A problem with my idea looking at your most recent post would be that Ansoro voted for Nottykitten which could mean that Nottykitten may be innocent or just another ruse by the mafia to feign his inocence. This last day really messed with any more pattern gathering. Though we could say that Ooglie101 is still in the mafia group due to Grimmjowforever voting for myusername22. Maybe during day 3, the group remained flustered not knowing who to mass lynch and could have been trying to signal each other to attempt a myusername22 vote, but unable to grab each mafia member's attention.
I've been suspicious of Myuser since Day 0 and I did actually provide pretty good reasoning for my vote which was overlooked by everyone but Myuser and Ansoro who both disagreed with my claim, I'll put it in a spoiler below
Excuse me? Let's look back at Page 27 when the whole Road and Ansoro voting Hunter thing happens (bold things are the important parts):
This is the 9th post on the page (check it if you wanttt) and now let us look at the 15th post...
Appears you're saying one thing now but another earlier. Like I said, I've been suspicious of you since Day 0 and I did say in one of the question-answering posts that I wouldn't let go of my hunch on you and then minorly on Jivvi (and the Pim thing was wrong because I read the wrong name in a post). Since my gut and head led me to vote Hunter yesterday and it was right, I have to follow them here too:
You know I was just going to point out those four on this vote and the the two days before also.
Guess who voted for Nitasu987 on Day 0? Ooglie101, Ansoro2112, Hunter27a1, Hypeburst Ltin on Day 1? Ooglie101, Ansoro2112, Hunter27a1, HypeBurst, Grimmjowforever Hunter27a1 on Day 2? Ooglie101, Ansoro2112, Hypeburst, Grimmjowforever
Seems very suspicious, but that could be me just putting on the tin foil hat and calling conspiracy. Glad I wasn't the only other one.
Though we could also say that Nottykitten could be part mafia and calling the shots in this whole "Mafia sacrificing Hunter" idea. Nottykitten was the first person to vote against Hunter and has been acting strangely the entire game. Maybe he got lucky? Or maybe he is a mafia member and has been attempting to fly under the radar the entire time boosting the credibility of his members by sacrificing Hunter.
Let me pick 2 names out of the lynching hat for all these days... what about Notty and Coolio? Let's see..
Day 0: Both vote Nitasu
Day 1: Both vote Ltin
Day 2: Both vote Hunter
Day 3: Coolio doesn't vote so both don't vote.
Yeah, I think that is just you calling conspiracy x3
Oh and one more thing.
To a much lesser extent: F.O.S. on Ooglie. Why? Well. look at this.
I have a small F.O.S on ansoro, and grim was mafia. I also have a F.O.S. on hype.
The only bit of evidence I have on ooglie is that I have an F.O.S. on ansoro, and I think they may have planned and all voted for hunter. As they saw no chance of saving him, and it's hard to defend a mafia member out of that situation because if they do get lynched, and you tried to defend them, then guess who else the town is going for.
Don't think too much of this F.O.S. because it is very small was little to no evidence.
Also myusername22 . I've thought about that, but I don't know yet.
I want to wait for some more discussion before I make my vote.
Firstly, the whole "they planned to vote Hunter since they saw no way in saving him" kinda doesn't make sense. I presume that like in the Doomed Cruise where some roles got chats (like me, the passenger or the mafia, cult, etc) got it at night. In the previous day there was nothing to make people really suspicious on Hunter at first glance but then Road spotted something and then people looked at it themselves and agreed. Secondly if we were mafia at the final vote count
Hunter27a1 (Brawler) has been lynched.
-Hunter27a1 = 10(Nottykitten, the road to ruin, ansoro2112, Ooglie101, HypeBurst, grimmjowforever, storm886, Natsu, std1997, Watermelon1388, cooliorules,) (L-3)
-the road to ruin = 6(GmK, 77_is_the_best, Jivvi, Hunter27a1, DaJinks, myusername22) (L-7)
It would have made sense, if we were all mafia, to put all our votes on Road since then the numbers would have turned from 10 to 6 to 6 to 10.
Now that I have talked about that... I kind of agree with Fruit's suspicion on Hype and Grim being Mafia buddies but not really Ansoro. Before I delve deeper into that I need to look at a previous Mafia game where I believe Grim was mafia since I think he did something similar.
Last night before i made that post saying I thought i was onto something I tried to think about what the mafia would do if the "conspiracy" were true and we were right. I ended up concluding that the mafia would probably try to deny everything outright (if people think their a group the towns chances go up massively)
however a town player should be looking at all possible outcomes, one of which would be they were simply accidently thrown in there and it's possible the others could be mafia. if ooglie were a town player I don't think he'd speak for the town and deny everything I think he would have spoken for himself and at least acknowledged the possibility that the others could have been a mafia group. so tell me this, WHY IS OOGLIE DEFENDING EVERYONE AND SPEAKING FOR THEM?
I wasn't going to suspect ooglie but I had a feeling this was something the mafia would do before ooglie even did it. I'm going to
this is very true. you did fos them. however you didn't actually include any of the Fos's in any of your speculations about possible plannings or possibilities of the conspiracy. instead you outright denied the conspiracy itself then added your FoS's at the end, this only tells me that either you suspect them or you could maybe possibly there could be a small chance you are town, either way i'm not any less convinced you are mafia. Though tbh i might've jumped to conclusions a bit voting you was a bit silly when there are bigger fish to fry.
Ooglie101 I'd like to here your response to this, otherwise I will vote for you again.
unvote
like I said I've got bigger fish to fry and speaking of bigger fish
you've stuck out to me this entire game. You've done a numerous things I've found suspicious and I find your behaviors to be mostly in control of the situation but just pretending to be clueless so people don't lynch you. This feels like a more extreme of what grimmjow was doing before he was killed, ontop of everything else I've already said so I'm going to
where did you guys go? maybe you all simultaneously went to holiday vacation But it's making you all look scummy and sickens me a bit, please come back and post here I want to know what you guys all think, if you don't have any thoughts Just pile onto someone elses thoughts! I'm tempted to try to vote you all out if this doesn't pick up
MarsKid I don't think you should end the game early but perhaps if you just keep it moving it won't have ever stopped completely! I think we're a bit past the point where a deadline should've already set could you please put one in? greatly appreciated!
also really please stop worrying about your job as host, you're doing fantastic with it, i know it's stressful but I can tell you that at least some of us are loving it so far.
And this is an example of bandwagoning and lynching without reason and even your own reason. Lazy townie? Possibly. Mafia? Possibly. I'm not willing to take any chances and this day is awfully boring (and you've been slightly inactive) so...
Forgot a bit more reasoning:
The game's been moving slow (and yes, I haven't been posting). We should get the game moving, first. Also, Prizyms is an experienced Mafia player. I don't think he'd jump to lynch without knowing what he's doing. If Ooglie turns out to be an important power role, then we can kill Prizyms tomorrow. Outside of this little debacle, there's just some suspicions and votes being tossed around. We can look at them afterwards. If we just agree on Ooglie for one day, we can get the next day moving.
Also, just to note, if you look at the time it was posted (same minute), I was actually typing it up, so it was more or less *meant* to be included in my first post, not a respond to that lynch or anything
Forgot a bit more reasoning:
The game's been moving slow (and yes, I haven't been posting). We should get the game moving, first. Also, Prizyms is an experienced Mafia player. I don't think he'd jump to lynch without knowing what he's doing.If Ooglie turns out to be an important power role, then we can kill Prizyms tomorrow. Outside of this little debacle, there's just some suspicions and votes being tossed around. We can look at them afterwards. If we just agree on Ooglie for one day, we can get the next day moving.
Point 1: Simply think for yourself, not much else to say here.
Point 2 and 3: This suddenly hit me and I have more reasoning for my vote on Mario. I'm town and in this scenario Priz is also town. With starting a bandwagon on me I get lynched and get turned up as town then the next day Priz is auto-lynched and turns up, in this scenario, as town. This means there would be 2 lynches of towns in these days and then quite a few kills at night, not to mention possible inactive deaths. For the mafia this is a perfectly good way to get a ton of people killed without bringing suspicion on yourself.
And more on Point 3, I've been one of the few fairly active players so far and, like people are suggesting, it would be smarter to lynch the more inactive people who can easily be mafia hiding in the shadows since well, there are a ton of shadows to hide in.
screw logic! screw reasoning I say we just lynch someone, the people who are here are worrying about reasoning so much their letting the mafia win! guys come on stop freaking being afraid to mis-lynch and just do something!
I'm going to vote Ooglie101 again since there seem to be more votes on him! vote Ooglie101
Natsu Dude vote someone already, same for you Da Jinks
MarsKid some of us are still trying to play and enjoy the game, could we please get a vote count? :D
As much as I would love continuing, like this it will probabily just be a guess and see what happens game. And even though I wont mind it, I don't think alot of others would like to continue it that way =S. My vote on Ansoro stays though.
screw logic! screw reasoning I say we just lynch someone, the people who are here are worrying about reasoning so much their letting the mafia win! guys come on stop freaking being afraid to mis-lynch and just do something!
I'm going to vote Ooglie101 again since there seem to be more votes on him! vote Ooglie101
Natsu Dude vote someone already, same for you Da Jinks
MarsKid some of us are still trying to play and enjoy the game, could we please get a vote count? :D
MarsKid, what you going to do? I say we kill off all the in actives and get the game moving. NO, you know what this game is too far in the grave. Let's kill it, and start a new game with LESS people, whoever idea was to have a 30 people game was not smart.
Anyways YOU need to make a decision if you want this game to SURVIVE because just sitting doing nothing is killing this game more! YOU ARE IN CHARGE so do something, so we can start playing or signing up for a new game. MAKE A DECISION!!!
MarsKid, what you going to do? I say we kill off all the in actives and get the game moving. NO, you know what this game is too far in the grave. Let's kill it, and start a new game with LESS people, whoever idea was to have a 30 people game was not smart.
Tell that to gmk xD he hosted an amazing game with 30 people and I don't remember there being a single replacement. Were just hitting a ton of bad luck due to a few factors ,
a) the holiday season is messing with peoples schedules.
B) there was another game going on when this one started
C) we may have tried to jam people in at the beginning rather than just starting the game.
D)the mafia is probably killing off all the actives
You can see there are at least a few semi-regularly active people here but nobody is entirely sure what to do, why not just set a deadline and see if we can't get something to happen? Then if nothing works simply end it.
Also for the next game I don't think we need too many less people maybe just cut it back to 20-25
in the past a lot of people played 20 player games and there still wouldn't be enough slots for everyone
To me it feels like over reacting a bit to see us switch to tiny 10-15 player games .
