1. I'm very surprised Mafia would get rid of Inffy. It was quite obvious at the end of day zero after Inffy claimed Hermit that he was third-party. What I'm trying to say here is, I'm confused why Mafia would kill someone who's already suspicious and adding chaos into the game when chaos would actually be in their favour. I hope I'm not overthinking it, but whatever it is, it seems to me that there's some motive behind it. Either that or there's some other party which killed him to begin with. The latter possibility I cannot substantiate or overrule because I have no information.
I also found this weird, the most possible solution I could see to this, is that notty is mafia, figured they were dead either way, and wanted to get rid of someone that would be valuable to town, even though inffy dying after they arguing would be really suspicous, but mafia went, hey, fuck it.
Another solution, is that the mafia wanted to get rid of inffy, as he seemed to want to help town as a third party, similar to me, and they figured that killing him would throw a lot of supicion on (innocent) notty.
I did not bother discussing this much, as the bandawagon for notty seemed too strong to derail, even with stuff we concider here. I do really like looking into lynches though.
The HK lynch was an obvious one, strong town role that outed.
2. Notty also didn't die N1. I'm still pretty suspicious of her, not to mention now that from the two people who have died we can more or less affirm that alignment is based off on tarot card readings (I.e. Emperor was Town and Hermit was Third-party). So pretty much at this point given how negative Notty's card implies I would say its still best to vote her.
I would say yes, for any other tarrot card. We do not know the extent of the towers, it symbolizes change, but a destructive change. Having her card saying changes that happen, as a town sided, is not too far out in the woods. If it was the devil, sure.
Notty not dying n1 could be because they only have 2 kills (I am assuming mafia were both kills, or mafia/vig) and they prioritized Inffy, hoping we would kill notty. If notty is innocent, I could easily see her dying n1 and n2, but it could also be that they think we will lynch her, or maybe they just like the confusion.
And of course, it can be as I said in the first thing above, notty is maf, no point killing maf.
3. I'm don't know what's going on with this "Choco lynch" thing, but I'm going to set my boundaries right now. Assuming that there are at most seven people who are Mafia, and since it takes eleven votes to lynch, nine is going to be my tipping point for me to claim my role. But of course I don't hope that will happen.
This comes from one post you made, which several people called scummy. After that, you have as far as I can tell, been completely silent. Not responding is not good.
4. Can we not base our lynches off previous games? Extrapolating games from one end to the other just seems pointless and I think it'd be more beneficial for town to just use the current information available. This is probably going to make me sound really scummy, and could even get lynch votes, but I just have to put this out here.
Mostly agree, but sometimes its relevant information, that are available to be checked up.
P.S. I still feel that Notty is Mafia or third-party, leaning towards Mafia. There's a lot of stuff going on now, and I'm still sort of confused. But logically speaking I think I can slightly trust Aqua and maybe Danni the most?
I am feeling about the same (except the part where you colored my name red to make me seem scum.), I think aqua is playing the game annoyingly and badly, but I dont neccesarily think he is wrong about notty.
I still want to lynch notty tomorrow, not today. You will notice that I am not saying that notty is innocent, however, its important to not tunnel vission on one thing, and concider different options.
As I stated early in the day, if we can not find, or agree on a better option, by all means, lynch notty. I have said this from pretty early on in the day; I think it would be stupid to end the day straight away without exploring both notty, and other people deeper. It seems we are at a standstill with notty, no more discussion there.
Which leads us to other lynch targets, current suggested are as far as I can tell, mostly you choco, and aqua, I would have been happy with lynching you, but your post is very well written, and makes sense. I honestly think aqua is some town role, with at least a semi important ability, so I am running out of options of other people we can lynch.
I wont be leading any campaignes for other lynches. Neither you or Aqua will gain traction. I still think its stupid to lynch notty today, when we can tomorrow, but a no lynch would be even more stupid.
If anyone has any other people to suggest, go ahead.
Notty you should probably be more active if you dont want to die.
For now, I dont see anything else we can agree on than killing notty, sadly.
Retract vote
