another person tonight and therefore get the number of Mafia and Town people closer. And look at his actions, he is getting the Doctor to save him, he is trying to pursuade everyone not to lynch. There is a small chance that he is the Detective.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Sploor seems the least suspicious to me at this moment, although he can just be fooling me. I do know that I can be easily manipulated...
Defiant however, the way how he threw in the fact that he's the cop, just like that... I'm not sure why, but this feels wrong. However, if nobody else comes forward and counterclaims, he is most likely the cop, so he's off the hook for now as well. At this point my vote would be nitasu because he wanted the detective to reveal themself so early in the game, but there's practically no evidence supporting the claim that he's Mafia either.
In conclusion, I have no idea what to vote, but I wouldn't want a no-lynch either, kraby's post convinced me in that.
Defiant however, the way how he threw in the fact that he's the cop, just like that... I'm not sure why, but this feels wrong. However, if nobody else comes forward and counterclaims, he is most likely the cop, so he's off the hook for now as well. At this point my vote would be nitasu because he wanted the detective to reveal themself so early in the game, but there's practically no evidence supporting the claim that he's Mafia either.
In conclusion, I have no idea what to vote, but I wouldn't want a no-lynch either, kraby's post convinced me in that.
zezmi
The noob himself
I too trust Sploorky.
All the evidence leads to Defiant faking it, even if no one claims cop I do not think he is to be trusted, I think it would be a bad idea for the cop to come forward, it is better for the cop to stay hidden and then try to tell us when they find a Mafia member after investigating people for a few nights. I think that we should lynch Defiant because, what ulterior motive would he have for lying about being the cop? He would get protection from the Doctor, and be a Mafia member in a great hiding place, and maybe others.
While there's the chance that Defiant is the cop, there's just as great a chance that he isn't. There are two ways to look at him right now.
As a mafia: He's been trying to get people to no-lynch, something that I don't think is a horrible idea (on the first day, that is) since normally, there isn't evidence. However, there wasn't any need to claim as the cop this early on if you don't have any evidence. Now, if you have two members of the mafia, then go ahead and claim! But if you have no evidence on anyone, then it's better for the real detective to stay low. That's why I don't think there has been a counter claim. To prevent the doctor from choosing the wrong person to save, as well as to make sure the mafia don't know the identity of the real cop.
As a cop: He's been the only one to claim so far. That's all I really see is goin' for him from the perspective that says he's the cop.
But then again, the town isn't exactly the best at not lynching the cop. Hell, Alpha threw in a little joke when I killed Jk last season that it was one of the first times the town DIDN'T kill the cops. So our history with that is the main reason why I'm hesitant to lynch Defiant.
As a mafia: He's been trying to get people to no-lynch, something that I don't think is a horrible idea (on the first day, that is) since normally, there isn't evidence. However, there wasn't any need to claim as the cop this early on if you don't have any evidence. Now, if you have two members of the mafia, then go ahead and claim! But if you have no evidence on anyone, then it's better for the real detective to stay low. That's why I don't think there has been a counter claim. To prevent the doctor from choosing the wrong person to save, as well as to make sure the mafia don't know the identity of the real cop.
As a cop: He's been the only one to claim so far. That's all I really see is goin' for him from the perspective that says he's the cop.
But then again, the town isn't exactly the best at not lynching the cop. Hell, Alpha threw in a little joke when I killed Jk last season that it was one of the first times the town DIDN'T kill the cops. So our history with that is the main reason why I'm hesitant to lynch Defiant.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
You forget that he can be a civilian as well. Trying to get us trought the first day without any dumb mistakes.
[Like lynching the real cop]
Defiant is very experienced, and this seems like a trick he would pull to help the town by faking the claim of the cop. So that perhaps he will be targeted at night, and not any other power roles. In which case I just revealed his plan [muwhahaha].
And all of you seems to forget the serial killer and the viligante. You say that if we do a No-Lynch the mafia would gain. But do they really... While at night the mafia can kill 1 person, the serial killer and viligante can kill one too. Since the viligante and serial killer are against the mafia, the mafia has a chance to loose 2 of their members at night. Making us gain too. [If done correctly].
Think about that when you say the mafia will gain. [I know that we can loose 3 members too, but just saying]
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
By abstaining it takes 1 less vote to have the majority of votes, right?
In which case, as ive been explained, was 10. Which is now 9.
So we have 9 votes on no-lynch and 1 vote on abstain. Meaning it is a no-lynch?
Or did I fail math again?
[I will be happy if we pass day 1 without any un-needed sacrifises.]
Defiant_Blob
(￣^￣)ゞ
Are we seriously debating whether to lynch me?
Okay, let's get some baseless and silly reasoning out of the way.
"He just threw it out there"
What else should I have done? Want me to make a big picture saying I AM THE COP? This is a silly argument that I don't know why it's being considered.
"He's pushing for no lynch."
Okay, first off, I just recently voted for no lynch. I have not been pushing or talking about it at all. Stop.
"All the evidence leads to me faking it"
THERE IS NO EVIDENCE WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT.
Also, if you want some actual logic, think about what would be happening if I /was/ mafia. Who would be supporting me? My mafia partners. And so far the whole town and probably the mafia as well seems set on lynching me soon, even though I've advocated cop claiming day one since game one.
Anyways I retract my no lynch because this is a bunch of tomfoolery at the moment.
Either way, I'd take a look into those tunneling me, as they are probable mafia.
Okay, let's get some baseless and silly reasoning out of the way.
"He just threw it out there"
What else should I have done? Want me to make a big picture saying I AM THE COP? This is a silly argument that I don't know why it's being considered.
"He's pushing for no lynch."
Okay, first off, I just recently voted for no lynch. I have not been pushing or talking about it at all. Stop.
"All the evidence leads to me faking it"
THERE IS NO EVIDENCE WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT.
Also, if you want some actual logic, think about what would be happening if I /was/ mafia. Who would be supporting me? My mafia partners. And so far the whole town and probably the mafia as well seems set on lynching me soon, even though I've advocated cop claiming day one since game one.
Anyways I retract my no lynch because this is a bunch of tomfoolery at the moment.
Either way, I'd take a look into those tunneling me, as they are probable mafia.
Defiant_Blob
(￣^￣)ゞ
And I'm back to no lynch. While we do have a chance to hit mafia, lynching will most likely hit town. As well, we don't know how many mafia and town members there are, and we might not have a mislynch.
There is no information present that could bring us to lynch someone with little doubt, and lynching a random or me would generally be a bad idea.
The doctor can choose whether they want to risk protecting me or not, it's their call.
There is no information present that could bring us to lynch someone with little doubt, and lynching a random or me would generally be a bad idea.
The doctor can choose whether they want to risk protecting me or not, it's their call.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
As everyone argued in the halls, the agreement came... lynching was simply to risky at this time. Everyone backed away slowly to their respective habitat blocks and closed their doors. As night loomed several residents of Zerbous prepared for the night by gearing up for their duties.
Night 2
Night 2
zezmi
The noob himself
So this is what we're looking at so far:
7 civilians - 1 dead - 6 unknown
2 elite citizens - both unknown
1 detective - Defiant_blob (open to doubt)
1 doctor - unknown
1 vigilante - unknown
1 mayor - unknown
2 mafia - both unknown
1 contact - unknown
1 godfather - unknown
1 fanboy - Jolteon (confirmed, dead)
1 lyncher - Endersteve5 (confirmed?)
1 serial killer - unknown
7 civilians - 1 dead - 6 unknown
2 elite citizens - both unknown
1 detective - Defiant_blob (open to doubt)
1 doctor - unknown
1 vigilante - unknown
1 mayor - unknown
2 mafia - both unknown
1 contact - unknown
1 godfather - unknown
1 fanboy - Jolteon (confirmed, dead)
1 lyncher - Endersteve5 (confirmed?)
1 serial killer - unknown
As night fell on Zerbous several people volunteered to try and tunnel out of the city. About half the town was doing this at one point or another. As HarmakPaul and Defiant walked down the hall someone watched from behind a corner, digging into their pocket they said “I’ve always wanted to try this” and tossed a roller skate down the hall. HarmakPaul was so busy arguing about the current cake to Redstone exchange rate that he never saw the roller skate as he stepped clear over it and saw defiant blob slip and fall.
He landed near superstein while he was squeezing a stress ball trying to hold in his anger. “Oh my god!” Defiant… you need help!” As he hauled defiant onto his back he dragged him to the infirmary. As he neared the hallway out of nowhere a knife flew through the shadows and struck him in the foot, the screaming attracted the doctor, who began to work on both of them into the infirmary.
At the dig site people chipped diamond pickaxes against bedrock without any signs of progress. Zezmi Old_man_Oak_63 and vati180 struggled to haul TNT against the blockage while notty kitten wired red stone. As three haulers finished they jumped behind a blast shield of sand and brick, while they plugged their ears in the dark waiting for the red stone signal to ignite the TNT, a pickaxe slammed into old man oak’s head. The other two looked about in the darkness for the assailant, while old man oak stirred, “thank goodness for safety helmets, that was almost a terrible accident”.
As the AI began to log in at the infirmary terminal the doctor began to brief it on his two patients,
“Well what happened?”
“Well where to begin, first there’s Superstein. He took a throwing knife to the foot… poor bastard never had a chance, died before I could even get him inside *shudders* not a pretty way to go.”
“Doctor, how would a knife to the foot kill so quickly?”
"I'm running some tests and I have some theories, but we should know after the autopsy"
“And what about defiant is he dead as well?”
“He’s alive for now but I fear it’s very serious he…. Dropped his feet. Still I did manage to stabilize him by rubbing aloe Vera on his neck, if he makes it through the night than he should be okay”
The sun rose over the dangerous town while everyone congregated at town hall…
Day 2
Superstein the civilian was killed
Old_man_Oak_63 was attacked
Defiant_blob was attacked
He landed near superstein while he was squeezing a stress ball trying to hold in his anger. “Oh my god!” Defiant… you need help!” As he hauled defiant onto his back he dragged him to the infirmary. As he neared the hallway out of nowhere a knife flew through the shadows and struck him in the foot, the screaming attracted the doctor, who began to work on both of them into the infirmary.
At the dig site people chipped diamond pickaxes against bedrock without any signs of progress. Zezmi Old_man_Oak_63 and vati180 struggled to haul TNT against the blockage while notty kitten wired red stone. As three haulers finished they jumped behind a blast shield of sand and brick, while they plugged their ears in the dark waiting for the red stone signal to ignite the TNT, a pickaxe slammed into old man oak’s head. The other two looked about in the darkness for the assailant, while old man oak stirred, “thank goodness for safety helmets, that was almost a terrible accident”.
As the AI began to log in at the infirmary terminal the doctor began to brief it on his two patients,
“Well what happened?”
“Well where to begin, first there’s Superstein. He took a throwing knife to the foot… poor bastard never had a chance, died before I could even get him inside *shudders* not a pretty way to go.”
“Doctor, how would a knife to the foot kill so quickly?”
"I'm running some tests and I have some theories, but we should know after the autopsy"
“And what about defiant is he dead as well?”
“He’s alive for now but I fear it’s very serious he…. Dropped his feet. Still I did manage to stabilize him by rubbing aloe Vera on his neck, if he makes it through the night than he should be okay”
The sun rose over the dangerous town while everyone congregated at town hall…
Day 2
Superstein the civilian was killed
Old_man_Oak_63 was attacked
Defiant_blob was attacked
- Status