Supernatural Hotel [Finished]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mmarz11

Former AoD Dev
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
431
Reaction score
539
Alright I am going to say this now, I lied about being a non-regular guest. I wanted to see if anyone would pretend to be a regular guest or if there would merely be three claiming. This is also why I suggested the cop should investigate the people that have claimed to be a regular guest due to one of the four having lied. At least one of these four have lied about being a regular guest. My guess would be there just being one person.

Everyone should be suspicious of @Ltin @Ooglie101 @HypeBurst and @cooliorules. Out of the four I think Ooglie101 is the odd one out. Naturally you should also be susicious of myself but lynch me, kill me, investigate me if you please but you'll see that I am telling the truth.

So... who is lying?
 

Enderfive

sarcasm incarnate
Mafia Host
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4,802
Alright I am going to say this now, I lied about being a non-regular guest. I wanted to see if anyone would pretend to be a regular guest or if there would merely be three claiming. This is also why I suggested the cop should investigate the people that have claimed to be a regular guest due to one of the four having lied. At least one of these four have lied about being a regular guest. My guess would be there just being one person.

Everyone should be suspicious of @Ltin @Ooglie101 @HypeBurst and @cooliorules. Out of the four I think Ooglie101 is the odd one out. Naturally you should also be susicious of myself but lynch me, kill me, investigate me if you please but you'll see that I am telling the truth.

So... who is lying?
...

Gee, thanks.
 

Ansoro2112

Hottie
Joined
Jan 23, 2012
Messages
3,405
Reaction score
4,133
Alright I am going to say this now, I lied about being a non-regular guest. I wanted to see if anyone would pretend to be a regular guest or if there would merely be three claiming. This is also why I suggested the cop should investigate the people that have claimed to be a regular guest due to one of the four having lied. At least one of these four have lied about being a regular guest. My guess would be there just being one person.

Everyone should be suspicious of @Ltin @Ooglie101 @HypeBurst and @cooliorules. Out of the four I think Ooglie101 is the odd one out. Naturally you should also be susicious of myself but lynch me, kill me, investigate me if you please but you'll see that I am telling the truth.

So... who is lying?
Like I said. Never trust anyone in this game. People has their own reason to do what they do.

I knew I shouldn't never trust those claims. Who's the crazy guy now?

Now, lets see who's the one lying. I'll wait for those 4 to talk.
 

Enderfive

sarcasm incarnate
Mafia Host
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4,802
Like I said. Never trust anyone in this game. People has their own reason to do what they do.

I knew I shouldn't never trust those claims. Who's the crazy guy now?

Now, lets see who's the one lying. I'll wait for those 4 to talk.
That doesn't make you any less suspicious, because at the time of you making that post, it was still complete nonsense.
 

Ansoro2112

Hottie
Joined
Jan 23, 2012
Messages
3,405
Reaction score
4,133
You do realize that you could have just claimed guest and then we would have seen there were five claimed guests, then it would be obvious someone was lying.

So, since I would like to see what the other 4 guests have to say,

Unvote
Not really. Because if Mafia or Third Party would've seen that those 4 roles were already claimed they would've probably just claimed PR. I think Mmraz wanted to claim PR and see if Mafia/Third Party was going to fall into the trap and claim Regular Guest since there was one person that didn't claim it.
 

Ltin

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
951
Reaction score
1,481
Like I said. Never trust anyone in this game. People has their own reason to do what they do.

I knew I shouldn't never trust those claims. Who's the crazy guy now?

Now, lets see who's the one lying. I'll wait for those 4 to talk.
What exactly am I supposed to say? It not like any claims have been brought against anyone, just a cc, directed at 4 people.
 

cooliorules

That Awkward Noodle
Donor
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
1,512
Reaction score
2,478
and mafia preferring to go for the PRs.
How do you know the mafia would prefer going for the power roles?

And to address Ansoro's cop outing:
Why would we do that? The mafia has a role blocker (the hooker) and if we said "oh this is the cop blah blah blah" then unless we kill the damned hooker, we will get no where. No where at all. The hooker would obviously go and block our last cop, it would make sense for them to do that, would it not?
Now, people are saying "oh the cop is being served on a silver platter to the mafia"
Have we forgotten about the doc?!

Anyway, ansoro has come back to life as the usual defence as he normally is, but I'm still suspicious of him. Heck, I was both the other seasons I've played.


Sorry if any of this has been said, I'm at school in class and trying to catch up
 

digi

-
Donor
Contributor
Joined
Sep 15, 2011
Messages
961
Reaction score
2,827
Alright I am going to say this now, I lied about being a non-regular guest. I wanted to see if anyone would pretend to be a regular guest or if there would merely be three claiming. This is also why I suggested the cop should investigate the people that have claimed to be a regular guest due to one of the four having lied. At least one of these four have lied about being a regular guest. My guess would be there just being one person.

Everyone should be suspicious of @Ltin @Ooglie101 @HypeBurst and @cooliorules. Out of the four I think Ooglie101 is the odd one out. Naturally you should also be susicious of myself but lynch me, kill me, investigate me if you please but you'll see that I am telling the truth.

So... who is lying?
I'm definitely suspicious of the following four that claimed to be guests. I know for certain that one is lying. In my experience playing with these four I have to narrow it down to @HypeBurst, @Ooglie101 and @Ltin. There's something about Coolio (and I'm not trying to sound offensive) who doesn't emit tactical planning.
 

myusername22

A username.
Donor
Joined
Dec 17, 2012
Messages
858
Reaction score
937
Alright I am going to say this now, I lied about being a non-regular guest. I wanted to see if anyone would pretend to be a regular guest or if there would merely be three claiming. This is also why I suggested the cop should investigate the people that have claimed to be a regular guest due to one of the four having lied. At least one of these four have lied about being a regular guest. My guess would be there just being one person.

Everyone should be suspicious of @Ltin @Ooglie101 @HypeBurst and @cooliorules. Out of the four I think Ooglie101 is the odd one out. Naturally you should also be susicious of myself but lynch me, kill me, investigate me if you please but you'll see that I am telling the truth.

So... who is lying?
@Mmarz11 what did you think you would gain by lying?
why didn't you tell us earlier when we asked if anyone lying could come clean then (or before)?
why should we trust you?

To me this looks like it could more easily be an attempt to screw up the 4 confirmed innocents we had and of the 5 we need to pick among you're the only one who has both changed their story and openly lied to use, so I'm honestly finding it hard to pick among anyone other than yourself.
 

Mmarz11

Former AoD Dev
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
431
Reaction score
539
@Mmarz11 what did you think you would gain by lying?
why didn't you tell us earlier when we asked if anyone lying could come clean then (or before)?
why should we trust you?

To me this looks like it could more easily be an attempt to screw up the 4 confirmed innocents we had and of the 5 we need to pick among you're the only one who has both changed their story and openly lied to use, so I'm honestly finding it hard to pick among anyone other than yourself.
I felt that by lying about being a regular guest might cause a mafia or third party to claim to be a regular guest. If I were to have claimed regular guest then they may not have claimed it due to there being four people or another person claims it after there being four causing suspicion on everyone which is not something they would want. I also feel that by lying that if someone were to try and kill a power role by killing me then they would have wasted an opportunity to kill one and would also cause there to be suspicion on the four claimed as well. Also, it is possible that a town power role claimed to be a regular guest as to avoid getting lynched/killed. However I think it is more likely that a mafia or third party is claiming. By doing this there is maybe one mafia or third party in a group of five for people to go through rather than trying to figure out through the remaining nineteen.

I wanted to see more on how events would unfold. Based on what people were saying I thought it would be better for me to say it now rather than waiting for another day to do so. I had considered not saying anything about lying until later on. I felt that although I don't have any abilities I would be able to cause the mafia or third party to waste a kill by thinking they would be getting rid of a power role instead of actually being a regular guest. I had also tried to get the cop to investigate the four claimed because I knew that one of them was lying. If the cop investigated everyone and is sane then three would come up as innocent and the last might be guilty or innocent depending on who the odd one out is. If the cop investigated everyone and is paranoid then three would come up as guilty and the last would be innocent or supernatural. This would allow us to know what type of cop the cop is and might also determine who the odd one out is. I also thought it would be better for the cop to be going through a small group of players instead of going through everyone and possibly keep on picking one side causing them to think they were one way or the other. If the cop kept on getting innocent then they might be sane and picking all of the town or they might be getting lucky and getting the mafia and then if someone doesn't fit what the cop had previously investigated then they might get killed due to it even if they aren't mafia or third party. I was trying to get this to happen and remain in a position that causes mafia or third party to waste a kill. By killing me people may have then realized that one of the four has to have been lying and would have suspicions on them.

I see no reason for you to trust me and I am not going to try and make you not lynch me or whatever you wish to do. Even if I am killed then it will be revealed that I was telling the truth and that at least one of the four is not who they say they are. You would also be losing a regular guest role which matters little compared to the other roles. So trust me or don't; I couldn't care less.

Also, I was already claimed as a non-regular guest role, why would I come out and say that I lied just to have suspicion put immediately on myself? I see no reason for a mafia or third party to blatantly put themselves in harms way just to cause suspicion on four people.

I felt that it would be a good idea but perhaps in the end I was merely a fool. Regardless, it has happened now and we'll just have to see where this goes.
 

Jeercrul

Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2012
Messages
343
Reaction score
502
Alright I am going to say this now, I lied about being a non-regular guest. I wanted to see if anyone would pretend to be a regular guest or if there would merely be three claiming. This is also why I suggested the cop should investigate the people that have claimed to be a regular guest due to one of the four having lied. At least one of these four have lied about being a regular guest. My guess would be there just being one person.

Everyone should be suspicious of @Ltin @Ooglie101 @HypeBurst and @cooliorules. Out of the four I think Ooglie101 is the odd one out. Naturally you should also be susicious of myself but lynch me, kill me, investigate me if you please but you'll see that I am telling the truth.

So... who is lying?
I personally do not see a point in stirring the waters to create more confusion. Especially while there is the whole notty debate and ansoro debate going on. It personally seems like an opportunity taken to divert attention off notty and ansoro, and it doesn't not help in making them seem less suspicious to me at all now.

Anyway, it doesn't hurt to lynch one or two Regular Guests that person us someone who can only create more confusion which isn't something I like to see. Even if you were telling the truth, how can we know you won't lie next time? We have no absolute idea whether you are that is, a MAFIA or simply a Regular Guest. Lynching you won't let us have a higher or lower chance of losing our power roles seeing how we already have four people singled out.

I also don't see why you would have to drag Ooglie in, and how he is the odd one out, without any proper explanation. Care to explain to us?

Thus,
Unvote
Vote Mmarz11

If you are truly a Regular Guest, we can then have 3 people singled out to find who the scum is in 1 of the 3. If you aren't, well, I know who to divert my attention to afterwards. It's an advantageous situation in both cases. Call me sadistic for doing this, call me scummy, but I honestly see this more beneficial than lynching Ansoro or Notty. That being said, Ansoro and Notty still aren't off my FOS. I just find you scummiest atm.
 

Jeercrul

Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2012
Messages
343
Reaction score
502
How do you know the mafia would prefer going for the power roles?
Considering how mafia's true aim is to win the game, it would be a better choice to eliminate people who pose the biggest threat to them in the game. That also means eliminating the PRs who have a greater chance of killing them or stirring up undesirable situations for them, as compared to the Regular Guests.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top