MEDIEVAL MAFIA: INTRUSION [DAY 8]
- Thread starter MarsKid
- Start date
- Status
I'm voting fruit ninja due to the rampant inactivity and some suspiciousness of arachadonic.
xXxFruitNinjaxXx
I'd like to see how you respond to this suspiciousness,
also please look over the recent activity and respond to these questions if you could.
who do you find most suspicious?
why do you think the death count is so low each night?
who else do you find suspicious?
why do you think both sploorky and alpha were killed already?
why do you think no power roles have "outed" themselves yet with a confirmed mafia?
what do you think the pattern is behind the night deaths?
xXxFruitNinjaxXx
I'd like to see how you respond to this suspiciousness,
also please look over the recent activity and respond to these questions if you could.
who do you find most suspicious?
why do you think the death count is so low each night?
who else do you find suspicious?
why do you think both sploorky and alpha were killed already?
why do you think no power roles have "outed" themselves yet with a confirmed mafia?
what do you think the pattern is behind the night deaths?
who do you find most suspicious?
I'm mostly trying to work out this Road/Ansoro vs Hunter business.
why do you think the death count is so low each night?
Either the roleblocker has worked out the identity of the commaner/SK, or the vigilante is holding back due to the likelyhood of hitting a blue.
who else do you find suspicious?
Nothing too major on anyone else yet, focusing on the task at hand.
why do you think both sploorky and alpha were killed already?
Experience, mostly.
why do you think no power roles have "outed" themselves yet with a confirmed mafia?
It's too risky, especially as it will be easy at this stage for the mafia to counterclaim and/or kill the cop.
what do you think the pattern is behind the night deaths?
I think it's mostly been eliminating the more experienced players.
I'm mostly trying to work out this Road/Ansoro vs Hunter business.
why do you think the death count is so low each night?
Either the roleblocker has worked out the identity of the commaner/SK, or the vigilante is holding back due to the likelyhood of hitting a blue.
who else do you find suspicious?
Nothing too major on anyone else yet, focusing on the task at hand.
why do you think both sploorky and alpha were killed already?
Experience, mostly.
why do you think no power roles have "outed" themselves yet with a confirmed mafia?
It's too risky, especially as it will be easy at this stage for the mafia to counterclaim and/or kill the cop.
what do you think the pattern is behind the night deaths?
I think it's mostly been eliminating the more experienced players.
Now for some more relevant questions of my own:
Who is the most suspicious to you, out of Road, Ansoro and Hunter?
Paraphrased, why?
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
Innocent?
Who is the most suspicious to you, out of Road, Ansoro and Hunter?
Paraphrased, why?
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
Innocent?
To answer my own questions~
Who is the most suspicious to you, out of Road, Ansoro and Hunter?
Road, followed by Ansoro (Hunter isn't far off)
Paraphrased, why?
Road had been openly pushing for bandwagons and random lynches, using flawed logic and a certain Ansoro to back his reasoning.
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
I think it'll mean Ansoro is probably mafia, and Hunter is probably innocent
Innocent?
Ansoro may or may not be mafia, same with Hunter
Who is the most suspicious to you, out of Road, Ansoro and Hunter?
Road, followed by Ansoro (Hunter isn't far off)
Paraphrased, why?
Road had been openly pushing for bandwagons and random lynches, using flawed logic and a certain Ansoro to back his reasoning.
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
I think it'll mean Ansoro is probably mafia, and Hunter is probably innocent
Innocent?
Ansoro may or may not be mafia, same with Hunter
Ansoro2112
Hottie
Help me here understand this Jivvi. Because I'm honestly not really getting the reason why I seem suspicious to you. There have been reasons for Hunter. Some reasons for Road. But what's my reason? For voting for Hunter? What makes me different from all the other ones who voted for Hunter? Or is it because you think I'm "defending" Road in some kind of way? Since you said this "Road had been openly pushing for bandwagons and random lynches, using flawed logic and a certain Ansoro to back his reasoning."
Agreeing with someone doesn't quite mean I'm defending him. Let me try to get this clear. I was agreeing about Hunter being mafia. I was never trying to protect Road's back. I'm not babysitting Road here.
Well, i didn't say you were defending him, I said you were covering up the holes in his reasoning. And besides, intentionally or not, you've been defending him, if only by pushing on Hunter. Another point is that as soon as Road made his vague susicion statement on Hunter, you jumped right in and started pushing on him.
Ansoro2112
Hottie
I wasn't covering up his roles in his reasoning. He had his own reasons to say why Hunter's guilty and I had mine. They're not the same. I also mentioned, before all this Hunter thing happened, that I was suspicious of him. You can look that up. I said that in the questions.
Oh damn. So Nottykitten, Ooglie101, HypeBurst, grimmjowforever, storm886, Natsu, std1997, Watermelon and cooliorules are intentionally or not defending him since they voted for him too right? I guess we are all defending Road after all.
It just doesn't make sense Jivvi. I believe is just the fact that I speak my mind way too much that you're grabbing this as a chance to lay suspicion on me. And how? You're trying to make it seem like Road and I are teaming up in some way. So if later on Road turns out to be guilty you'll blame it all on me. Easy move right? Yeah.
I kind of blatantly stated that that wasn't what I was getting at, but okay.
These thing of Hunter's are pretty accurate
(The middle one isn't as relevant, but is part of the same image as the top one)
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Who is the most suspicious to you, out of Road, Ansoro and Hunter?
Road seemed the most suspicious from my pov, but ansoro seems to have similar motives. Based on the votes, I seem to be the most suspicious (or simply bandwagoned). I believe this is due to my voting for Ltin yesterday and the subsequent vote counts posted by me, which may have caused me to appear too eager to lynch him.
Paraphrased, why?
Pushing for seemingly random lynches (the only one with minor reasoning behind it at the time Nottykitten ) while using flawed logic in his own arguments.
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
Ansoro'd seem to be the next to be lynched. While Nottycat originally suggested the vote on me, I believe she's innocent. We'll see if others think the same.
Innocent?
I'll probably end up dead overnight or lynched the next day.
Third party?
If road is the hangman or sk, that'll help us out by reducing the amount of players killed per night. I'm not sure who'd be killed overnight in this situation.
Road seemed the most suspicious from my pov, but ansoro seems to have similar motives. Based on the votes, I seem to be the most suspicious (or simply bandwagoned). I believe this is due to my voting for Ltin yesterday and the subsequent vote counts posted by me, which may have caused me to appear too eager to lynch him.
Paraphrased, why?
Pushing for seemingly random lynches (the only one with minor reasoning behind it at the time Nottykitten ) while using flawed logic in his own arguments.
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
Ansoro'd seem to be the next to be lynched. While Nottycat originally suggested the vote on me, I believe she's innocent. We'll see if others think the same.
Innocent?
I'll probably end up dead overnight or lynched the next day.
Third party?
If road is the hangman or sk, that'll help us out by reducing the amount of players killed per night. I'm not sure who'd be killed overnight in this situation.
GmK
International Man Of Cake
Who is the most suspicious to you, out of Road, Ansoro and Hunter?
Still Road, but I do get a vibe from Ansoro, who seems to try the 'Why would what I do even look suspicious' defensive route, one that is often picked by scum to discredit the person deeming them suspicious.
Paraphrased, why?
As stated before, I deem hunter to be suspicious, but Road just came out of nowhere and said "he is scum, we must take the opportunity and lynch NOW". Only later some reasoning was given when it was contested, but in my opinion that move was more scummy than the things hunter did.
Now, I do understand the arguments road has brought forward about how unlikely it is that he is scum, and I personally want to believe them, but at this point I won't be swayed.
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
I'd be glad that my suspicion did turn out correct, and it would make ansoro, who at the beginning 'blindly' followed road without stating reasons of his own, seem more suspicious.
Innocent?
I'd look like a total fool and would be a prime lynch suspect...
Third party?
That would explain quite a few things!
Still Road, but I do get a vibe from Ansoro, who seems to try the 'Why would what I do even look suspicious' defensive route, one that is often picked by scum to discredit the person deeming them suspicious.
Paraphrased, why?
As stated before, I deem hunter to be suspicious, but Road just came out of nowhere and said "he is scum, we must take the opportunity and lynch NOW". Only later some reasoning was given when it was contested, but in my opinion that move was more scummy than the things hunter did.
Now, I do understand the arguments road has brought forward about how unlikely it is that he is scum, and I personally want to believe them, but at this point I won't be swayed.
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
I'd be glad that my suspicion did turn out correct, and it would make ansoro, who at the beginning 'blindly' followed road without stating reasons of his own, seem more suspicious.
Innocent?
I'd look like a total fool and would be a prime lynch suspect...
Third party?
That would explain quite a few things!
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
Who is the most suspicious to you, out of Road, Ansoro and Hunter?
Hunter, to be honest. Hence the vote.
Paraphrased, why?
I strongly believe that one of them is mafia (or 3rd party), and I honestly have been more swayed by Road's argument, and feel the evidence he brought up in it against Road is of better quality (poor wording, sorry. End of term, too tired to do stuff) then what Hunter's is.
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
Wootwoot, victory!! Well.. mini victory!
Innocent?
Wellshit. And along with many others, I will most likely look suspicious. Dammit.
Third Party?
That would.... that would make a lot of sense... and a lot of the happenings would be.. explained.
Hunter, to be honest. Hence the vote.
Paraphrased, why?
I strongly believe that one of them is mafia (or 3rd party), and I honestly have been more swayed by Road's argument, and feel the evidence he brought up in it against Road is of better quality (poor wording, sorry. End of term, too tired to do stuff) then what Hunter's is.
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
Wootwoot, victory!! Well.. mini victory!
Innocent?
Wellshit. And along with many others, I will most likely look suspicious. Dammit.
Third Party?
That would.... that would make a lot of sense... and a lot of the happenings would be.. explained.
Da Jinks
Political Nerd
Who is the most suspicious to you, out of Road, Ansoro and Hunter?
Road, I feel the way he's pushing on Hunter is suspicious and he gave little reasoning when he started the push. Plus, don't see how Hunter is all that suspicious myself.
Paraphrased, why?
Well I did that all above...
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
If road is guilty then I'd say ansoro will be in the red seat.
Innocent?
Then I honestly see me, GmK and Hunter in the red seat.
Road, I feel the way he's pushing on Hunter is suspicious and he gave little reasoning when he started the push. Plus, don't see how Hunter is all that suspicious myself.
Paraphrased, why?
Well I did that all above...
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
If road is guilty then I'd say ansoro will be in the red seat.
Innocent?
Then I honestly see me, GmK and Hunter in the red seat.
HypeBurst
Just Fabulous
Who is the most suspicious to you, out of Road, Ansoro and Hunter?
I believe that Hunter is guilty but to be completely honest this day is taking way too long and I just want some progress kthx
Paraphrased, why?
wait wut is this asking me to do
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
I would put "trust" into Road and Ansoro. I would be very suspicious of MyUser above all, they may have all voted for Road but he was the one who backed out when he noticed that more votes were going Hunter's way, as to seem like he wasn't on Hunter's side.
Innocent?
Well fuck, Lynch the shit outta me.
I believe that Hunter is guilty but to be completely honest this day is taking way too long and I just want some progress kthx
Paraphrased, why?
wait wut is this asking me to do
If your foremost suspicion is lynched, what do you think that it will mean if they're:
Guilty?
I would put "trust" into Road and Ansoro. I would be very suspicious of MyUser above all, they may have all voted for Road but he was the one who backed out when he noticed that more votes were going Hunter's way, as to seem like he wasn't on Hunter's side.
Innocent?
Well fuck, Lynch the shit outta me.
- Status