Why not?I do not agree with a massclaim of names
I think it might benefit Anti-town rolesWhy not?
And have you made Notty your target?
And if it's successful, does notty/jivvi's role still appear on their death, or will it be gone, and thus that will be an indicator that it worked?
Not just way easier, but it actually makes it possibleRegarding claiming names and such, benefit of claiming names: way easier to lynch people.
I dont see a reason it would not, you could probably even vote Danni122112, just no one would be lynched at the required amount of votes. Seems to be the most logical way to do it at least, imoI wonder if voting Aqua appears on the votecount
Unvote
Vote Aqua
Do you not think the benefit of us being able to actually lynch people we find suspicious outweighs the negative consequence of mafia being able to know who to target?I think it might benefit Anti-town roles
NottyKitten is my target (im assuming that is Jivvi?)
I don't know?
Well, we can still lynch some people, its just that or possible targets are limited to those who we know.Not just way easier, but it actually makes it possible
Which is either HKCaper, who I'd actually be OK with lynching tbh (anyone else feel this way?), you (again I'd be OK lynching), or Jivvi (who I'm not OK with lynching)Well, we can still lynch some people, its just that or possible targets are limited to those who we know.
Ok so if someone dies, we can no longer vote for themyes, however, voting for Inffy and Unu voting for Aqua didn't
I read it but I didn't realize he missed out some people's votes in that votecountWas nobody actually reading the thread and Ender saying how it was disrespectful to vote for corpses??? Enderfive I just want you to know i appreciate you <3
Also in this situation the Mafia not having a different name would mean noone else can be called them since otherwise they'd be untargetable, which means it'd make no sense to risk a 50/50 lynch with unu hammering since they could just suss out who has the name of one of them and the other is Mafia and so they'd lynch that name and it'd be an easy winThe only thing I can think of is that it'd be useful in a late-game cc'd name scenario, where two people have claimed the same name and town want to lynch one of them but can't decide who's lying
Say the alive players are Arelic, Jivvi, Inf, Oog, Notty, and Unu
And Arelic and Notty claim to be rolename Jivvi, and the Mafia is lying and doesn't actually have a name
We could make the votecount this
Jivvi - Inf, Oog, Jivvi (3/6)
Then have Unu vote for Arelic, and if Arelic survives, Notty is the real Jivvi, because otherwise Arelic would have 4/6 votes, so they can know that Arelic is lying and isn't Jivvi and lynch Arelic
But that'd be a 50/50 shot at mislynching and it just seems like such an unlikely and pointless scenario that it surely can't be the point of his role, and it would only ever happen if Mafia weren't given a different name, which I think is unlikely considering the info we have right now
Are you fucking high, voting Aqua lynches whoever has the role Aqua, if you want to vote for me vote 112We could however vote for Aqua, which means voting Aqua isn't voting someone who dies, which means lynching Aqua still lynches Danni