OH LOOK! here comes the new guy with a server idea...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Friendy

SMP Overlord & Events Manager
Donor
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,529
Reaction score
1,403
First part is false, second part is true. The reason being that "mature and respectable users that can handle such a position" are what we require our staff to be. I'm really not sure why you'd think those things wouldn't be requirements for a staff position.
I never said they wouldn't, Also; Look at how much Zombie staff there is, 50+ Including Trusted.
 

CloudBryan9

Your Local Time Traveler
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
474
Reaction score
598
Razinao's post answers this question quite well. And I would hate to see the current servers change so drastically.
I agree.
If this would be on say lava, there would be people who want to build and seek shelter rather than running a course.
If it was on zombie we would be getting runner maps that would be somewhat linear or one way.
And if it was on tnt... well, I don't see it working with the gameplay of tnt.

In my opinion, this idea would reach its maximum potential if it was its own server. Rather than being an add-on to one of our existing servers.
 

Pick Yer Poison

is a kid now, is a squid now
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
616
Reaction score
1,731
I never said they wouldn't, Also; Look at how much Zombie staff there is, 50+ Including Trusted.
If I have to explain why your original choice of phrasing implies you do not think being a "mature and respectable [user who] can handle such a position" is not a requirement for staff, then I am not even going to bother arguing this point, because there is no possible way I will be able to explain to you why I am right.

And if you are going with the "well, I didn't say exactly that" excuse, then you have already lost the argument. Implications are generally more important than what is directly stated, because they are harder to keep a lid on.
 

Friendy

SMP Overlord & Events Manager
Donor
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,529
Reaction score
1,403
If I have to explain why your original choice of phrasing implies you do not think being a "mature and respectable [user who] can handle such a position" is not a requirement for staff, then I am not even going to bother arguing this point, because there is no possible way I will be able to explain to you why I am right.

And if you are going with the "well, I didn't say exactly that" excuse, then you have already lost the argument. Implications are generally more important than what is directly stated, because they are harder to keep a lid on.
I don't even know what you're talking about, All I said was Blocktopia Itself is not lacking staff (Other than TNT/Lava lacking a bit), I was simply stating that the servers need more mature and respectable staff and not ones that like to argue with users - Not stating who does so, And not everyone is like that.
 

Ahiya

Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2011
Messages
63
Reaction score
37
Like many others, I really like this idea. A big factor about this however is time. Lots of work is going to have to be put into this. I would really like this to be an add-on on Lava, even though it won't reach it's full potential if it were its own server. If it was put on Lava, specific maps can be built so that people can't build a shelter or stuff and would have to push on. Once again, great idea, I would like to get good ideas like this more often :D!
 

HarmakAnna

Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2011
Messages
739
Reaction score
944
Like many others, I really like this idea. A big factor about this however is time. Lots of work is going to have to be put into this. I would really like this to be an add-on on Lava, even though it won't reach it's full potential if it were its own server. If it was put on Lava, specific maps can be built so that people can't build a shelter or stuff and would have to push on. Once again, great idea, I would like to get good ideas like this more often :D!
Though, as mentioned before, it wouldn't work on Lava, since some people just wanna build. I was thinking that if it wasn't too much trouble, some of the current staff could voluntarily staff that server (if created) until enough new staff are chosen for the server. Though, the maps need to be more than just jumpcourses of adminium. For example, maybe some op_blocks? This has to be the best server suggestion I have ever seen.
 

CloudBryan9

Your Local Time Traveler
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
474
Reaction score
598
Though, the maps need to be more than just jumpcourses of adminium. For example, maybe some op_blocks? This has to be the best server suggestion I have ever seen.
The jump courses could be op_blocks, adminium, or even have the perbuild op-ref, to prevent building or breaking of blocks. (If they try to break/glitch through the blocks, we can warn/kick/ect... for abusing a flaw or glitch. Just like in zombie)
 

CloudBryan9

Your Local Time Traveler
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
474
Reaction score
598
Not to mention Maps would be easier and faster to make since we would mainly have to make jumpcourses instead of worrying too much of the scenery since people are timing their jumps not worrying about if the area around them is cool, right?
Of course there will be just plain adminium jumpcourses. But why not invest in some great back ground scenery or landscapes, and themes. After all this is Blocktopia, which in my opinion equals quality.
 

balloon98

The balloon that never pops
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
825
Reaction score
559
Of course there will be just plain adminium jumpcourses. But why not invest in some great back ground scenery or landscapes, and themes. After all this is Blocktopia, which in my opinion equals quality.
That is kinda what I meant since we CAN have background scenery but it doesn't have to be played on so you don't have to worry about the scenery being bad to play on
 

catmss24

Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2011
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
What if there is a course for each person, though the amount of ppl allowed would be lower than other servers. The spawn would be very wide. Each person would get their own course, well, they'd all be the same, just narrow. Then, not everyone is trying to jump on a same block. There could be points too. For 1st 2nd and 3rd. And one of the rules, kickable, would be only one player per course. So you do have so person pushing you and making it hard to play. Just my idea from this.
 

DarthLego5679

That n00b.
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
832
Reaction score
1,338
Just out of curiosity, is this idea truly being considered by the developers and the HA's or is it going to be like "its a nice idea, but probably won't happen"?
Alright, here's my impressions.

I like the idea. Really. I do. It does sound like it would be fun to play.

Here's the problem. Actually, there's a couple. I'll start with the one that's unavoidable: I can't see us funneling time, money, and staff into this to make it work, and expect a decent payoff. There are already elements of this in both the Zombie and the TNT servers, mostly the former. A lot of the Minecraft parkour/racing as described here can be seen happening spontaneously in the Zombie server, and is often encouraged or even enforced by the map itself.

Furthermore, there's another big problem with this: a race between players on different paths might be nice, but what happens when it takes several minutes just to get past the first jump, due to everyone pushing each other and penning themselves in? This is Minecraft, and players have mass; if two people try and cross the same obstacle at the same time, someone's not gonna make it. Worse, the decision of who makes it is decided by sheer luck more often than skill, and the #1 way to make a gamer angry is to make them lose (or die, in some games) due to forces beyond their control that can strike at any time. It's possible this could be eliminated with a plugin or something of the sort, but the first point still stands tall.

So: good idea and good presentation, but I don't see this happening. Thanks for actually taking the time to think this idea out and make sure it hasn't already been formally presented before posting! :)
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,629
Reaction score
3,021
...Great idea, actually. Why not get an MCForge server on one's computer and have us start? It won't be 24/7, or be officially Blocktopian, but it must be a good start. I'd make my own off of this, but I don't have the ability to make it connectable. Any servers available? ;)

(This wouldn't cost any money at all to set up.)
 

HadesHunter

Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
83
Reaction score
21
So.. Just to sum this all up;

- Good race server idea, it's origianl, not seen often, and it has good potential
- Problems include; Time, Money, vaguely leaning towards a staff problem, would not be compatible with TNT/Lava/Zombies if attempts to induce this idea into them were made, and my guess is a bandwidth problem (Just my guess, I don't know if this would be a problem. Feel free to correct.)

On par with Time, it could be an every-so-often event thing, or a so-and-so hour every day/week/weekend thing. On par with staff, I could definitely help out with that. I'd love to be a staff member for a race server like this.

Imo, it should definitely be tested. I like it.

Edit: Any final rulings on this idea?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top