SCP - Secure, Contain, Mafia [GAME OVER]
- Thread starter Fiestaguy
- Start date
- Status
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Yes, exactly. It was a mislynch. A lynch that you were pushing for the most.
I know others were pushing too, but atleast they gave reasonings[however bad they were]. But reasonings nontheless.
My plan here was to get you to answer why you lynched Caff. But obviously you don't have any reasoning or you wouldnt be avoiding the question every time.
But sigh, I'm gonna give up on you. I wanted you to answer the question to see wether your reasoning was Mafia-sided or not. But I kind of got an answer anyways because of how anti-town you reacted.
honestly Ltin was pushing harder than I was toward the end
wasn't trying to dodge the question, just didn't like the aggressiveness of the accusation
first reason for voting caff was the guilty myuser had on her
which was reason enough
then dess came up and was like "HEY IMMA COP WITH NO CONFLICTING EVIDENCE BUT I WAS BLOCKED"
which somehow led to caff being innocent
i was the one to suggest the miller thing as a possibility
there was no visible downside to lynching caff, as her role was non-pr
and the lynch could have proven/disproven myuser's cop claim.
thought this was obvious, but then myuser ragequit and town decided to unvote and let things stall
is this sufficient answer or am i still "dodging"
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Well I don't really see how this was obvious at all but that's just my opinion I guess.
Still the next point being that you are conflicting yourself with your answers. You were willing to risk lynching a town-sided person to prove/disprove a cop claim, yet you say you won't confirm nor deny Desserns claim. Why? If you were fine with caff being lynched to prove a cop claim why aren't you fine with roleclaiming? Because this time we don't need to kill someone in order to prove dess's cop claim.
I guess you're claiming Vanilla Towny then? Since Dessern called you a vanilla Towny. And if you're not a Vanilla Towny then Dess would be lying in which case you'd be voting him or pointing out that hes lying. And since you're not voting him I guess we can assume that hes speaking the truth. Also this means Dess is claiming rolecop.
unvote
Thanks, that was all I wanted to hear as an answer, it really wasn't that hard to just answer.
Still the next point being that you are conflicting yourself with your answers. You were willing to risk lynching a town-sided person to prove/disprove a cop claim, yet you say you won't confirm nor deny Desserns claim. Why? If you were fine with caff being lynched to prove a cop claim why aren't you fine with roleclaiming? Because this time we don't need to kill someone in order to prove dess's cop claim.
I guess you're claiming Vanilla Towny then? Since Dessern called you a vanilla Towny. And if you're not a Vanilla Towny then Dess would be lying in which case you'd be voting him or pointing out that hes lying. And since you're not voting him I guess we can assume that hes speaking the truth. Also this means Dess is claiming rolecop.
unvote
I'm still totally unsatisfied with User's defense, first is was "Caff confirmed mafia" than I brought up the possibility of trying to bait a cc cop, than all of the sudden we get that cc who coincidentally claims to have had no result, than we offer up Caff as a sacrificial lamb to settle the matter than just drop it like it never happened today? A doc died, the inn keeper died, we can't trust the cops anymore. Frankly this whole game is going to hell and I don't know how we're going to get back on our feet. I think today's FOS should be one of the cops so we can sort this whole thing out because I doubt that both of them are guilty but I'm certain one is scum.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Just mostly people that are dead. And the rest is possibly reading/preparing a post or doesn't have time to post.
Also, nowhere did Dessern actually say what kind of cop he was. So it doesn't exactly conflict with his previous claim.
Also, nowhere did Dessern actually say what kind of cop he was. So it doesn't exactly conflict with his previous claim.
Well this is a bit of a start to a new day. Time to gather thoughts.
So about 4 pages worth of stuff in just the first 12 hours of night ending, most of it seems at least semi-aggressive (the bit between hunter and notty being the most notable initially).
I'm a little concerned in that I can see a few people who have posted today just rushing through their posts without thinking, or even reading, all of what has been said. I could take the time to try and point out specific people, but it is still early in the day and I'd rather give em time to say a bit more first.
Between Dess and Myuser, it seems more likely that Myuser is paranoid/insane and that Dess is more likely to be a sane cop, though it's hard to make a concrete judgement based on how many variables there could be. Also, I am also interested to see if Dess confirms/denies him being a role cop instead of a normal cop.
These are my more solid thoughts about how today has gone so far, I'll post more thoughts later when I can.
So about 4 pages worth of stuff in just the first 12 hours of night ending, most of it seems at least semi-aggressive (the bit between hunter and notty being the most notable initially).
I'm a little concerned in that I can see a few people who have posted today just rushing through their posts without thinking, or even reading, all of what has been said. I could take the time to try and point out specific people, but it is still early in the day and I'd rather give em time to say a bit more first.
Between Dess and Myuser, it seems more likely that Myuser is paranoid/insane and that Dess is more likely to be a sane cop, though it's hard to make a concrete judgement based on how many variables there could be. Also, I am also interested to see if Dess confirms/denies him being a role cop instead of a normal cop.
Sorry, did I miss something here or are you just assuming/know that gmk has a special role? (I may have missed something since gmk hasn't posted a lot).
These are my more solid thoughts about how today has gone so far, I'll post more thoughts later when I can.
...I'm not seeing your logic here. Traditionally, in setups with a modified cop, the other is sane. You're saying that because one cop may have a negative modifier, so must the other one? Frankly, this just doesn't make any sense to me.
I was going to point this out as soon as I got caught up ;-;
Perhaps not that it was conflicting, but I was going to point it out nonetheless.
I don't know if it was Ooglie or not. It was an anonymous message just like the one shortly after the start of today.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
It doesn't make too much sense no, but on IRC mafia setups with a paranoid cop tended to have insane cops aswell I believe. Which is what I thought about when I wrote it. But I guess you're right since a paranoid one and a normal one make sense aswell.
Either way it doesn't really matter anymore, since I don't think insane rolecops exist. And rolecop is what dess is claiming appearently.
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 255, 255)]Vote Count - I accidentally made the background text color white[/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 255, 255)]Myusername22 - 1 - (Iggy234) [12 more][/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 255, 255)]Iggy234 - 1 - (Raxo2222) [12 more][/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 255, 255)]With 24 alive it'll take 13 to lynch and 12 to no-lynch.[/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 255, 255)]Myusername22 - 1 - (Iggy234) [12 more][/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 255, 255)]Iggy234 - 1 - (Raxo2222) [12 more][/BCOLOR]
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 255, 255)]With 24 alive it'll take 13 to lynch and 12 to no-lynch.[/BCOLOR]
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
If there is truely a Mafia poisoner, someone is going to die exactly 11 hours from this post. Incase that's me I'll just tell my action right now.
Last night I gave an item to Tim. And no, I have no idea what the item does. I only have the name which I won't share unless Tim/Oak wants to share it.
Last night I gave an item to Tim. And no, I have no idea what the item does. I only have the name which I won't share unless Tim/Oak wants to share it.
Good question! I've avoided it because investigating cop cc's isnt recommended in any setup. I'm going to try not to do it.
If you were asking about the hypothetical situation I would probably receive a role the next morning, assuming I'm insane and dess were Innocent I'd get a guilty report. If dess were mafia I expect I would get an innocent report. Just assuming the logic of an insane cop, I have no clue if anything special would happen I already told you everything I know about my role yesterday.
- Status